3 ms·
As knowledge and technology, and thus capacity, advances, the definition and moral implication of "productive" changes. Is it ethical to deny essentially free
by Brian_K_White 6y ago
As knowledge and technology, and thus capacity, advances, the definition and moral implication of "productive" changes.
Is it ethical to deny essentially free resources from people simply because they didn't perform some act you consider "productive" according to the medieval definition of working real hard?
Is it ethical for 11 rich people to simply own all the robots and all the land that actually produces all material needs, and since no one else except a few technicians and engineers can possibly have any sort of productive job by the old rules, they get none of the resources and shall just die, or, be relegated to agency-less slaves for the pointless amusememt of the few with actual jobs?
Is it ethical to pick any arbitrary time limit and say on day X you die, because that's the rules we made up? Even if that time limit is 1000 years, it's still arbitrary and constitutes a murder.
What younger members? There is no reason to assume that the birth rate will not eventually decrease to match the death rate, or eventually our expansion into space.
I see no problems with longer life that are worse than the current problem of dying.
These sorts of arguments are like being handed a bag of gold bricks and complaining that they are so heavy.
You know, you're right. Them gold bricks is just sooo annoyingly heavy. Because I am just that nice, I will suffer their burden for you.
You can die at your religion's appointed 80 years or whatever number you imagine, but there is no ethical argument why everyone else shouldn't seek to live both as long and as well as they can possibly manage, by any means short of vampirism.
Merely a lot of standard rules about how resources are distributed and how decisions and policy are made today would need to change to fit that different context of tomorrow. The ethical solution to that problem is to simply work on it.