4 ms·
> Calling out the BTC network on its energetic inefficiency completely misses the point that the work put into the network is exactly the scarce digital asset,
by tsimionescu 6y ago
> Calling out the BTC network on its energetic inefficiency completely misses the point that the work put into the network is exactly the scarce digital asset, and hence the store of value.
Why would that matter? The problem is the huge amount of greenhouse gases getting released because of this store of value. Whether it makes some economic sense or not is irrelevant to the discussion of whether it should be allowed to continue on environmental grounds.
- CryptoUnchained 6y agoYou're so angry about the greenhouse gases that you're completely missing the logic behind an energy currency. You complain that the energy and dollars are spent speculating because you're flat out ignoring that miners are re-investing their profits to become more efficient and productive. Bitcoin mining is a rat race to develop efficiency in technology and energy deliverance. Oil companies capturing the wasted natural gas, Hydro dams capturing the wasted water energy, etc. Bitcoin is a battery or energy credit where areas with abundant energy can benefit from their standing in the world and benefit the people of the region. Bitcoin has its ebbs and flows but eventually balances to where your typical american household cannot afford to mine bitcoin and profit.
- tsimionescu 6y ago> Bitcoin mining is a rat race to develop efficiency in technology and energy deliverance. The cloud computing companies and EV companies and every other company that spends large amounts of its budget on buying electricity is doing the same thing. The difference is that (at least some of) cloud computing or driving is doing useful work with the energy being consumed, whereas 100% of energy going into bitcoin mining is simply getting converted to bitcoin, a speculative asset, and heat. And the greenhouse gases are the largest problem the civilized world has ever faced, they are not some small aside. We need to figure out ways to produce less energy while still powering the important parts of our economy (transport, production of goods, research etc). Bitcoin is doing the opposite - it is creating a need for more energy production to create and exchange money, when we already have much more efficient ways of creating and exchanging money (the whole banking infrastructure of the world consumes less electrical energy than bitcoin, while doing orders of magnitude more transactions per second than bitcoin can hande in a year).
- yownie 6y ago>doing useful work with the energy yea is video games useful work? youtube videos perhaps? twitter? It's nice that you have a sliding scale of what utility is that only you can define, you seem completely trustworthy.
- tsimionescu 6y agoArt and entertainment are useful work, yes, obviously. But it is true and I pointed that out that there is a lot of waste going on in the cloud as well.
- yownie 6y ago>Art and entertainment are useful work, yes, obviously. why?
- tsimionescu 6y agoBecause they bring enjoyment to people, and all that truly matters is the happiness of people. Money is only useful in so far as it can buy the things that people need, but making those things still requires energy in addition to money. Burning energy to make money when you can literary just will money into existence is completely absurd.
- inter_netuser 6y agoThe US just printed in one month the entire amount of dollars in existence prior to 2013. Should Bitcoin allow USD to continue? We will see.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThat you don't care to understand how and why the global monetary system works is not an excuse to start believing in "digital gold". There are good reasons why bad ideas, such as limited supplies of currency, have been abandoned. The huge problems of the monetary system lie more in the direction of Bitcoin (the unbridled speculation of Wall Street) than fractional reserve banking and fiat money.
- inter_netuser 6y agoWhat are the most important properties/goals of Bitcoin, in your view? I am genuinely interested in your view. The attitude on this forum towards Bitcoin literally boggles my mind, at most maybe 5% truly understand it.
- tsimionescu 6y agoFixed supply, algorithmic cryptographic validation of transactions, psuedonimity, no centralized control by a human-like entity. Each of these turns out to be a net-negative in my view: - fixed supply means that people are incentivized to hold bitcoin instead of spending/investing - algorithmic transactions mean that there is no way to reverse a mistaken transaction or a fraud; it also means that losing the key to your wallet is irreversible destruction of the money contained in that wallet - pseudonimity means that it is very hard to track money laundering and other illegal financial schemes - lack of centralized control enforces all of the others and makes it impossible to prop up the currency based on the current needs of the economy I also understand the distrust of fractional-reserve banking and most complicated financial manipulations, and I wouldn't deny in any way that these have been misused very often at the benefit of the rich and powerful. But, at least with the current system, citizens have some amount of democratic control over their financial system, which they wouldn't in a pure Bitcoin world.
- CryptoUnchained 6y ago2 things are about to happen in the bitcoin space. The size of transistor in the bitcoin miners is hitting a wall. The bitcoin market will either drive alternative energy efficiency in the chase of profits, or it will drive new technologies to lower the node size. Both will be a benefit to mankind.
- kybernetikos 6y agoPoW is voracious. There is no limit to how much energy that the bitcoin network will consume. As you add more computation to the network, the computation requirement to create new blocks grows. You could invent a dramatically more efficient way to calculate hashes - after a short period of readjustment, the network would go back to consuming just as much power as it does now. You could find a way of generating power more cheaply. The network will then use much more of it. Energy requirements continue to grow until an equilibrium is reached. That equilibrium occurs when the energy cost to mine new blocks is commensurate with the value received from doing so. However, miners who can externalise their energy costs will generally outcompete miners who cannot. Incentives to damage the environment and avoid taking resposnibility are built into the system.
- tsimionescu 6y agoOr, much more likely, they will stagnate on those technologies and instead will drive the price of electricity up, hurting mankind greatly. Transistor density and energy efficiency are not niche problems that no one cared enough about to throw money on before bitcoin came along, they are some of the hottest areas of research from some of the largest companies in the world, from Apple itself to Amazon, Intel, AMD, Nvidia, Qualcomm, Microsoft, Huawei and many others.
- yownie 6y ago>The problem is the huge amount of greenhouse gases getting Really, you mean the huge amount of greenhouse gases we release here in Iceland where our energy is entirely from renewable sources and we mine 11% of the bitcoin network?
- tsimionescu 6y agoWhy not sell that energy to other countries then, or put it to use to produce goods and services that people need? Maybe move a data center from a more polluting country to Iceland? There are many things that people actually need which could be done with that energy, but that would probably bring less money than burning it away on Bitcoin. And make no mistake, these things are still being done, just soemwhere else in the world with more polluting energy. The energy supply of the world is limited, so mobile use cases will often move around.
- mr_woozy 6y agolooked at a map lately?
- tsimionescu 6y agoIt could be an opportunity to invest in new mechanisms of power distribution, and be on the forefront of research in this area. It could also find more productive uses of this electricity, such as supercomputing clusters or lasers used for research.
- yownie 6y agoWe are located too far from major client population centers for any Data hosting to make sense, you'd always deal with higher latency to either the US or European users vs hosting in those places. Few submarine cable connections (which cost hundreds of millions to run) mean high data costs versus well connected cities such as Hamburg or London or NYC. You do realize that transmitting power via cable means moving it through large bodies of salt water (the ocean) that contribute to huge losses in EMF resistance. Not to mention a power cable from Iceland to anywhere else in the world would be 2x as long as the longest power transmission ever created. It's more scary for me to realize you actually have no productive ideas for a country that mines BTC from renewables but STILL think you're insights are correct. Did you know what we do with the electricity here before mining was popular? Alcoa Aluminum smelting, Ever check out the environmental impact on smelting?