4 ms·
The short of it is that the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy, primarily with medical professionals. Everyone wants to stand out
by pseudolus 6y ago
The short of it is that the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy, primarily with medical professionals. Everyone wants to stand out and mark their social class even in supposedly "classless" societies.
Interestingly enough in francophone countries lawyers have their own commonly used honorific "master" or in french "maître" (Mᵉ). I don't expect that title will ever gain much traction in the US as lawyers would probably get tired of being asked to seat people in restaurants.
- CarelessExpert 6y ago> The short of it is that the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy, primarily with medical professionals. That... isn't indicated anywhere in the article at all. If I had to summarize: knights got wealthy, squires/esquires became a thing, folks started using "esquire" because it was then rich adjacent, then over time it got connected to the legal profession, through the article makes no attempt to really explain that evolution.
- pseudolus 6y agoFrom the article: "But lawyers, unlike doctors (medical or otherwise), have no other title-based way to signal what they do, or, to be somewhat uncharitable, that what they do is special, and therefore that who they are is important."
- CarelessExpert 6y agoNothing in the paragraph indicates an origin for the connection to the legal profession. In fact, later in the piece they explicitly state that the origin of that connection is unknown: > Successive writers tried to pin down what it actually meant, with no great success. Ferne, who was himself also a lawyer, noted that it was often used by those in the legal profession. Later definitions suggest someone adjacent to power, maybe the son of a knight or the younger son of a titled noble who would receive no other title of his own. But also, consistently, it included someone in a legal profession: a justice of the peace, a barrister, a sergeant-at-law. It was never recorded, explicitly, why this might be.
- pseudolus 6y agoPerhaps instead of stating "that the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy" I should have stated "that use of the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy" which is entirely consistent with the author implying that lawyers need to signal that what they do is special".
- CarelessExpert 6y agoSo if your comment is about "what does the title mean", yup, no argument there. Today, it means lawyer. The article is about why. And the article explicitly states we have no idea why the term is now attached to the legal profession. Again, all we know is: knights got rich, squires became a thing, people started using "esquire" to appear rich adjacent, then ... esquire == lawyer. That's it. That's all the article gives us as far as the origin story goes. But maybe you're not talking about the origin and instead just talking about contemporary use, in which case we're in violent agreement! :)
- MereInterest 6y agoTo be fair, similar professional jealousy is also the exact reason why "Doctor" in English refers to a physician. In the late 1800s, physicians felt that they as a profession didn't get enough respect, and decided to exclusively refer to each other as "Doctor", and require that patients refer to them that way as well. The terminal medical degree was renamed from "Bachelor of Medicine" to "Medical Doctor" as part of the same movement.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y ago> The short of it is that the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy, primarily with medical professionals. Everyone wants to stand out and mark their social class even in supposedly "classless" societies. This is my understanding too. In my opinion, use of honorifics demonstrates a character flaw that should be corrected, not accommodated or encouraged. My general M.O is to use the same level of formality with a person that they use with me. For example, if my physician uses my first name, I use hers. This lets me match their desired level of familiarity, but disregards any pretense they might try to introduce.
- slim 6y agoIsn't it controversial these days? (see debate about master/slave in computer context) /s
- brmgb 6y ago> Interestingly enough in francophone countries lawyers have their own commonly used honorific "master" or in french "maître" (Mᵉ). Yes but it's never used outside of a professional setting in the same way everyone would have a good laught at the expense of someone with a PhD calling themself a doctor and using Dr in France.