10 ms·
Wow, that's outlandish. For some perspective this guy's hands would have been cut off in Saudi Arabia. At the end of the day (assuming this isn't some fake ad c
by 3pt14159 15y ago
Wow, that's outlandish. For some perspective this guy's hands would have been cut off in Saudi Arabia. At the end of the day (assuming this isn't some fake ad campaign) dude lost his right to privacy when he stole the laptop. The victim has a right to remotely control his property, especially when it has been stolen.
As for a crime lower than stealing my bicycle: That's crazy. Even if you have a bicycle worth more than your laptop, the loss of time and possible identity theft that could happen with a lost laptop more than outweighs the financial loss of either.
- loy22 15y agoWhen it comes to justice Saudi Arabia is not an inspiring example, I'm not interested in this perspective. Their system is stuck in the medieval era, why should we take any pride from such a comparaison ? I'm uneasy with this kind of plastering as well, it has this "mob lynching" vibe that is often for the worst rather than the best. It appeals to our worst instincts, and you can sense that the author is angry and we are helping him to punish this guy when we look at this. I felt dirty to be honest. If you don't believe it, ask yourself: why didn't he blur his face ? Would his message be less efficient ?
- raganwald 15y agoYou see where you and I are coming from different places? My understanding is that in Saudi Arabia, the thief's hands would be cut off after a trial. Which is my point. I did not question someone remotely controlling their property. I questioned someone publishing certain pictures in a blog regardless of how they obtained them. Now onto a subjective matter. A bicycle is a highly personal item for many people. It may not involve identity theft, but for some people it involves a loss of freedom and mobility that can't be replaced easily. My current bicycle has been highly personalized for my use. Having it stolen would be like having a bit of my soul stolen. If you don't feel the same way about your bike, I quite understand. UPDATE: You said that "The dude lost his right to privacy when he stole a laptop." Did you notice what you just did? You convicted someone of an offence without trying them in a court of law. If we were in a jurisdiction where murder is a capital offence, you could use exactly the same logic for lynching and hanging a man without bothering to try him. He lost his right to life when he murdered, and we know he murdered, so fetch a rope and a horse. Now some (strawman alert) might say that the evidence is overwhelming. Well, where do we draw the line? What's the rule for "We don't need a trial?" Pictures on the Internet? Eyewitness accounts?? Confessions? All of these have been proved unreliable in the past, which is why we have trials.
- djackson 15y ago1. Person A has a laptop 2. Person A no longer has a laptop. Person A did not sell or give away this laptop. The laptop was stolen. 3. Person B now has the missing laptop. Conclusion: Person B is in possession of a stolen laptop.
- raganwald 15y agoThis is fine line or argument, but don't you think it belongs in a courtroom, being made to a jury that has been shown all of the evidence and who will also hear the accused make his own arguments for his innocence?
- dtegart 15y agoThe website appears to have been created in response to the inability of the police to bring the person, allegedly responsible, into a courtroom to explain why he is in possession of a stolen laptop.
- wnoise 15y agoThat's definitely required before bringing the resources of the state to bear in punishing the person. If you're not doing that, then no, it needn't be.
- rosser 15y agoIsn't possession of stolen property prima facie proof of guilt of ... possession of stolen property?
- Periodic 15y agoIs buying stolen property, which you seller does not tell you is stolen, over Craig's List equivalent to stealing the item? Should the buyer be jailed?
- by 15y agoNo. The police possess a great deal of stolen property. The entire police force would collapse into a blue hole if they had to arrest everybody in possession of stolen property. The crime is knowing it is stolen and having no intent to return it.
- MBlume 15y agoI think by 'lower' he means 'worse', or 'more despicable', so you guys don't actually disagree on that.
- jhamburger 15y agoI'm not sure what perspective Saudi Arabia's laws give us. In Saudi Arabia homosexuality is punishable by death, does that give us any perspective of how they should be treated here?
- mike_organon 15y agoYes, that's better than a lynch mob with no rule of law.
- nske 15y agoIs it, really? I for once would pick living amongst a disorganized mob who would lynch me upon suspicion of doing something that I also consider unjust, over an organized society that would punish me, through the best procedures, for something that I find my fundamental right. Neither case is ideal, obviously, but it's better for a society to miss procedures than a sense of individual rights. Also, I think it is far easier for a society to build procedures/laws than change radically its perceptions on what is right and what is wrong.
- Brashman 15y agoI think his point is that although the guy whose photo was taken probably stole the laptop, we shouldn't jump to that conclusion without a proper trial. For instance, maybe he bought it from the thief off craigslist. I don't know how that gets sorted out by law, but I wouldn't blame the person who bought it and wouldn't want his face posted on the internet.
- mishmash 15y ago>For instance, maybe he bought it from the thief off craigslist. Could be but one could also speculate the other direction. What if the robbery occurred in a very short time span, and the photo of him driving away was taken (assuming it was time and location stamped) during that time and in the immediate vicinity of the crime? This would make it unlikely that a third party transaction had occurred.
- BlazingFrog 15y agoWhich is precisely why modern civilized societies have a judicial system. To reach a verdict based on actual facts and evidence. Not some "what ifs". [edited for typos]
- mishmash 15y agoSo the current facts are that: a) the guy owns a laptop b) he took pictures using it Sounds like he's in the clear to post them anywhere he likes then?
- ElliotH 15y agoI own a netbook - its quite small and could be easily hidden behind a sofa or something, lets say I leave it somewhere private - maybe a hidden corner of someone's house (a friends house, I didn't break in). I take some photos with it it. Does it sound like I'm in the clear to post them anywhere I like?
- 15y ago