20 ms·
What Does the Title ‘Esquire’ Mean, Anyway?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> In the 20th century, the country slowed and then stopped giving out hereditary titles; the last one granted was in 1984 Wasn't the 1st Baronet Thatcher created in 1990? > But lawyers, unlike doctors (medical or otherwise), have no other title-based way to signal what they do Don't most lawyers in the US have a JD? That's a doctorate isn't it? Can you call yourself 'doctor' from that? (Not even all medical doctors calling themselves 'doctor' have a doctorate!)
- thechao 6y agoI think they’re talking about hereditary peers; a baronet is not a peer.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIt just says 'hereditary titles', and a baronetcy is an hereditary title (which is why it was awarded to her husband, not Thatcher herself.)
- cascom 6y agoA baronet is not a peer, but it is a hereditary title, Mark Thatcher(Husband) was made one, Margaret Thatcher was made a baron (different, and is a peer) but hers was a life peerage not a hereditary one.
- germinalphrase 6y agoAre there any non-class reasons why lawyers would require a “title-based way to signal what they do”? Plenty of professions with equivalent training have no honorific (even if they do list various letters after their names).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CarelessExpert 6y agoThese days they don't, which is why, as the article notes, not many lawyers use the term, as it's seen as archaic and pretentious.
- rayiner 6y agoNo there’s not. This is all about class signaling.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bradknowles 6y agoTo be a lawyer in the US, you only have to pass the bar exam, presumably in the state where you are located. Many state bars have reciprocity agreements with other states, so that you can be admitted to the bar in a state you have recently moved to, by applying to the state bar association and providing your credentials with the other state bar association. Oh, and the fee, of course. Some state bar exams are much tougher than others, and they don’t have a reciprocity agreement. New York is one such well known example. The reciprocity situation gets more weird when you talk about moving from one country to another. And the UK situation is also weird, with regards to Solicitors versus Barristers — one type practices law inside the courtroom, while the other type practices law outside the courtroom — and I can never keep straight which is which. Having a JD doesn’t really have any bearing on whether you can pass the bar exams. Source: my wife is a lawyer, she has a JD from Georgetown Law, she is a member of the DC, NY, and TX bar associations, and when we moved to Texas from Belgium in 2006 we had to go through some real wacky stuff with regards to reciprocity.
- bradknowles 6y agoOh, and my wife never calls herself “Doctor”. She will tell people that she has a JD, if they ask. But that’s as far as she goes in that area.
- D13Fd 6y agoYou definitely can't call yourself a "doctor" in the U.S. just by virtue of having a law degree (unless you also have a Ph.D.)
- Sharlin 6y agoBut the GP was talking about having a JD, not just any law degree. Dr. Biden does not have a PhD (or an MD), which led to the mentioned controversy, but the majority opinion seems to be that any doctorate (at least a non-honorary one) confers the right to use “Dr.”, right?
- D13Fd 6y agoNo. JD is the standard and lowest law degree (the other being the uncommon LLM, which requires more education than a JD but is not used in most fields of law), and does not allow you to call yourself “doctor.”
- chrisseaton 6y agoI'm sure you're right - but do you know why that is? It is a doctorate isn't it? What makes some doctorates qualify and others not?
- D13Fd 6y agoNo. It may be because JD’s are so common and easy to earn relative to a Ph.D. (at least a hard science Ph.D.). The JD itself is not meaningful for the practice of law - its passing the bar that matters. But that’s true for other professions too (doctors).
