6 ms·
One thing I haven't quite understood is why Netflix even bothers to encrypt the video streams. It seems like a waste of effort, since Netflix isn't exactly serv
by jiggawatts 6y ago
One thing I haven't quite understood is why Netflix even bothers to encrypt the video streams. It seems like a waste of effort, since Netflix isn't exactly serving content that would qualify as "secret". There's not even any porn on there, so it's not the biggest concern if someone were to find out what some people were watching. This data is being collected anyway via endpoint technologies like Samsung's Automated Content Recognition (ACR): https://www.samsung.com/us/business/samsungads/resources/tv-ad-retargeting/ https://www.samsung.com/us/business/samsungads/resources/tv-...
It seems like encrypting the video stream traffic at this kind of scale requires a substantial engineering effort and special hardware.
Encryption also means that shared downstream caches at ISPs can't do anything to reduce their bandwidth consumption. The only option is to contact Netflix and physically install one of their edge caching boxes.
Content tampering protection could be obtained by simply computing content hashes offline once, which the clients could verify.
- freedomben 6y agoI would guess it's for DRM.
- paulgdp 6y agoEncryption for DRM needs to happen only once per media, and then can be saved to storage and shared infinitely many times. So that's probably something else
- stock_toaster 6y agoMy guess would be to prevent middlebox fiddling. Such as an end user device asking for 4k, but a middlebox somewhere between the customer and Netflix inspecting the http content and blocking it (or modifying the client request in flight), because "only 480p allowed here" or something like that.
- mrpippy 6y agoUS cellular carriers do that by throttling bandwidth to the network ranges used by video providers
- jen20 6y agoI'd imagine the poor behaviour of ISPs (especially in the US) with regards to privacy is the reason. Deriving reported speeds for `fast.com` from the video sources was a masterstroke, too!
- drewg123 6y ago"This helps protect member privacy, particularly when the network is insecure — ensuring that our members are safe from eavesdropping by anyone who might want to record their viewing habits." from https://netflixtechblog.com/protecting-netflix-viewing-privacy-at-scale-39c675d88f45 https://netflixtechblog.com/protecting-netflix-viewing-priva...
- cperciva 6y agoCome on Drew, you know as well as I do that media can be unmasked via side channels if an attacker really cares.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoMaybe, but why make it easy?
- jabberwcky 6y agoAre you attacking him because he's using TLS? Will you ever be satisfied? TLS fixes a whole lot more than just privacy, it's also authenticating the remote end. Are we really suggesting dumping something that is trivially accelerated in hardware to do some homebrew crypto crap just for the sake of a forum thread? Netflix solution is fine, and the concentration of interest in TLS means it only gets cheaper over time to build Netflix-like configurations, which is especially great since we've spent the past decade or more trying to convince the entire industry this configuration is also best practice
- cperciva 6y agoI'm just pointing out that the privacy justification is nonsense. Protecting the integrity of connections? That's important. Preventing web browsers from throwing a fit about "insecure connections"? That's also important. But privacy isn't the issue here, and I've talked to enough people at Netflix to know that they know that too.
- bobthebuilders 6y ago
- toast0 6y agoWho's watching what is secret data and although it can be possible to extract that from packet sizes and duration of streaming, it's a lot easier to extract it from http paths. But, beyond that, the battle to use http when it makes sense has been lost. Modern platforms strongly encourage https and discourage http.
- ikawe 6y agoSure, things like ACR exist, it doesn't mean we should give up. Lots of people think "privacy mode" should be default for everything and isn't just for when you're watching porn.
- throwawayboise 6y ago> There's not even any porn on there, so it's not the biggest concern if someone were to find out what some people were watching. True there's no out-and-out porn, but there is content that's close to the line, and beyond that there are themes that could be indicators that a viewer is gay, or in some other demographic that he might want to keep private. Target can tell if you're pregnant based on your shopping; certainly there's a lot that can be inferred from the movies you watch.
- the-dude 6y ago> Target can tell if you're pregnant based on your shopping; I am very skeptical about that story, it sounds too good/scary to be true, and there is only 1 reported incident, without proper sources. Sounds made up to me. https://medium.com/@colin.fraser/target-didnt-figure-out-a-teen-girl-was-pregnant-before-her-father-did-a6be13b973a5 https://medium.com/@colin.fraser/target-didnt-figure-out-a-t...