3 ms·
> I'd be surprised if there weren't a fight from the feds about ceding this amount of power to a state. Huh, I had exactly the opposite reaction. Ceding what a
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> I'd be surprised if there weren't a fight from the feds about ceding this amount of power to a state.
Huh, I had exactly the opposite reaction. Ceding what amount of power to a state? The article says a company would receive the same authority that a county government already gets. That's authority the feds never had; they're not losing anything here.
Which kind of defeats the purpose. How is it a charter city if it's still subject to all the same laws that it would be if it weren't chartered? The Lübeck model wasn't based on being allowed to staff the courts -- it was based on being allowed to write the laws.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoThough probably not what the article was referring to, Nevada is a bit of a special case here because in the past they created a county (Bullfrog County) for the express purpose of preventing the federal government from storing nuclear waste at the Yucca Mountain site. Ironically, what Nevada is proposing to do might actually make it easier for the federal government to store nuclear waste in Nevada as long as it was contracted to one of these new company counties, though the specific details of the legislation would need to be reviewed to know for sure.
- atlasunshrugged 6y agoInteresting, maybe I'm misunderstanding it but my thought process was basically that yes, a company gets the same amount of authority that a county government gets but where I disagree is where you say this is authority the feds never had. I think the feds would see it as they've essentially granted (or bargained) with the state so they can have this authority, I'm not sure they'd see it as within the state's purview to unilaterally grant it to another. My disagreement isn't that it'd defeat the purpose of it being a charter city, if the feds don't allow it it would indeed defeat the purpose. My point is that my immediate concern is that this draft bill may be challenged in court by somebody (name a government, tribal group, nonprofit, or NIMBY cohort) on the grounds that the state doesn't have that authority to grant these rights and that it should rest with the feds.
- clairity 6y agounder what jurisdiction do you believe the fed has that power? it's not an overarching government that gives power to the states, but rather the states, as canonical units of power, that cede power to the fed for mutual benefit of the collective states. the fed doesn't own/control all the (unincorporated) land, the states do. the fed may try to use it's limited delegated powers (like the interstate commerce clause) to shape things on the margins, but it doesn't have direct jurisdiction on this matter.
- atlasunshrugged 6y agoI have no idea under what jurisdiction the fed has that power, I have very little US government experience and IANAL. But my impression is that the federal government oscillates between being more and less involved in state's affairs over time and administrations, and that when considering novel (or semi-novel since the practice of allocating jurisdiction to companies seems to have been done elsewhere - ex. Florida & Disney) legislation it should be a serious consideration that the federal government would be interested in getting involved, especially in a contentious issue like this very likely will be and that new precedent and rulings can always be set depending on who is in power (legislatively or in the courts).
- clairity 6y agoyes, (national) politicians will want to get involved (under the assumption that any publicity is good publicity), but that doesn't mean they can do much directly other than yak about it in the media.
- kelnos 6y agoThat's not how the US constitution works, though. Any power not specifically granted to the federal government is explicitly reserved to the states and its people. In practice this ends up being more of a muddy issue than I'd like it to be (cough interstate commerce clause cough), but in principle, that's the law of the land. But it does seem that this proposal isn't really the same as what we'd think of as a charter city/county. I don't think the state would be giving the corporation carte blanche to write its own independent legal system; they're still subject and subordinate to federal and state law. The only expressly weird thing about this from a government perspective is that the county would be run by a supervisory board that the corporation entirely controls (as in, the company wouldn't have to hold elections for those positions). Still, that's a very big difference and I'm very much against this whole idea.