- sithadmin 6y agoThe primary reason is that it’s simply not customary. That’s it. It’s no deeper than that. But JD programs also differ significantly from academically oriented PhD programs in that the overwhelming majority of them focus on generalized practical knowledge and skills alone. Most don’t even properly prepare graduates for local licensure exams, forcing them to do yet another prep course (or at least intense self-study) prior to practicing their trade. In this regard, it’s a degree that’s more similar to an MBA than it is a PhD, and while it shares traits with MD programs, MD programs have a much deeper emphasis on theory, and a much deeper emphasis on practice and ethics than you’ll see in any JD program. That’s not to say that there aren’t folks that do a JD but proceed along an “academic” track intended to focus on original research and prepare for legal scholarship. These people exist, but they are a tiny minority among JD candidates.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cascom 6y agoThatcher, and I believe all ex-PM’s, are typically given a peerage, however they are not hereditary and thus are called life peers. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_peer https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_peer
- detaro 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets
- chrisseaton 6y agoI don't know why you'd look this up on Wikipedia but not actually look up what I referenced. > The Thatcher baronetcy, of Scotney in the County of Kent, is a baronetcy created for the husband of Margaret Thatcher, Denis Thatcher, on 7 December 1990, following the resignation of his wife on 28 November. The current holder is Mark Thatcher, who succeeded his father in 2003. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thatcher_baronets
- cascom 6y agoThe article should have read “hereditary peerages” rather than “hereditary titles”
- bidirectional 6y agoNo PM since Thatcher has been given a peerage, though I believe Major through Brown turned them down, unsure about Cameron, and May is still an MP. Historically they would be given an hereditary earldom, this switched to life peerages under Douglas-Home (who gave up his hereditary earldom to become Prime Minister). Churchill was famously offered a dukedom by both The Queen and George VI, turning down both.
- wl 6y agoThe JD is a three-year degree that is the first one earned in a subject. If that sounds like a bachelor's degree, it's because it really is: It used to be called an LLB or Bachelor of Laws. But law schools renamed it in a misguided attempt to increase the prestige of the legal profession. The only pretense it has to being called a graduate degree is that law schools require usually another bachelor's degree in a different subject. It's still a second bachelor's degree. In short, the JD is a "doctorate" in name only. The legal community, for the most part, is wise enough not to push the matter.
- swampthing 6y agoBy this definition, an MD is also a bachelor’s degree.
- wl 6y agoSure. I've said as much elsewhere: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26047229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26047229
- swampthing 6y agoCool, just pointing out where that logic leads.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIn the UK the medical degree that most medical doctors do is an undergraduate bachelor’s degrees. They use 'doctor' as a courtesy title after graduating, but only if they're junior and not a surgeon.
- swampthing 6y agoYea, I was referring to the MD degree (guessing the degree you’re referring to is not called that).
- 6y ago
- valarauko 6y ago> > In the 20th century, the country slowed and then stopped giving out hereditary titles; the last one granted was in 1984 > Wasn't the 1st Baronet Thatcher created in 1990? True. I think the article is confusing the term with Hereditary Peerage, the most recent of which was indeed created in 1984, the Earl of Stockton. By contrast, a baronetcy is not a peerage.
- cwwc 6y ago> “It’s something where, in my personal experience, I would never use it. It would be horrifically pretentious to do that.” I've only ever seen lawyers from bad schools use esquire, to be blunt. If you've gone to HYS, no way you'll use this.
- swebs 6y agoThis is a poorly written article coated in the author's hamfisted rant on modern US politics. The Wikipedia page is much more straightforward and in-depth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Esquire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Esquire
- D13Fd 6y agoI thought it was interesting and it accurately describes the use as kind of embarrassing to other attorneys, in a way the Wikipedia article doesn't. I didn't see anything particularly political about it other than the last line (about memes invading the "halls of American power").
- pc86 6y agoThe first several paragraphs are ranting about Dr. Biden and sexism.
- ModernMech 6y agoI didn’t read that as a rant at all. I read that as giving context to debate over titles using a recent example in the news. How was it a rant?
- D13Fd 6y agoThey are not ranting and, honestly, didn’t come across as all that political to me. Those paragraphs are referencing the controversy as a lead-in to an article about the use of esquire, which has little to do with the First Lady. At best you could say that the references to current politics are distracting.
- JasonFruit 6y agoI don't know about rant, but the thick coating of political implication throughout was distasteful. The Wikipedia article has less character, in a good way.
