4 ms·
So, is anything from the nuclear documents in the book you mentioned? Or is it really all lost forever?
by simonebrunozzi 6y ago
So, is anything from the nuclear documents in the book you mentioned? Or is it really all lost forever?
- DennisP 6y agoThe documents themselves are lost, but Ellsberg was deeply involved in nuclear strategy and in the past few years has been able to get public declassified sources for much of what he remembered. The previously-classified history of US nuclear strategy is mostly what the book is about. (See my cousin comment for a short outline.)
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoThanks a lot!
- redis_mlc 6y agoYou can just watch the movie "Dr. Strangelove." People thought it was SciFi, but it was actually a documentary. The nuclear silo launch code for decades was "000000" to save time to launch. Also, Reagan and Russia didn't care about some goofy MAD doctrine - they wanted actual ABM defenses. That's why there's an ABM ring allowed by treaty around Moscow, and why Reagan funded SDI (lasers weren't implemented, but anti-missile missiles were.) Reagan thought MAD was immoral if you could build a real defense, and he was right. Something most people don't know is that Russia seriously planned to nuke Beijing durng their 1969 border dispute, but the US found out and told them not to. The CCP did their "wolf warrior" b.s. on Russia, and after the Russians had enough they decided to root out the problem once and for all. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-Soviet_border_conflict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-Soviet_border_conflict Ironically, the CCP asked Russia to declare a joint war on the US in the 50's and 60's twice for communist ideological reasons, but Russia laughed them off since there was no practical advantage for Russia. Although Russia's weapons worked just fine, the US over-estimated Russian belligerence and grossly under-estimated the CCP. The US Democrats are obsessed with the Russians, but it's the CCP that is completely unhinged. Xi wants to be god on earth over all other countries.
- mhh__ 6y agoThat was only one step in many many codes - you couldn't just get a job in a launch silo and press boom
- lr1970 6y agoIIRC, during the Korea war there were people at Pentagon proposing to nuke China over their support for the North.
- redis_mlc 6y agoIt went far beyond merely proposing. Nuclear-armed B-29's were flown to Guam and Japan. I think Truman even delegated the decision to drop them to Ridgeway, meaning Truman pre-authorized their use based on a common understanding it was a last resort. Truman's public statements were that all weapons were on the table, including nuclear.
- fit2rule 6y ago>Although Russia's weapons worked just fine, the US over-estimated Russian belligerence and grossly under-estimated the CCP. Imagine if the people of Russia and USA could unite with Europe and form the basis of a new state. Seems like it'd be worth the effort a bit more than going to Mars. Or, maybe the two conditions will be .. related.
- nabla9 6y agoThe US nuclear strategy at time was called massive retaliation. 'massive retaliation' was strategy where the US committed itself to response in much greater nuclear strike in the event of an attack, even conventional attack by Soviets. Kennedy abandoned that strategy during Cuban crisis when he saw that it didn't really work and was insane. It was simply not credible that US would commit losing 80-100 million people after single event. The US and NATO nuclear deterrence moved to what is now known as flexible response. The response to attack will be proportional.
- coolgeek 6y agoThere seems to be a bit of confusion here. I surmise that what was "lost forever" was only a copy of the documents. I base that on common sense, as well as this from the linked article (about the Pentagon Papers): > So Mr. Sheehan smuggled the papers out of the apartment in Cambridge, Mass., where Mr. Ellsberg had stashed them; then he copied them illicitly, just as Mr. Ellsberg had done, and took them to The Times. (Of course, I could be the one that is confused here, misreading this discussion. But I don't think that is the case)
- DennisP 6y agoYes, it was Ellsberg's copies of the nuclear strategy documents that were lost. The original documents were still in a classified safe in the Pentagon. Some were later declassified, long after they were obsolete, and probably some have never seen the light of day.