4 ms·
Direct link to study: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07418825.2020.1853799?journalCode=rjqy20 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07418825.
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Direct link to study: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07418825.2020.1853799?journalCode=rjqy20 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07418825.2020.18...
This type of analysis has some obvious limitations:
- Fraud is more likely to be recorded in public record when committed at big corporations. Many small companies also commit fraud, but it goes unnoticed, unpunished, or otherwise not recorded in ways accessible to researchers because they're too small to make waves. Maybe too small to bother prosecuting.
- Big companies have, by definition, more people, more activity, more transactions, and more opportunities for fraud. It's a mistake to assume that all fraud is orchestrated from the top of these companies. Often, it's mid-level managers looking to get a bonus, raise, or promotion who think they can get away with fraud in their little department.
In my anecdotal experience, big companies are far less likely to behave fraudulently than small, local companies. A big company knows that endemic fraud is a death sentence for their reputation and can bring intense regulatory scrutiny. A small company knows that they can defraud you out of a couple thousand dollars one time and it's not worth your time to pursue legal action.
Of course, most small companies I've worked with are not out to defraud your customers. Building a long-term relationship with a small company can be much more fruitful than being customer number 10,001 for a big company.
Always be careful, regardless of who you're dealing with.
- Nextgrid 6y agoI've noticed fraud (as a customer, and in one case as an insider) at big "growth & engagement"-funded startups most of us have heard of. It's rarely fraud in the legal sense of the term, but it's definitely fraud in the moral sense. They exploit information asymmetry (in one case, the main customer base was mostly teenagers unaware of their options such as card disputes or small claims court) or make it hard for people to claim compensation in case things go wrong, relying on the fact that most people won't bother for the relatively small sums (though at scale that adds up to quite a bit of money).
- tobylane 6y agoWhat do you think should be the weighting factor? Something like revenue or employee count? Maybe someone with access (OpenAthena, Shibboleth) could post the stats and methodology.
- tlb 6y agoWhat fraction of their revenue is due to fraud. It'd be a big project, comparable to a major audit, to calculate it for each company.
- cycomanic 6y ago> Direct link to study: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07418825.2020.18 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07418825.2020.18... > This type of analysis has some obvious limitations: > - Fraud is more likely to be recorded in public record when committed at big corporations. Many small companies also commit fraud, but it goes unnoticed, unpunished, or otherwise not recorded in ways accessible to researchers because they're too small to make waves. Maybe too small to bother prosecuting. From the article >We compiled data on 250+ US public companies involved in corporate securities frauds identified in 1,000+ Securities and Exchange Commission filings over 2005–2013; we randomly selected a comparable control group of 500+ US public companies from Compustat. Based on logistic multivariate regression analyses, marginal profitability, a strong growth imperative, and firm prominence were significant fraud risk factors. Prominent Fortune 500 firms were more susceptible to marginal profitability and/or strong growth-opportunities as risk factors. So it seems they only compared public companies and used SEC filings for identifying fraud, are you saying fraud for small public companies is less likely to be reported to the SEC than for large companies? Otherwise your argument does not apply. > - Big companies have, by definition, more people, more activity, more transactions, and more opportunities for fraud. It's a mistake to assume that all fraud is orchestrated from the top of these companies. Often, it's mid-level managers looking to get a bonus, raise, or promotion who think they can get away with fraud in their little department. That does support the thesis that large companies would commit more fraud. I didn't see a claim that fraud is orchestrated from the top. > In my anecdotal experience, big companies are far less likely to behave fraudulently than small, local companies. A big company knows that endemic fraud is a death sentence for their reputation and can bring intense regulatory scrutiny. A small company knows that they can defraud you out of a couple thousand dollars one time and it's not worth your time to pursue legal action. So after dismissing the representative research you bring up your anecdotal evidence. Was the motivation behind dismissing the presented research maybe that it doesn't match your own experience? This is a common psychological trap to fall into, but just because something does not match our own experience does not make it necessarily less true. > Of course, most small companies I've worked with are not out to defraud your customers. Building a long-term relationship with a small company can be much more fruitful than being customer number 10,001 for a big company. > Always be careful, regardless of who you're dealing with.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"but it goes unnoticed, unpunished, or otherwise not recorded in ways accessible to researchers because they're too small to make waves. Maybe too small to bother prosecuting." Hm, but small crime under the radar just as well apply to big corporations, meaning just as probably small company fraud might have been overlooked or ignored, so was probably lots of small crime on the big corporations. So the bigger point still stands. And what does it have to do with media coverage? "We compiled data on 250+ US public companies involved in corporate securities frauds identified in 1,000+ Securities and Exchange Commission filings over 2005–2013" I would assume their data is from the state from actual judgments and not that they dig in newspapers archives.