- D13Fd 6y agoThe article nails it with this quote: >American lawyers all could call themselves “Esquire,” inasmuch as anyone can, and for lawyers it wouldn’t be misleading. But not many do. “There’s not a huge amount of debate, but when it does come up, there’s a sense that this is a kind of archaic term, it’s somewhat embarrassing,” says Silversmith. “It’s something where, in my personal experience, I would never use it. It would be horrifically pretentious to do that.” This is correct. Seeing "esq." after a lawyer's name in an e-mail signature definitely tells you something about the person sending the e-mail (and it's not just that they are a lawyer...).
- pseudolus 6y agoAmongst lawyers it might be seen as ridiculous but I've seen the title used on many a bus stop shelter featuring ads for personal injury attorneys. For some reason it seems to resonate with members of the general public. It was also adopted by Bill ("Bill S. Preston, Esq") of "Bill and Ted" fame. One would have hoped that would have generated some ridicule and killed the title but unfortunately it did not.
- D13Fd 6y agoYes. Those bus stop ads are an example of the kind of attorney who uses "esq."
- excalibur 6y agoI'm assuming the Esquire was conferred on Bill S. Preston by his dad, making him the pretentious one. But of course the whole Wild Stallyns schtick was always more about being a musician than the music itself.
- ValentineC 6y agoI only got around to watching all the Bill and Ted movies last month, and found this explanation to make more sense: https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/397ukr/eli5_in_bill_teds_excellent_adventure_when_bill/ https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/397ukr/e... (tl;dr it's a reference to a watch ad.)
- consp 6y agoWhy don't they start using the requirement of having a Masters of Law degree to practice law, like some European countries do? This solves the "title" problem once and for all as they are then supposed to be qualified by passing a masters exam and infer an official title.
- pseudolus 6y agoThe short of it is that the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy, primarily with medical professionals. Everyone wants to stand out and mark their social class even in supposedly "classless" societies. Interestingly enough in francophone countries lawyers have their own commonly used honorific "master" or in french "maître" (Mᵉ). I don't expect that title will ever gain much traction in the US as lawyers would probably get tired of being asked to seat people in restaurants.
- CarelessExpert 6y ago> The short of it is that the title has arisen as a result of a form of professional jealousy, primarily with medical professionals. That... isn't indicated anywhere in the article at all. If I had to summarize: knights got wealthy, squires/esquires became a thing, folks started using "esquire" because it was then rich adjacent, then over time it got connected to the legal profession, through the article makes no attempt to really explain that evolution.
- pseudolus 6y agoFrom the article: "But lawyers, unlike doctors (medical or otherwise), have no other title-based way to signal what they do, or, to be somewhat uncharitable, that what they do is special, and therefore that who they are is important."
- CarelessExpert 6y agoNothing in the paragraph indicates an origin for the connection to the legal profession. In fact, later in the piece they explicitly state that the origin of that connection is unknown: > Successive writers tried to pin down what it actually meant, with no great success. Ferne, who was himself also a lawyer, noted that it was often used by those in the legal profession. Later definitions suggest someone adjacent to power, maybe the son of a knight or the younger son of a titled noble who would receive no other title of his own. But also, consistently, it included someone in a legal profession: a justice of the peace, a barrister, a sergeant-at-law. It was never recorded, explicitly, why this might be.
- wegs 6y agoThe first segment, on Dr/Mrs/Mademe/First Lady/etc. Biden is ill-informed. The use of titles carries very different implications in different cultures. America is diverse. First name can signify disrespect or familiarity. Titles can signify high status, or stuffy pretentiousness. "Dr" can be reserved for medical doctors, can extend to PhDs, or even extend to JDs. I spent 15 minutes, the other day, on an inane debate with a colleague, before we realized we were using a word with subtly different meanings. There's a new form of strawman attack, where you point to a crazy on the internet with some opinion, and stereotype everyone to have that same opinion, and the linked article is clearly from someone with issues. But the fact remains tht there are cultural pockets of culture where all the terms are appropriate and don't convey disrespect, whether "Jill," "First Lady," "Dr. Biden," "Mrs. Biden," "Madame President," or even "Hey you." Conversely, there are cultural pockets where all of those convey disrespect. If you're aware of it, and look for it, it's not hard to tell which is which, even. In a multicultural society, we should try to hear what the other person is trying to say, assume good intentions, and not pick battles over semantics. Your words and body language mean something different than mine, and that's okay. We should try to communicate. Disrespect isn't about a title, but what's behind it.
