4 ms·
I supported bitcoin when it first came out because I support the idea of decentralised, trustless money. Far too much money is redirected into the hands of fina
by globular-toast 6y ago
I supported bitcoin when it first came out because I support the idea of decentralised, trustless money. Far too much money is redirected into the hands of financial workers who are not adding any value to the economy. Finance is good and necessary, but the way it currently works is not.
But bitcoin simply does not work as money. There is really no doubt about this. Even the biggest proponents of bitcoin right now call it a "digital gold". But we don't need a digital gold. We have gold and gold has none of the same problems as money and is a far more stable storage of wealth. Today bitcoin proponents don't understand what Satoshi was trying to do. So I'm in agreement that this is all just a monstrous waste of resources at this point.
- john_alan 6y agoCompletely agree. The core tenet has been lost. Monero is closer to digital private money than anything else right now. And in my view, worth the cost of POW.
- knuthsat 6y agoYeah, although a bunch of work on Monero is still a result of work from people that worked on Bitcoin. There's some independent research there but AFAIK Bitcoin people did not stop working on confidential transactions or fungiblity. Just explaining that the core tenet was not lost, but that it was still not researched. Bitcoin jump started a research movement that reaped all kinds of cryptocurrency variants as time went on. https://electroneropulse.org/public/doc/Bulletproof%20RingCT.pdf https://electroneropulse.org/public/doc/Bulletproof%20RingCT... Here's a paper whose coauthors belong to the Bitcoin team discussing efficient confidential transactions that were eventually implemented in Monero (not by the Bitcoin team).
- jonhendry18 6y ago"Here's a paper whose coauthors belong to the Bitcoin team discussing efficient confidential transactions that were eventually implemented in Monero (not by the Bitcoin team)." The knowledge held by the Bitcoin team wouldn't disappear if Bitcoin was shut down. They could still contribute to other crypto projects.
- knuthsat 6y agoYes, but saying that the core tenet was lost is a bit dramatic. The guys working on it were still interested in other aspects of cryptocurrencies that bitcoin does not implement. Bulletproofs coming out in 2017 meant that Monero had inefficient fungibility and confidential transactions before, bloating the blockchain before they implemented bulletproofs. There's so much stuff that still had to be researched after Bitcoin came out. One big example that comes to mind is SegWit. The cryptography was still not there and I do not feel that something can be lost if it's not there.
- comboy 6y agoWe do need digital gold to be able to have market of cryptocurrencies that are actually in use and not just being speculated on with fiat. Sidechains enable that. The whole waste argument is ridiculous on so many levels. I imagine these people shouting at people houses - turn off that AC! You are wasting energy for which you have paid! We could have made so many aluminum cans with that! And if you say that sure, let's have digital gold, but not Bitcoin, let's use Foo. Then without sidechains all value in Bitcoin gets destroyed. And I assure that there will be Bar that's going to be pareto optimal to Foo. It just doesn't work. To have a currency, it needs to represent some value. If it's not coming from a government, then people must trust the value will stay there (there's almost always a lot of trust involved in our value assignments). Bitcoin is sooo far from perfect. But you can't have crypto future without it if you think long enough about it. Also on the long run, with everything being connected to the Internet and silicon being cheap, I think many heating elements will also be doing some computation. The fact that they are not - that is a waste.
- azernik 6y agoCutting down A/C usage is, in fact, an important climate change mitigation.
- comboy 6y agoClimate change doesn't care if I use my 1kWh for gaming on a console, using dryer, A/C or computing digits of pi which have already been computed because I wanted to do it on my super inefficient old computer. There are many ways to mitigate climate change but I don't think that telling people what should they do with electricity is the way to go. Perhaps focus more on how the energy gets produced, not how it is consumed.
- effie 6y ago> I don't think that telling people what should they do with electricity is the way to go. If the advice is sound, maybe we should be telling people about it. For example, we could recommend to replace cheap ineffective ACs with effective but expensive heat pumps and some small percentage of people will do that. But this won't do much to mitigate CO2 production. AC energy consumption isn't a major driver of CO2 pollution, fossil-fueled transport and coal/gas power plants are.
- herewegoagain2 6y agoExtracting gold is very wasteful, I'm not sure it is better than Bitcoin in terms of environmental impact. And Bitcoin is much more useful than gold. You can easily send Bitcoin to your family at the other end of the world. With gold, not so easy. Even buying and selling gold is much more difficult. Storing gold is also much more complicated, you can not encrypt gold, so you need physical protection.
- FranckLeroy 6y agoIt was 3 times more in 2018. It might be 20x more now : https://thenextweb.com/hardfork/2018/11/06/cryptocurrencies-bitcoin-energy-gold/ https://thenextweb.com/hardfork/2018/11/06/cryptocurrencies-...