6 ms·
The Rise and Fall of Bitcoin Billionaire Arthur Hayes
- maurodelazeri 6y agothis will go nowhere, as always
- josh2600 6y agoAmazing article and crazy story. Arthur was one of the most entertaining speakers in cryptocurrency; not an easy feat in a gallery of magicians, rogues, and exotic financiers. I have to wonder what the court case will ultimately shake out to be about. The most interesting part of this case is how the indictment differs from BTC-E and other organizations labeled as antithetical to the free world. I think there's two reads to it: either the fraud at BitMEX was so rampant and pervasive that taking the time to indict a particular instance of villainy was not in the interest of justice, or this was something else entirely more complicated. In either case the whole thing is fascinating. I, for one, cannot wait to see the court documents as they come out. I can only imagine that there will be a great many fireworks.
- jluxenberg 6y agoI think the indictment is straightforward: BitMEX provided banking services to US customers without implementing Know Your Customer and other required anti-money-laundering safeguards. Being a "fintech" product doesn't exempt an operator from the law: KYC is the law on the US. I'm surprised there haven't been more indictments, since I'm sure other exchanges have operated fast+loose w.r.t. AML and KYC
- jstanley 6y agoI don't know what you think BitMEX is, but I'm pretty sure they never offered banking services.
- jkhdigital 6y agoThe law covers commodity futures trading services as well, which is what the indictment cites as justification for holding them to the terms of the Banking Secrecy Act. The laws around KYC and AML are written for the traditional banking system, and are a bit nonsensical when applied to crypto. BitMEX deals only in Bitcoin, so it begs the question of how one could “launder” anything through it.
- josh2600 6y agoI think this is where it gets hairy: bitmex was 100% synthetic and denominated in btc. There’s no part of what they did that related to usd except that the trades were denominated in usd pricing, but all monetary flows in and out of the exchange were btc. It may be the case they the US has jurisdiction over US customers anywhere in the world even if they aren’t transacting in US dollars. I guess we’re going to find out? To be extra clear, it would be hard to call what bitmex sold a commodity futures contract because there was never a way to take delivery of the asset nor intention to do so. Their contracts were perpetual futures, which is to say: fictitious markers of value that can only ever be btc at the end of the day. This is why so many people referred to it as Arthur’s digital casino. Edit: lastly, IANAL, it could be possible that the bsa includes Bitmex perpetual futures and this is open and shut. The interesting thing to me is the btc component but maybe that doesn’t matter at all?
- smabie 6y agobitmex allowed people to trade btc settled quanto derivatives contracts. That's it.
- hntrader 6y agoThe derivative contract that drove the success of Bitmex, called a Perpetual Future, was quite the innovation. It behaved like a futures contract that never expired. It then led to copycat products across their major competitors. Is there any product like this in traditional financial markets? Regarding the authorities' pursuit of Hayes, it does strike me as odd that they're not going after their major competitors (mostly China-based) who also don't have KYC and are therefore serving US customers through VPN too.
- cortesoft 6y agoAre the China based competitors owned by Americans? I figured they went after this one because it is owned by an American, and they therefore have the authority to go after him.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- markdown 6y agoJulian Assange isn't American :)
- lazylizard 6y agoand somali pirates..probably somalian??
- deathlight 6y agoI think violently attacking people falls under a different category than moving money or information in ways that powerful people/institutions don't like.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> It behaved like a futures contract that never expired. What does that mean? A futures contract says "on [date], we will exchange [X amount of goods] for [Y amount of money]". If there's no date, nothing ever happens.
- 1996 6y agoIt's funny and sad: the US govt thinks it can regulate a foreign exchange based in an independent country. And now the govt wants its pound of flesh for having been shown to be clowns, because (OMG!) foreign businesses may not respect the laws of other countries! TBH I think Hayes only mistake was to incorporate in the Seychelles instead of HK or Russia: BitMex would then be in a place that can't be trampled on with impunity. Some people in the West lament that most mining is done is China. I think it's clearly in crypto best interest to be in bed with the underdog, as the incumbent may not willingly give up its position as the world currency. Some people say "eat the rich"? Their appetite for justice would be better satiated by taking a bite of politicians and their lackey prosecutors.