- ghaff 6y agoBy and large, call people what they want to be called even if you think it's a bit unnecessary and pretentious. The fracas over Dr. Biden was silly and whatever one's views of PhDs/other research doctorates emphasizing a doctor title, it's important to some--both male and female--and the latter also gets into all sorts of issues of sexism and perceived sexism. As the article says, the US in general is less into titles than the UK. I went to an event put on by The Economist a couple years back and the registration form forced you to choose a title and I think were about 30 choices and you had to pick one. (Mr. and Ms. of course but also Lord, Dame, Rev., etc.)
- bloak 6y agoSomebody at https://fm.schmoller.net/2010/01/if-ever-you-need-a-really-comprehensive-title-drop-down.html https://fm.schmoller.net/2010/01/if-ever-you-need-a-really-c... quotes a list of 133 choices of title offered by the Royal Opera House ticket booking system. It's not a lot of bytes so perhaps I can quote it: Mr, Mrs, Ms, Miss, Advocate, Ambassador, Baron, Baroness, Brigadier, Canon, Captain, Chancellor, Chief, Col, Comdr, Commodore, Councillor, Count, Countess, Dame, Dr, Duke of, Earl, Earl of, Father, General, Group Captain, H R H the Duchess of, H R H the Duke of, H R H The Princess, HE Mr, HE Senora, HE The French Ambassador M, His Highness, His Hon, His Hon Judge, Hon, Hon Ambassador, Hon Dr, Hon Lady, Hon Mrs, HRH, HRH Sultan Shah, HRH The, HRH The Prince, HRH The Princess, HSH Princess, HSH The Prince, Judge, King, Lady, Lord, Lord and Lady, Lord Justice, Lt Cdr, Lt Col, Madam, Madame, Maj, Maj Gen, Major, Marchesa, Marchese, Marchioness, Marchioness of, Marquess, Marquess of, Marquis, Marquise, Master, Mr and Mrs, Mr and The Hon Mrs, President, Prince, Princess, Princessin, Prof, Prof Emeritus, Prof Dame, Professor, Queen, Rabbi, Representative, Rev Canon, Rev Dr, Rev Mgr, Rev Preb, Reverend, Reverend Father, Right Rev, Rt Hon, Rt Hon Baroness, Rt Hon Lord, Rt Hon Sir, Rt Hon The Earl, Rt Hon Viscount, Senator, Sir, Sister, Sultan, The Baroness, The Countess, The Countess of, The Dowager Marchioness of, The Duchess, The Duchess of, The Duke of, The Earl of, The Hon, The Hon Mr, The Hon Mrs, The Hon Ms, The Hon Sir, The Lady, The Lord, The Marchioness of, The Princess, The Reverend, The Rt Hon, The Rt Hon Lord, The Rt Hon Sir, The Rt Hon The Lord, The Rt Hon the Viscount, The Rt Hon Viscount, The Venerable, The Very Rev Dr, Very Reverend, Viscondessa, Viscount, Viscount and Viscountess, Viscountess, W Baron, W/Cdr
- jhunter1016 6y agoThis is why I love weekend HN. Articles like this don’t often seem to make the front page on the week days, but they are fantastic.
- Krasnol 6y agoI've always found it quite funny how common it is in the US to be the 2nd or 3rd e.g. "Peter II Smith". I haven't seen this anywhere in Europe besides in history books for kings etc. It looks like one of those "need to compensate for lack of history" things.
- goodcanadian 6y agoIn certain parts of the US (mostly Texas, I think), it is common to give your first born son the same name as you. In that case, using Sr. and Jr., or numerals becomes a practical matter of identifying which Peter Smith you are talking about.
