4 ms·
The mRNA vaccines were completed within a week or two with modern technology. It took nearly a year to test: prove that it was safe, prove that it was effective
by dragontamer 6y ago
The mRNA vaccines were completed within a week or two with modern technology. It took nearly a year to test: prove that it was safe, prove that it was effective (preventing deaths, preventing hospitalizations, preventing symptoms).
This blogpost completely ignores the difficult proof issue.
- nostromo 6y agoWe could have tested it in two weeks with paid volunteers. The pay for brave vaccine testers could have literally been $1m and we’d have saved several trillion bucks and potentially over a million lives. Hell, make it $10m or $100m and you'd still save a ton of money. We've done this for several other viruses: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_challenge_study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_challenge_study
- biggieshellz 6y agoWe could test that it's safe, yes. Effective, no. You have to have the people out in the community, for both the vaccinated group and the control group, and then compare who gets infected in each group. The testing actually took less time than they expected due to the unfortunately-high prevalence of COVID-19 in the community.
- nostromo 6y agoNo, the testers would be directly exposed as part of the trial, which is why they'd be compensated -- as opposed to waiting around for 9 months for some percent of people to be exposed.
- dragontamer 6y agoAnd the control / placebo group? You're really going to force testers to potentially pick up the placebo, and then inject them with COVID19 forcefully? I mean yeah, it'd work, but its generally considered immoral under today's philosophy of science.
- maxerickson 6y agoWhy wouldn't they be willing volunteers? It would be quite possible for it to clearly be informed consent also, at least to the extent the disease was characterized at that point in time. The reason people keep bringing it up is that the consequences of the pandemic have been much worse than the consequences of allowing a few thousand people to intentionally expose themselves to an infection in a controlled setting¹. It's not guaranteed that challenge trials would have mitigated the pandemic, but it's weird to just outright circumscribe the possibility when the ongoing downside is huge. 1. I use the odd phrasing here because lots of people pretty much choose to expose themselves to the infection anyway; maybe not explicitly, but close enough.
- marvin 6y agoWould it be immoral if they were offered a million dollars?Honest question, because it feels like the philosophy might not match up with common experience. It feels like an interesting question. People voluntarily risk worse for less pay in other fields, e.g. the military. And if it wasn't immoral, what is the dollar limit?
- dragontamer 6y agoMoney is worth different amounts to different people. Bill Gates or Jeff Bezos will never risk their life for "only" a million bucks. Find a depressed + suicidal dude somewhere else, and they may be personally willing to risk their life for just $100. Making an industry of people who are willing to harm themselves for money is... probably not the business we should be encouraging. And that's assuming everyone is "playing nice". At a minimum, it means that we'll be inclined to start experimenting upon the poor and depressed (and then shedding away moral qualms because they signed a piece of paper). Historically speaking in the USA, we have legacies like the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, where African Americans were chosen as the control group and lied to about getting a Syphilis treatment: leading to a generation+ long distrust in science. Yeah yeah, we can't "assume" scientists will be racist jackasses today. But... we still have to account for what happened in our history and why certain testing methodologies have become taboo.
- reillyse 6y agoTotal ethical failure here. You are supposed to not make people ill.
- nostromo 6y ago2,000,000+ people are dead because we didn't take this path. The risk to testers under 40 would have been negligible. I'm not being flippant about other peoples' lives -- I would have signed up myself if the compensation was high enough.
- dragontamer 6y ago> The risk to testers under 40 would have been negligible. Luke Letlow (age 41) says otherwise, since he's dead. Okay, he's above 40, but he's high-profile and easy for me to remember. Plenty of sub 40 year olds have died. Even among the survivors... plenty of young and healthy 20-30 year olds are having month-long recoveries, unable to breath at their old capacity. Purposefully damaging the control group (who by definition, must NOT receive the vaccine) is immoral. Whether people in the control group believe in the potential harms of the disease or not.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 6y ago"One person died" isn't a refutation, it's just an appeal to emotion. Under 40 the survival rate is 99.98% for everyone -- including the already ill. If you screened for comorbidities and gave people great healthcare, you could get that 99.999% or higher. And save millions of lives (and trillions of dollars) by doing so.
- dragontamer 6y ago> Under 40 the survival rate is 99.98% for everyone -- including the already ill I doubt that. But I'm not entirely sure how to calculate the numbers you just said. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm I realize this page changes, so I've taken a screenshot here: https://imgur.com/0iM5FHC https://imgur.com/0iM5FHC This is the chart of who died in January 2021. Yes, most deaths are aged 65+, but there's been deaths in all age categories. I doubt its 99.98% as you suggest (especially since the current case-mortality-rate is ~2.5%, at least for my state) The official CDC numbers are stratified from 35 to 44, I'm not entirely sure who you are citing to get "below 40" age groups.
- namesbc 6y agoIn order to use this method to test a vaccine for deployment to people over 65, you need people over 65 in your control group. This means you are choosing people to murder.
- tinus_hn 6y agoA ridiculous exaggeration; you’re asking for volunteers to take a risk. Not killing them. People can decide for themselves to take risks. You may not agree with the choices they make and that is your problem. Not theirs.
- namesbc 6y agoNo, I am saying that volunteer challenge trials don't test what want to test so their results are useless at best, and murder at worst.
- maxerickson 6y agoDo separate branches then. Use challenge trials to accelerate deployment to under 30s (or whatever) and natural infection for other age brackets. I honestly haven't thought deeply about the ethics, but it's really concerning that it has become such a hard rule that preventing people from injuring themselves in a particular way (we don't prevent lots of other forms of injury) is somehow obviously superior to letting tens of thousands of people die for lack of information.
- namesbc 6y agoThe vaccine is going to be deployed to communities at risk first, you can't test vulnerable populations via volunteer challenge trials.
- maxerickson 6y agoThat's circular. If the challenge trial is successful, start deploying it to the groups tested using that method and then shift to the at risk groups as data justifies it. It won't hurt the at risk groups to start up high volume manufacturing earlier (it will likely help them), and there is a benefit to everyone each time anyone is vaccinated (the reduction in transmission efficiency).
- aqme28 6y agoI don't think that's true. You still need to study the testers over a period of time. With a human challenge study you can get by with fewer testers and a little less time, but it won't be that different.