8 ms·
> In the 20th century, the country slowed and then stopped giving out hereditary titles; the last one granted was in 1984 Wasn't the 1st Baronet Thatcher creat
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> In the 20th century, the country slowed and then stopped giving out hereditary titles; the last one granted was in 1984
Wasn't the 1st Baronet Thatcher created in 1990?
> But lawyers, unlike doctors (medical or otherwise), have no other title-based way to signal what they do
Don't most lawyers in the US have a JD? That's a doctorate isn't it? Can you call yourself 'doctor' from that? (Not even all medical doctors calling themselves 'doctor' have a doctorate!)
- thechao 6y agoI think they’re talking about hereditary peers; a baronet is not a peer.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIt just says 'hereditary titles', and a baronetcy is an hereditary title (which is why it was awarded to her husband, not Thatcher herself.)
- cascom 6y agoA baronet is not a peer, but it is a hereditary title, Mark Thatcher(Husband) was made one, Margaret Thatcher was made a baron (different, and is a peer) but hers was a life peerage not a hereditary one.
- germinalphrase 6y agoAre there any non-class reasons why lawyers would require a “title-based way to signal what they do”? Plenty of professions with equivalent training have no honorific (even if they do list various letters after their names).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CarelessExpert 6y agoThese days they don't, which is why, as the article notes, not many lawyers use the term, as it's seen as archaic and pretentious.
- rayiner 6y agoNo there’s not. This is all about class signaling.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bradknowles 6y agoTo be a lawyer in the US, you only have to pass the bar exam, presumably in the state where you are located. Many state bars have reciprocity agreements with other states, so that you can be admitted to the bar in a state you have recently moved to, by applying to the state bar association and providing your credentials with the other state bar association. Oh, and the fee, of course. Some state bar exams are much tougher than others, and they don’t have a reciprocity agreement. New York is one such well known example. The reciprocity situation gets more weird when you talk about moving from one country to another. And the UK situation is also weird, with regards to Solicitors versus Barristers — one type practices law inside the courtroom, while the other type practices law outside the courtroom — and I can never keep straight which is which. Having a JD doesn’t really have any bearing on whether you can pass the bar exams. Source: my wife is a lawyer, she has a JD from Georgetown Law, she is a member of the DC, NY, and TX bar associations, and when we moved to Texas from Belgium in 2006 we had to go through some real wacky stuff with regards to reciprocity.
- bradknowles 6y agoOh, and my wife never calls herself “Doctor”. She will tell people that she has a JD, if they ask. But that’s as far as she goes in that area.
- D13Fd 6y agoYou definitely can't call yourself a "doctor" in the U.S. just by virtue of having a law degree (unless you also have a Ph.D.)
- Sharlin 6y agoBut the GP was talking about having a JD, not just any law degree. Dr. Biden does not have a PhD (or an MD), which led to the mentioned controversy, but the majority opinion seems to be that any doctorate (at least a non-honorary one) confers the right to use “Dr.”, right?
- D13Fd 6y agoNo. JD is the standard and lowest law degree (the other being the uncommon LLM, which requires more education than a JD but is not used in most fields of law), and does not allow you to call yourself “doctor.”
- chrisseaton 6y agoI'm sure you're right - but do you know why that is? It is a doctorate isn't it? What makes some doctorates qualify and others not?
- D13Fd 6y agoNo. It may be because JD’s are so common and easy to earn relative to a Ph.D. (at least a hard science Ph.D.). The JD itself is not meaningful for the practice of law - its passing the bar that matters. But that’s true for other professions too (doctors).
- sithadmin 6y agoThe primary reason is that it’s simply not customary. That’s it. It’s no deeper than that. But JD programs also differ significantly from academically oriented PhD programs in that the overwhelming majority of them focus on generalized practical knowledge and skills alone. Most don’t even properly prepare graduates for local licensure exams, forcing them to do yet another prep course (or at least intense self-study) prior to practicing their trade. In this regard, it’s a degree that’s more similar to an MBA than it is a PhD, and while it shares traits with MD programs, MD programs have a much deeper emphasis on theory, and a much deeper emphasis on practice and ethics than you’ll see in any JD program. That’s not to say that there aren’t folks that do a JD but proceed along an “academic” track intended to focus on original research and prepare for legal scholarship. These people exist, but they are a tiny minority among JD candidates.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cascom 6y agoThatcher, and I believe all ex-PM’s, are typically given a peerage, however they are not hereditary and thus are called life peers. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_peer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_peer
- detaro 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets
- chrisseaton 6y agoI don't know why you'd look this up on Wikipedia but not actually look up what I referenced. > The Thatcher baronetcy, of Scotney in the County of Kent, is a baronetcy created for the husband of Margaret Thatcher, Denis Thatcher, on 7 December 1990, following the resignation of his wife on 28 November. The current holder is Mark Thatcher, who succeeded his father in 2003. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets
- cascom 6y agoThe article should have read “hereditary peerages” rather than “hereditary titles”
- bidirectional 6y agoNo PM since Thatcher has been given a peerage, though I believe Major through Brown turned them down, unsure about Cameron, and May is still an MP. Historically they would be given an hereditary earldom, this switched to life peerages under Douglas-Home (who gave up his hereditary earldom to become Prime Minister). Churchill was famously offered a dukedom by both The Queen and George VI, turning down both.
- wl 6y agoThe JD is a three-year degree that is the first one earned in a subject. If that sounds like a bachelor's degree, it's because it really is: It used to be called an LLB or Bachelor of Laws. But law schools renamed it in a misguided attempt to increase the prestige of the legal profession. The only pretense it has to being called a graduate degree is that law schools require usually another bachelor's degree in a different subject. It's still a second bachelor's degree. In short, the JD is a "doctorate" in name only. The legal community, for the most part, is wise enough not to push the matter.
- swampthing 6y agoBy this definition, an MD is also a bachelor’s degree.
- wl 6y agoSure. I've said as much elsewhere: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26047229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26047229
- swampthing 6y agoCool, just pointing out where that logic leads.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIn the UK the medical degree that most medical doctors do is an undergraduate bachelor’s degrees. They use 'doctor' as a courtesy title after graduating, but only if they're junior and not a surgeon.
- swampthing 6y agoYea, I was referring to the MD degree (guessing the degree you’re referring to is not called that).
- 6y ago
- valarauko 6y ago> > In the 20th century, the country slowed and then stopped giving out hereditary titles; the last one granted was in 1984 > Wasn't the 1st Baronet Thatcher created in 1990? True. I think the article is confusing the term with Hereditary Peerage, the most recent of which was indeed created in 1984, the Earl of Stockton. By contrast, a baronetcy is not a peerage.