- Krasnol 6y agoI like that "Senior/Junior" thing but I always wondered if people actually say "Hi, I'm Peter the third...".
- cascom 6y agoI’ve never heard it, but the thirds often end with nicknames like Trip (as in triple) or Tres (south Texas / 3 in Spanish) or if your in south Louisiana the the prefix of petit (little, eg Jean and petit Jean) is appended to the junior vs the senior
- mindslight 6y agoIME (n=2), people don't really use "senior/junior/third" when introducing themselves. Disambiguation is done with nicknames (eg John vs Johnny), and the titles only come out when it makes sense to talk technicalities.
- ctdonath 6y agoArticle needlessly spends paragraphs bashing political conservatives for no purpose related to the point.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoHa. I see what you did there. Bashing crazy ideas became 'bashing conservatives'. Because they so often come up with crazy ideas? It's still fair and proper to bash crazy ideas. The notion that it isn't, may be another crazy idea. And I wonder who promotes that idea?
- k__ 6y agoI heard, in Austria they use all degrees as titles. My girlfriend would get emails starting with "Sehr geehrte Frau Magistra XYZ,..."
- ginko 6y agoYeah, from an Austrian perspective the whole doctor title discussion in the US was sort of bizarre. Of course you call yourself doctor if you have a doctor's degree.
- ghaff 6y agoThe US is just not really into titles. We make exceptions for the clergy and medicine--and to a more limited degree within academia. But a lot of people find an insistence on titles in other contexts off putting. Per another comment. Look at a typical event registration form in the US. These days you probably have Mr., Ms., and prefer not to say. Fill one out for a (non-tech) event in the UK or Europe and you may have dozens of titles to choose from.
- iso1210 6y ago> The US is just not really into titles Except when it comes to military worship.
- masswerk 6y agoIt's kind of difficult. :-) First, yes, academic titles are actually part of your name by law, which is extraordinarily weird. It's in your passport, in full abbreviated form, designating the faculty. (Like "Mag. phil." or "Dr. rer. soc. oec.", etc. I involuntarily checked into various hotels under the first name "Phil", because of this.) On the other hand, there are those who actually use a title in everyday life, even insist on it being used, and those, who merely ignore it for the most (reserved for interaction with potentially hostile bureaucracy, etc.) Using a title as an author is obviously a no go (with the probable exception of MDs), but it may happen. (A useful hint to not to buy a book.) Rather recently, we have even seen an inflation in academic titles, starting with commercial schools being upgraded to universities and their titles becoming academic titles, as well. Applied universities were rolled out at scale with titles first marked by a distinctive appendix "FH", which was later allowed to be dropped, for it having been perceived as a stigma. There's now a movement to grant masters of trade automatically the academic title of master. Then, there are bureaucratic and occupational titles, carefully chiselling out the exact position in the hierarchy, which enjoy frequent use in addresses of all kind. However, these are merely ornamental and are not part of your name. Lastly there's a third, highly ambiguous category, which is probably the most famous one, being the titles of "Professor" and "Hofrat" (Court Councillor), granted by the federal president. So Professor may be someone with habilitation and occupying a sede at a university, or it may be a merely honorary title, for the most reserved for celebrities of the cultural field, e.g. opera singers arriving at a certain age. Likewise, Hofrat is used in some parts of the country as a bureaucratic title on the federal state level ("wirklicher Hofrat", coming with its own pay grade), but its also a honorary title reserved for high ranking civil officers as some kind of no costs gratification for lifetime achievements, just before the transformation into a Lipizzaner as the final apotheosis. (There's also a complementary "Kommerzialrat" for ageing dignitaries of the commercial field. However, as this is quite unambiguous, it's also considered of slightly lesser interest.) (Quite opposed to this, any medals of honour are never yours, considered just on loan, and are expected to be returned in the case of your death. You're even prohibited from wearing them, with the exception of a few, regulated events, like the Vienna Opera Ball.) --- Edit: As a more serious explanation, Dr was the sole academic degree for almost all of the time and it was only granted by universities proper. It was only in the 1980s that a new academic system was adopted, introducing the intermediary degree of Magister, which came at sometimes three times the effort as compared to a doctorate in the previous system. So it was recognized as well, but with mixed reception. Meanwhile, we switched to the PhD system with an even more inflated system of titles, associated with varying degrees of esteem, use and general recognition.