- PKop 6y agoWhat do you mean "thinks" it can? It is clearly doing so here. Not that there's a short supply of examples, but just look at the current meddling in oil pipeline agreement Nordstream 2 between Russia and Germany; the US financial empire regulates whichever foreign nation's affairs they can get away with.
- 1996 6y ago> What do you mean "thinks" it can? I mean that the government can claim whatever it wants, the validity of the claims still have to be demonstrated in court - since we are not yet in a dictatorship the executive and the judicial branch remain separate. > the US financial empire regulates whichever foreign nation's affairs they can get away with. Germany is a lapdog, but Russia less so. I get the feeling it won't be allowed to fly: if Germany really wants its Sputnik vaccines, it will have to show some spine. And let's talk again when the "US financial empire" thinks it can do the same with China :)
- arcticbull 6y agoCourts have established US jurisdiction over extraterritorial matters many times.
- PKop 6y ago
- vmception 6y agoabsolutely a two-tiered justice system where is his deferred prosecution agreement? why wasnt it even offered here, was it offered here? all they try to pin on him is two bank secrecy act violations and don’t offer a “pay us to go away” route this state has zero credibility
- 1996 6y agowell, that's because Hayes is right: the only difference is in the amount of the bribe. As a mere billionaire, he can only afford coconuts. HSBC can afford 1.92 billion dollar totally-not-a-bribes-even-if-it-works-the-same > After HSBC admitted to laundering nearly a billion dollars for the Sinaloa cartel and moving money for sanctioned customers in Cuba, Iran, Libya, Sudan, and Myanmar, the Justice Department elected not to indict the bank or its officials, instead having it pay a $1.92 billion fine and install a court-appointed compliance monitor. HSBC was only missing North Korea to get a perfect axis of evil collection :) > this state has zero credibility HN has even less. Wait a few hours and look at the offended virgins that will post angry replies saying the state is right and billionaires are evil in general, and this one in particular. Old school geeks used to be innovative, libertarians and pro freedom. In 2020, now that they're at the top of the food chain thanks to selling online ads, they are mostly concerned by enforcing societal norms and praising the status quo, while creating the perfect surveillance apparatus for the big government. Of course they must bow their heads to their corporate masters - they don't want to bite the hand that feeds them! A lost generation.
- arcticbull 6y ago> HN has even less. Wait a few hours and look at the offended virgins that will post angry replies saying the state is right and billionaires are evil in general, and this one in particular. The state is right to prosecute violations of the law. The issue is that deferred prosecutions shouldn't be offered to anyone, instead of as yourself and parent imply, being offered to this guy. In this case the system worked, in the others, it needs to be adjusted. Billionaires aren't evil although money and its distribution is a social contract, and redistribution is a natural part of fiscal policy. Billionaires built their largesse by leveraging systems and facilities of the state. Without the army, the roads, the legal system, they wouldn't have gotten far, and so they are required from time to time to chip back in. Not a virgin though, so I'm not sure how this fits into your calculus. > Old school geeks used to be innovative, libertarians and pro freedom. Not all innovation is good. Not all laws are bad. Our shared reality lies in the middle.
- rajacombinator 6y agoIf you think you can avoid the iron fist of Uncle Sam ... good luck. Everyone playing this game knows the rules.
- seibelj 6y agoAll of this speeds the adoption of decentralized solutions. 2020 vs. 2017 is night and day - most of these contracts can be minted, traded, and settled in a completely decentralized and unstoppable way. Once ETH scaling solutions are fully deployed it’s game over. The world has simply changed. There won’t be anyone to arrest in 2023.
- o-__-o 6y agoStill need to convert USD into crypto. Who will do that?
- zadler 6y agoThat will also be solved, using chain collateralized actors in meat space. It’s already kind of happening, with projects finding ways to tokenize off chain assets like stocks and property.
- o-__-o 6y ago>meatspace So a ripe target for regulation? You may not remember the Nixon shock, but overnight gold was devalued and the target of enforcement was on conversion from gold to USD. All it takes is a very heavy handed law to collapse a delicate single point of failure
- quickthrower2 6y agoIt’s all done in seperate parts. Pick an exchange and turn your USD into USDT or ETH then get that into your favourite DEX and go wild! To shut this down you need to shut down our darling Coinbase because the rest of this can be done completely anonymously with smart contracts.
