3 ms·
It's all about the context. When you ask your father why something is done a certain way, you're seeking information. You're not questioning the competence of
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
It's all about the context.
When you ask your father why something is done a certain way, you're seeking information. You're not questioning the competence of his field or implying that you have seen an obvious solution that his entire field has simply missed.
However, when engineers say "This change will require 4-6 weeks" and their boss says "Can't you just add a form field and run a database migration and ship it tonight?", the boss is casting doubt on the team's assessment of the situation and their competency in executing.
The demeaning nature varies with intent. If someone is asking a simple question ("Why can't we just ship it tonight? Help me understand") it's nowhere near as bad as a boss waiving away objections with an over-simplified order ("Just change the code and ship it tonight!")
- kelnos 6y agoI don't think anyone would object that that kind of negative reaction to a repeat offender (the hypothetical manager) who has demonstrated through repeat behavior that they have little respect for their employees' expertise. What is a bit more pervasive, though, is a growing belief that any question of the form "why can't you just...?" is inherently condescending and rude. Yes, I agree that a "help me understand"-style question is the ideal way to ask, but I think people have definitely become more (IMO unreasonably) sensitive against the "why can't you just...?" form, when often it's asked innocently and without a trace of disrespect. Something I always try to remind myself: I can't control other people's behavior, but I can control how I react to it. We should try to gently correct truly bad behavior when it is safe and constructive to do so, but it generally does us no good to get all worked up about it in the first place, especially if it's something as benign as a poorly-worded question. And being impatient with these sorts of things can be to our detriment; sometimes a fresh, layman's perspective can provide an insight we hadn't considered.