- hanche 6y agoAnecdote time: I spent the academic year 1980/81 as a visitor at the University of Toronto. I stayed at Massey College. They would add letters behind everybody's names on doors and the list of residents to indicate their academic degree. But they couldn't make any sense out of my Norwegian degree (cand.real.), so they used esq. instead.
- MaggieL 6y agoPolitical screed not up to AOs usual standards.
- cascom 6y agoWhat’s missing in a lot of this conversation is the spoken vs written honorific. There are many professions/designations that people may wish to be identified (often times reflective of their profession, work, achievements) e.g. Maj. Gen. Jane Smith, Ret. John Smith, P.E. Jane Smith, CPA The Honorable John Smith Dr. Jane Smith, PhD John Smith, Esq. All these written forms of address convey something about the person yet, verbally they would be Mr. Miss/Ms/Mrs when addressed (leaving aside the rabbit hole of Dr / PhD thing for the moment)- point being that there is difference in taking pride (even if to outsiders you may wonder why (appending MBA?!?!) it doesn’t change they way they are addressed verbally.
- ghaff 6y agoFor that matter, there are people who append laundry lists of professional certs to their name in work emails. I guess it really depends.Things like PE, CPA, CFA, assuming they're relevant to your current position, make a lot of sense in a professional context. Appending MBA, ME, much less SB/BS, would just seem weird. (Unless it's specifically in an alumni context.)
- canadianfella 6y agoThose people are typically shitty at their job, in my experience.
- SeanLuke 6y agoI'd be interested in the history of how people in the medical profession came to misappropriate the term Doctor (which IIRC referred only to a PhD).
- barry-cotter 6y agoUniversities started out as trade schools for the clergy, lawyers and doctors. The Ph.D. significantly postdates that. The title of doctor originally meant you were qualified to lecture. It was in use long before anyone was granted a Ph.D. as an honorific basically equivalent to calling someone learned.
- andrewmcwatters 6y ago> Universities started out as trade schools for the clergy, lawyers and doctors. You mean, "the clergy, lawyers and physicians?" :)
- andrewmcwatters 6y agoOn a separate note, I don't understand why socially we've come to associate one type of doctorate (usually an M.D.?), for a physician, as the only type of "Doctor" when we're talking about a physician. I assume it's just a historical convention? I have no skin in this game, but today it seems rather rude to not consider other doctors, "Doctors," but OK to consider just physicians, colloquially a "Doctor", a "Doctor." If I had a Ph.D. you'd damn well be sure I wanted people to acknowledge my doctorate, even if it was in something else, such as mathematics, law, or education.
- underseacables 6y agoThere’s a lot of professions that desperately want to be seen as medical doctors, but they lack the training and education to do so. A lot of healthcare licensure is built around that ideal, but if you give someone an exclusive scope of practice, with lots of fancy titles, through a little mirror action they could make themselves appear as doctors. Probably the worst of this is the registered dietitians.
- ghaff 6y agoIt's all historical convention. My personal feeling is that it's perfectly understandable to highlight relevant research doctorates in a research/academic setting. Yes, it's a status thing but it's understandable. Otherwise? Eh. Why PhDs and certain other "doctorates" and not Masters and other post-undergraduate degrees that may (or may not) also involve substantial original research?
- usrusr 6y agoOf all the people who have lived in the centuries since the term doctor got established, a very large majority hasn't ever interacted with a doctor that wasn't of the medical kind. From this perspective any weirdness surrounding the term/terms becomes rather unsurprising.