- xtracto 6y agoHere in Mexico people are using LocalCrypto along with "send money to a friend by giving him a code so that he can withdraw from an ATM without a card" to perform anonymous long distance exchanges. Granted, the amounts are relatively small (350 usd max) but it looks quite useful.
- arcticbull 6y ago> At first Hayes was a nobody among crypto’s dank sea of tax evaders, drug dealers, arms traffickers, child pornographers, contrarian libertarians, and wanker bankers pining for a return to the gold standard. They kinda nailed the space with this quote lol. The only reason this guy got wealthy was because he was willing to look the other way and accept dirty money without the required follow-up questions that anyone who's ever worked at a payments company knows is required ramp-up viewing.
- smabie 6y agobitmex allowed people to trade with btc. There is no payments company or conversion to usd. bitmex only supports btc.
- arcticbull 6y agoCurrency is currency, KYC should be required.
- jkhdigital 6y agoDude, it’s crypto to crypto. Every transaction in or out of BitMEX is on the Bitcoin blockchain. Accepting “dirty money” doesn’t really mean much when you’re a financial cul-de-sac. I personally know a lot of people who own crypto, and none of them are criminals. There are some contrarian libertarians though—guilty as charged!
- CryptoPunk 6y agoUnbelievable that a journalist thinks this is an objective account of the cryptocurrency sector.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt’s like the completely forgot the biggest use case, speculation while melting the ice caps.
- ve55 6y agoThe near-infinite reach of US finance laws into every area of cryptocurrencies (among other categories) is pretty staggering. The promises that cryptocurrencies want to gift to their users are continually sacrificed in the name of draconian regulatory compliance, regardless of the national borders (or lack-thereof) involved. It's particularly interesting to watch various cryptocurrency platforms slowly transform into that which they originally detested, not of their own will, but via the strong guiding hands of US agencies. In this case Bitmex was not incorporated in the US, informed US residents that they were not allowed to use the platform, and even blocked all US IP addresses from accessing their services as well. As the article mentions, yes, some people got around this with VPN blocks, lying about their location, and more. Apparently the US views the solution to this loophole as arresting the founders of Bitmex, regardless of their country of residence, for not complying with US laws. As another commenter reminded me to mention, Bitmex also did not touch USD: they didn't allow withdrawals, deposits, nor transactions in USD, ever. The discrepancy between this treatment and that which established US megabanks receive is made perfectly clear by the latter section of this article, in which billions in fines are often paid in exchange for having purposefully committed blatantly illegal activity for profits on a massive scale. Perhaps there is more to this story that we do not know (I see accusations of a lack of solvency, front-running, and other more serious activities), but if there is no true bombshell awaiting explosion here, I certainly hope his legal defense is sufficient for a solution in his favor.
- ac29 6y ago> Apparently the US views the solution to this loophole as arresting the founders of Bitmex, regardless of their country of residence The only person who's been arrested (Sam Reed) was arrested at his home in the United States. Arthur Hayes, the main focus of this story, is a US citizen and spent most of his life in the US, though seemingly has lived in various countries of late. By virtue of being a billionaire, he can most likely reside whereever he likes. I cant see why that should make him immune from prosecution in the US (a Grand Jury found there was enough evidence to indict him, though this does not mean hes been found guilty of anything).
- ve55 6y ago
- technick 6y agoSay it with me, America is not a global bully. Now say it in a mirror a bunch until you believe yourself or you realize how it is bullshit.
- xyzelement 6y agoThat just doesn't sound like the kind of activity we Americans would bother with, but thank you for the invitation I guess? :)
- anonisko 6y ago...are we the Fire Nation?
- prirun 6y ago*Barclays, BNP Paribas, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, ING, Lloyds Banking Group, Royal Bank of Scotland, and Standard Chartered have all paid fines for conduct that has included money laundering, sanctions violations, and massive tax fraud. In the world of high finance, charging corporate officers in their individual capacity is rare.* Yeah, we've all heard of these. They only get fined. *"I can push back on that—big time,” replied former CFTC chairman Giancarlo. “The CFTC has been no slouch in making referrals for criminal action.” He cited Refco and Peregrine Financial as examples where, at the commission’s urging, the Justice Department charged CEOs who later received lengthy prison terms.* Nope, never heard of these. They go to jail.