3 ms·
Yeah, it makes a lot of sense for that sort of power to be a dice roll. If the system is completely deterministic then people start gaming it and the result is
by roenxi 6y ago
Yeah, it makes a lot of sense for that sort of power to be a dice roll. If the system is completely deterministic then people start gaming it and the result is politics. It is better to allow the dice to roll than to mandate everyone goes with a bad choice.
I see a call in your comment for rewards to be given out of innate qualities rather than observed outcomes. If you have a method for determining that; how about we do a small trial in politics first - where it would do more good - and argue about how well it worked? There is no evidence in my view that it is possible to determine people's innate qualities from a distance. The difference between a genius and a fool is too slim. It is doubtful that there has ever been a method to do that which worked.
Between, say, the American way of embarrassing riches and the EU way of equality I note one didn't produce many tech companies.
- warent 6y agoInteresting argument that gives me something to think about. Though the last line doesn't make much sense to me. Between, say, the American way of embarrassing riches and the EU way of equality I note one didn't produce many tech companies You seem to be implying that producing many tech companies is somehow indicative of a superior result. It's borderline heresy to argue otherwise in HN of all places, but are we certain about that?
- throwawaysea 6y ago> Between, say, the American way of embarrassing riches and the EU way of equality I note one didn't produce many tech companies. This is a great point that is often ignored. People like to claim that X or Y EU nation is better governed than the US or enjoys greater happiness. However they are also beneficiaries of all the innovation that has come out of America for them to have those standards of living - things like the smartphones and the Internet in recent times.
- truprajutr 6y agoHow about www (invented at CERN)?
- stass 6y agoWhat was invented in CERN was hypertext. WWW and internet was largely built and commercialized in US. I think it’s fair to say that a lot of innovative technologies were invented in Europe, but most of them end up being commercialized in US due to market incentives and the whole funding and support infrastructure these incentives created.
- truprajutr 6y agoBy "inventing the WWW" I meant designing HTTP and HTML as well as implementing the browser and the server software. This all was done by Berners-Lee around 1990.