- fortran77 6y ago> The minor debate over Lady Dr. Jill Biden’s title, which came up shortly after her husband’s election, may seem completely ridiculous and insulting, which it is, but it’s also the latest in a line of kerfuffles relating to how people in power in the United States present themselves "Ridiculous and insulting?", not really. There's a long history of people mocking "Ed.D" holders calling themselves "Dr." outside of specific contexts. (Like on a paper or publication that's related to your field, etc.) And an Ed.D. is not a Ph.D. You don't see people with JD degrees calling themselves "Doctor" or even using the term "Esquire" outside of specific contexts, like on an article of incorporation for their Professional Corporation. etc. You may see the actual degree indicated (Ph.D, Ed. D) after a name on a professional paper, etc. But not the term "Dr." For an example take, see this blog posting from 2017, before anyone was thinking of First Lady Biden or her title: https://headinthesandblog.org/2017/06/ed-d-school-leaders-demand-called-doctor-please-get/#:~:text=If%20you%E2%80%99re%20an%20Ed.D%20running%20a%20school%20or,in%20your%20email%20signature%20and%20your%20online%20bio https://headinthesandblog.org/2017/06/ed-d-school-leaders-de.... Also see Wikipedia on this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_of_Education#Comparisons_of_the_EdD_to_the_PhD_in_education_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_of_Education#Comparison... And this article negates its own point in its conclusion! It says "lawyers can use the term Esquire, but not many do." Michelle Obama, by all accounts a competent attorney, never demanded to be called "Lady Dr. Michelle Obama, Esquire" even though with her J.D. and admission to the bar it would be logical. She would have been mocked the same way Jill Biden was.
- eplanit 6y agoYes. If you have a PhD and you were an academic or researcher or practitioner, then fine call yourself "doctor". If, like jill Biden, you never really applied yourself in that domain as a professional career, then get over yourself. I guess we'll overturn those conventions now for the sake of politics.
- rayiner 6y ago> This was the same time that the idea of a gentry emerged in England: People who are not noble, but certainly not peasants, either. They were people worthy of being ranked above somebody in the social hierarchy. So esquire had come to suggest moderate respectability with a dash of prestigious servitude. This part is on point to a lot of contemporary society.
- buserror 6y agoIt's still used in England -- my accountant (old school) writes to me as "Mr M xxx, Esq" -- and I'm not a lawyer. It is supposed to be a form of politeness when mentioning someone else's name.
- philbo 6y agoEsq should not be combined with Mr though, it's either/or.
- JCM9 6y agoBoth the medical and legal professions engaged in “degree inflation” when awarding “doctorates” for degrees that don’t meet the academic qualifications for a traditional doctorate degree. The medical profession took it further and wanted to be called “doctor” (traditionally an academic title reserved for those with the highest degrees in a subject, with the title literally meaning “to teach.”) The medical community makes a big deal about the title thing and it’s broadly rooted in attempts by previous generations of physicians to be seen as a respected and legitimate profession. Until well into the early 20th century that was a struggle for physicians, who were often viewed as crack pots that engaged in wild unscientific practices—-because that was true for many. Medical school was a joke at the time by modern standards. So for all the reasons above when any physician tries to suggest that a physician is the only “real doctor” you can roll your eyes and suggest they crack open a history book and then let them go back to stroking their own ego. JDs never really went the same path but did take up this odd practice of using “Esquire.” Elsewhere in the world Esq is typically used to formally address young gentlemen without any other title. If your teenage son gets a bank account in the UK their the statements will come addressed to Joe Blogs Esq. To anyone with broader worldwide exposure to titles, this makes the use of the title by lawyers in the US hilarious because it makes the person look like they’re taking the title of some kid in the UK.
- tryptophan 6y ago>So for all the reasons above when any physician tries to suggest that a physician is the only “real doctor” you can roll your eyes and suggest they crack open a history book and then let them go back to stroking their own ego. I think you are misunderstanding what their issue is. They aren't mad about people calling themselves 'doctors' in general society, but in a medical setting. You have nurses, PAs, chiropractors, naturopaths all calling themselves a 'doctor' in a medical setting, all trying to associate themselves with the rigor and expertise an MD would grant. As to the origin of the title in a medical setting, you may be right, but it has been used that way for a long time now. Being pedantic about its usage isn't helpful when there are lots of bad actors trying to confuse people by referring to its commonly understood meaning.
