4 ms·
I think this is a very bad comparison, for several reasons. 1. With the Apollo missions, the money being put into the project was going into research and devel
by tsimionescu 6y ago
I think this is a very bad comparison, for several reasons.
1. With the Apollo missions, the money being put into the project was going into research and development, so there was at least some expectation of getting new science and technology out of it. With Bitcoin,nthe money put in is going into speculation or mining, which only fuels the network. There is no reason to expect new technologies to come out of this, and certainly not any new science.
2. The Apollo project was a big consumer of money, of which there exist plenty in the world and we can create more. Bitcoin is a huge consumer of electricity, the production of which is generally accelerating global warming, the single biggest threat to our survival as a civilized society that has ever existed in history.
We already know that Bitcoin itself is not even remotely close to being a solution to the problem you're thinking about (decentralized money), even IF I agreed that this is a real problem (I don't, I believe Bitcoin is going in the wrong direction compared to fiat money). You could make a decent argument for investing in developing scalable crypto coins, maybe Ethereum or maybe something else, but proof-of-work crypocoins and Bitcoin in particular are an obvious dead end, and can be decommissioned entirely without much loss (especially if the bitcoin holders were compensated somehow).
- Koiwai 6y agoFor #1, there is no actual evidence to counter that, but, the logic doesn't stand either, just, why not? https://twitter.com/id_aa_carmack/status/1348094702550216707 https://twitter.com/id_aa_carmack/status/1348094702550216707
- shawnz 6y ago> There is no reason to expect new technologies to come out of this, and certainly not any new science Proof-of-stake coins are one obvious counterexample. Would proof-of-stake technologies have been developed if proof-of-work didn't come along first to incentivise development and build trust in cryptocurrencies?
- tsimionescu 6y agoProof-of-stake is not an iteration on proof-of-work, it is a lateral idea. There is no reason why the first popular crypto-coin wouldn't have been proof-of-stake, except that it didn't occur to Satoshi (or it did and they didn't like it for other reasons).
- shawnz 6y agoFirstly that's not completely true: proof-of-stake doesn't solve the initial wealth distribution problem so often proof-of-work is still necessary in some capacity even in proof-of-stake coins. Furthermore it's possible that a purely proof-of-stake currency would have never gained the widespread trust that proof-of-work did at a time when cryptocurrencies were a new idea. Or maybe not... but people did have ideas about proof-of-stake quite early on and it took much longer for those ideas to gain the same level of acceptance that proof-of-work did.
- tsimionescu 6y agoInventing the technology and getting it adopted are two different things. For example, I happen to believe that decentralized coins are a horrible idea in and of themselves, even without proof-of-work also helping to increase global warming. So, from my point of view, any adoption of a crypto-currency is a net-negative, and I would be happy to know that the technology exists, but is staying abandoned as long as we have no use for it other than non-centralized money.
- shawnz 6y ago> I happen to believe that decentralized coins are a horrible idea in and of themselves, even without proof-of-work Sure, but that is a much different argument than proof-of-stake vs proof-of-work. With the assumption that having a successful proof-of-stake cryptocurrency is a net good, then what I am saying is maybe our usages of proof-of-work up until the future widespread adoption of proof-of-stake actually will contribute more positively to that end than negatively.
- 6y ago
- CryptoUnchained 6y ago1. Bitcoin mining is a race to cheap power, it's of course going to lead to more efficient power delivery technologies. Excess energy being created by hydrodams is being sold to fund infrastructure and to subsidize energy costs during dry seasons. Oil companies are capturing energy once wasted: https://news.bitcoin.com/bitcoin-helps-oil-companies-reduce-carbon-footprint/ https://news.bitcoin.com/bitcoin-helps-oil-companies-reduce-... Bitcoin is an energy currency.
- lottin 6y ago> Bitcoin is an energy currency. Not a currency, but a digital asset that wastes enormous amounts of energy.
- inter_netuser 6y agoLast year it transacted more than a trillion dollars in transactions. It's in the top 20 or so of world currencies, and it's still in its infancy (thus volatility etc).
- lottin 6y agoSardines were also involved in transactions amounting trillions of dollars, but that doesn't mean sardines are a currency.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- blindgeek 6y ago"It's in the top 20 or so of world currencies, and it's still in its infancy (thus volatility etc)." My question, then, is how do we go about drowning Baby Bitcoin in the metaphorical bathtub?
- CryptoUnchained 6y agoWastes enormous amounts of energy... The energy is literally being stored in the value of bitcoin. It's an energy credit. People are transforming excess electricity into bitcoin. Period. What do I do with my profits from mining bitcoin? Send my kids to college, buy groceries, remodel my bathroom, etc. It's an entire ecosystem, speculatively mining bitcoin by consuming electricity is just as evil as driving 1.5hrs to work because you're too lazy to find something near your house for example. People expend trillions of dollars in energy "mining" fiat.
- primitivesuave 6y agoYou make a very compelling argument, especially #1 that there can't be an expectation of any new technology or science to come out of money spent on speculation or mining. Equivalently, any progress in blockchain technology doesn't require the existence of the Bitcoin network to be implemented. I now see some holes in my Apollo analogy (also government vs individual spending). I am lucky there is always someone on HN who will make a better point :)
- shawnz 6y agoI actually think there is an expectation that increased trust/acceptance in Bitcoin will help the success of future improved cryptocurrency technologies. Bitcoin gives users a trustworthy decentralized store of value today that they could easily move to another cryptocurrency in future using some kind of decentralized exchange based on smart contracts. It provides liquidity for all future cryptocurrencies.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThat is a different argument than the comparison with the Apollo mission, and entirely relies on believing that the end-goal itself, a crypto-currency based financial system, is a net good in itself. The Apollo argument was more compelling because it didn't require any value-judgement of the end-goal (but it was less appealing to me for the reasons I outlined). It is an argument about the process, regardless of the results (in the end, the lunar landings in themselves were a symbolic victory more than any great advancement of science - the science happened on the way). We can go into arguments on why I think the end-goal of crypto-currency believers a la Satoshi would be a net negative, but others have covered it pretty well (deflation, fraud, money laundering, having your life savings destroyed by a hack etc).
- thejynxed 6y agoTo a point, but that trust by the public can be easily swayed and destroyed - see Biden pick Janet Yellen and her recent comments about how BTC is used for and good for nothing but criminal activity including that by state sponsors of terrorism.