3 ms·
> The minor debate over Lady Dr. Jill Biden’s title, which came up shortly after her husband’s election, may seem completely ridiculous and insulting, which it
by fortran77 6y ago
> The minor debate over Lady Dr. Jill Biden’s title, which came up shortly after her husband’s election, may seem completely ridiculous and insulting, which it is, but it’s also the latest in a line of kerfuffles relating to how people in power in the United States present themselves
"Ridiculous and insulting?", not really. There's a long history of people mocking "Ed.D" holders calling themselves "Dr." outside of specific contexts. (Like on a paper or publication that's related to your field, etc.) And an Ed.D. is not a Ph.D. You don't see people with JD degrees calling themselves "Doctor" or even using the term "Esquire" outside of specific contexts, like on an article of incorporation for their Professional Corporation. etc.
You may see the actual degree indicated (Ph.D, Ed. D) after a name on a professional paper, etc. But not the term "Dr."
For an example take, see this blog posting from 2017, before anyone was thinking of First Lady Biden or her title: https://headinthesandblog.org/2017/06/ed-d-school-leaders-demand-called-doctor-please-get/#:~:text=If%20you%E2%80%99re%20an%20Ed.D%20running%20a%20school%20or,in%20your%20email%20signature%20and%20your%20online%20bio https://headinthesandblog.org/2017/06/ed-d-school-leaders-de.... Also see Wikipedia on this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_of_Education#Comparisons_of_the_EdD_to_the_PhD_in_education_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_of_Education#Comparison...
And this article negates its own point in its conclusion! It says "lawyers can use the term Esquire, but not many do." Michelle Obama, by all accounts a competent attorney, never demanded to be called "Lady Dr. Michelle Obama, Esquire" even though with her J.D. and admission to the bar it would be logical. She would have been mocked the same way Jill Biden was.
- eplanit 6y agoYes. If you have a PhD and you were an academic or researcher or practitioner, then fine call yourself "doctor". If, like jill Biden, you never really applied yourself in that domain as a professional career, then get over yourself. I guess we'll overturn those conventions now for the sake of politics.