3 ms·
The problem with electronic voting machines, is no matter how secure you make them, people find the narrative that they are insecure easily believable, regardle
by skissane 6y ago
The problem with electronic voting machines, is no matter how secure you make them, people find the narrative that they are insecure easily believable, regardless of whether the narrative is true or not in any particular case.
If you stick entirely to paper-based voting, you don't have that problem. Of course low-tech means of fraud still exist (stuffing ballot boxes, etc), but there are low-tech means of presenting that – you allow each candidate/party to send poll observers to watch the counting process.
- cortesoft 6y agoYep, I changed my view on electronic voting for this reason. Even if we create a perfect, provable, electronic voting system, a very small percentage of the public is going to be able to understand the proof and even fewer will be able to verify for themselves. Most people will have to rely on experts to tell them if it is secure or not. For voting, we need most people to be able to both understand why it is secure and be able to verify for themselves that it is. Paper ballots provide that, electronic voting doesn’t.
- mjevans 6y agoElectronic fast counting on deposit for in-person voting? Sure, but I like mail in a lot better. I am OK with electronic printing of human legible votes; if you want to get fancy. (Fill the bubbles in fully)
- hunter2_ 6y agoThere's always the issue of not being able to verify for oneself. We tend to trust video, but what if it's video of something tainted (or a straight up deepfake)? If poll workers hand off ballots to separate counters, but publicly hired counters are diverted and provided with plausible decoys while poll workers actually hand off to secret actors who just capture and release video of the public counters... back to the Swiss cheese we go.
- smichel17 6y agoThis is extremely difficult to pull off at scale without being caught.
- iso1210 6y agoThis is the key. Hacking a traditional X-in-the-box and count-in-public ballot at scale is impossible. Yes I could go to a neighbouring ward and claim I'm Joe Bloggs and vote as him. That will work until he turns up later and they tell him he's already voted. Do that once or twice and it may avoid press coverage. Do it a lot and it's going to get coverage.
- fit2rule 6y agoIf you cannot trust a computer to take your vote, why would you trust it to keep your life safe and the train on the rails, or the plane in the air? This distrust of voting machines is only happening because the voting machines are NOT trust-worthy. If we were to build trustworthy voting machines, they'd probably be best modelled on other safety-critical systems.