- hrktb 6y agoFrom the study: > Findings were robust to various empirical measures and additional controls for undetected fraud. Otherwise, I think logic would dictate that greedy people try to get into bigger companies where decent amount of money is moving. Same for fudging the books, it starts to make sense from a risk perspective if there is a decent amount of transaction to hide fraud in. For too small businesses, fraud will be more limited to not recording events (gifts etc.), and those arguably occur whatever the size of the company. To put it differently, I think big companies will be more of a fraud magnet, and they’ll need super serious effort to guard against it. Those efforts are often not good enough/not incentivized so it’s bound to happen more often.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI am curious as to how they could possibly make the findings robust to undetected fraud. It sounds very much like their "experiment" group consists of companies that are more often in the limelight. If the "control" group's members commit fraud at the same rate but are less likely to have it detected because of a relative lack of attention, how could you possible control for that in the study design?
- cycomanic 6y agoNote that the article is only about securities fraud. From the abstract I assume they looked at the group that was reported to the SEC for fraud and compared to a random selection of 500 companies and then compared what percentage amongst those two groups were big corporations, growth pressures etc.. Regarding the control for undetected fraud, there could be various methods that one can employ (e.g. when one has some statistics about undetected fraud for example). From the formulation in the abstract I assume that when they apply the controls their findings don't change, so with or without the controls large corporations are more likely to commit fraud.
- bordercases 6y agoNeither "limitation" is inconsistent with the slightly different, but discursively relevant idea that the higher EV for fraud will skew towards bigger corporations versus smaller ones. In particular, the second limitation is not a limitation at all, but can serve as a prior explanation for why fraud is more likely in large corporations. If you were to measure the amount of fraud per capita, small corporations might dominate; but it's the impact or scope of fraud that makes one fraud more important than another. And even if fraud within an organization is not coordinated from the CEO down, it's still the organization as a singular entity that's held accountable for the behavior of its parts.
- cat199 6y ago> In my anecdotal experience, big companies are far less likely to behave fraudulently than small, local companies. I'd imagine it's kind of a bell curve, with very small companies more likely (since some of those are 'fly by night'), increasing to some point due to more oversight / legitimacy needed to run a bigger organization, until they start to become powerful enough that corrupt people can hide things or accept fraudulent actions as a 'cost of business'. Didn't investigate methods (and wouldn't be very qualified to judge anyway), but this study might not catch the smaller fish, so it would skew towards only catching the bigger ones, leading to the conclusion
- btilly 6y agoIn my anecdotal experience, big companies are far less likely to behave fraudulently than small, local companies. In my anecdotal experience, big companies are far more likely to have figured out how to walk barely on the legal side of the line. It may not be fraud per se, but it doesn't feel different on the receiving end. Here is an example that I saw while working as a consultant at Bristol Myers Squibb. They had perfected the art of paying a lot of their bills at the last possible moment. And were happy to accept penalties to delay it more. With the explicit hope that suppliers would go broke and out of business before successfully collecting, and then they wouldn't have to pay at all. I was horrified, and the accountant who told me about it was describing how terrible it was to be taking calls from people whose life's work was going under, and be unable to pay them what they were owed because corporate policy was clear. And none of it was actually fraud. They were very careful to stay just within what the contract allowed.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThis is a big reason why Walmart can get lower prices than other companies. My family used to be in food processing. Walmart was one of the only grocers to pay their bills on time. We made next to nothing on the Walmart orders but we could count on the cash arriving when they said it would. Everyone else, they would pay late or need to be endlessly reminded.
- refurb 6y agoYour BMS story is suspect. If the company you owe money to goes bankrupt that doesn’t absolve you from paying your bills. If you’re a big supplier for BMS I assume your a critical part of their business, so why would BMS want you to go under? If you’re a small supplier you wouldn’t even get on the radar of BMS leadership. Paying a small supplier a few million is a blip on BMS balance sheets. Yes, big corps manage cash flow very tightly, will force unfavorable payment terms on suppliers, but using that as a strategy to bankrupt them? I doubt it. If anything big companies like BMS are risk adverse as hell.
- closeparen 6y ago>go broke and out of business before successfully collecting, and then they wouldn't have to pay at all Wouldn't accounts receivable be among the dead company's assets to be redistributed to creditors?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]