- 6y ago
- kova12 6y agoI do like this amendment! I'd say, if it's not a thing, it should be passed.
- citizenpaul 6y ago"Wanker" Sorry couldn't help it.
- joshuaheard 6y agoI learned a different history of the term Esquire in law school. As the article says, the term Esquire was first used to describe the person who helped a Knight by handing him weapons and helping him get up in their heavy armor after getting knocked to the ground in a joust. So how did it become ascribed to a modern-day lawyer? When you think of a legal trial, you think of Tom Cruise in A Few Good Men ("You can't handle the truth!"). But before this modern trial by jury, there were many types of trials in the Middle Ages. There was Trial by Fire, where people walked over hot coals. If they were not injured, they were innocent. There was also Trial by Combat where the accused had to fight the King's Champion. Since the King's Champion, usually a knight, had his own esquire, the accused was given an esquire as well to assist the accused in the trial. Later, when the more civilized Trial by Jury became the norm, an esquire assisting the accused remained an essential feature. The term Esquire grew to include an office of trust for the King and his court. In America, a lawyer, the person assisting the accused in a court of law, also became a trusted officer of the court of law, with the title Esquire. Of course in America, where there is no formal peerage or titles, the title of Esquire is mainly traditional, and not a formal feature of the judicial system.
- bradknowles 6y agoKnights actually had “Squires”, not “Esquires”. A Squire was a person to assist you in all your Knightly activities, not just in helping you in combat or a jousting tournament. Squires were also usually expensive, and therefore some Knights might not have a Squire at all, they might have just one Squire, or they might have multiple Squires. The relationship between Knight and Squire was very much like the relationship between any other type of Master and his Apprentice. There were also Men-At-Arms who were further down the totem pole from Squires. The concept of “Esquire” came later.
- halostatue 6y agoThe article addresses this. The French term for squire was `escuier`, or shield-bearer. So squire and esquire are the same thing. > This is where esquires come into play. The word itself derives from Old French, and in turn from Latin, where it means something like “shield-holder.” In the 1200s and 1300s in England, a variety of languages were used, so such figures might be referred to as the Latin armiger (“arms-holder,”) or scutifer (“shield-bearer”), or the French escuier, which became “esquire.” These terms all refer to roughly similar people. This role was generally considered moderately prestigious for young men of some wealth, but at its core it was a service job. You carry a knight’s stuff, tend to his horses, that kind of thing. “Esquire” and “squire” were names for the same gig for a few hundred years.
- andrew_ 6y agoIs it commonplace for Atlas Obscura to include social and/or political commentary now? This is the first I've seen of an author there opining, and it's quite disappointing.
- Aloha 6y agoWhat of this is social or political commentary?
- carlob 6y agoIt's not atlas obscura, it's reality that has a clear liberal bias
- pochamago 6y agoThis is a fairly political statement to put into an article on the linguistic history of a word: >The unstated goal of all this talk is a gross collection of sexism, elite gatekeeping, anti-elitism in general, and a simple partisan attack on the Biden administration
- bink 6y agoI am curious about the statement: "In California, Arizona, and the District of Columbia, local bar associations have penalized or advised against any non-lawyer (or suspended lawyer) from appending “Esquire” to their names, as it may erroneously signal the capacity to practice law." If the title carries no legal weight how can a bar association "penalize" a non-lawyer for using it? I ask because I have a friend who is a lawyer and used to include "Esquire" in his email signature. As a jab at him I started doing the same in group emails and he (jokingly) suggested I could be pursued legally for using that title.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoF*ck you Atlas Obscura. You make it so painful to find a way to refuse your cookies. One of the darkest patterns I've seen in a while. I'm so tired of this. Most of the websites I'd like to visit, AND most of the websites that I find on HN, are now a privacy/cookies hell.
- Fjolsvith 6y agohttp://annavonreitz.com/documents/fyi.pdf http://annavonreitz.com/documents/fyi.pdf