3 ms·
Why create a new weird text format for locating a person, when you could use RP records (rfc1183) to provide an email address and a reference to a freeform text
by toast0 6y ago
Why create a new weird text format for locating a person, when you could use RP records (rfc1183) to provide an email address and a reference to a freeform text record.
- teddyh 6y agoPrecisely this. The DNS already supports exactly what he is proposing to instead do with some sort of JSON monstrosity.
- alangibson 6y agoJSON doesn't have anything to do with it. That was just the response from Cloudflare's DoH endpoint. The heart of the idea was using a SPF-ish TXT record.
- teddyh 6y agoStill, it would be better to use the existing RP record type (with included additional TXT link) than to make up YET ANOTHER overloading of TXT.
- alangibson 6y ago> Why create a new weird text format for locating a person, when you could use RP records (rfc1183) Because they aren't the same thing. RP records designate the person responsible for the domain, which may or may not be the person that the domain identifies. RP records also assume the user has an email address. That's been a bad assumption for long time now.