3 ms·
it's more that their morality includes compliance with the laws of the states they operate in. It always has, and they will buck those laws on extremely rare oc
by shadowgovt 6y ago
it's more that their morality includes compliance with the laws of the states they operate in. It always has, and they will buck those laws on extremely rare occasions, usually when they believe they are seeing a mis-implementation of the laws, and (when outside the US) usually by ceasing to do business in the territory (see: Google's pullback from China).
None of what we're seeing in Pakistan right now is new for tech company SOP. Google Maps shows different borders depending on the location of the originating query. Twitter masks certain tweets for users in Germany because some speech that's legal in the US is illegal in Germany and the penalties are harsh for propagating it.
It's a big world, and the US doesn't have a monopoly on law or ethics in the international community.
- babesh 6y agoThat is a load of bullshit. Google tried to get back into China (see Project Dragonfly). Did China change the offending laws in the meantime? How are those Tianamen Square searches doing in China on those Apple phones? What kind of person or entity hides under the pretense that it’s the law and you have to always follow it? Nuremberg trials defense? Separate but equal? South Africa anyone? All I have to do is to do is change the law and then suddenly it’s moral. Slavery moral one day, not moral the next. Moral on this side of the line but not moral on the other. One day the emperor says that red hats are against the law, the next day you can only wear red hats. Wait, 1984! A morality grounded on adherence to the law is no morality at all. It only lets the levers of law be pulled by those with other ideas on morality or the lack thereof.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt's important not to run so fast from 1984 that one runs into Snow Crash. If corporations are setting morality apart from the law, they become another authority. Then we have a different set of problems; at least in some countries, the government authority is elected. CEOs aren't elected by the people, and the emperor has nothing on the whims of Jeff Bezos or Jack Dorsey.
- babesh 6y agoBoth are problematic and both are occurring right now.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago> "their morality includes compliance with the laws of the states they operate in. It always has" I will believe it when they pay their taxes
- shadowgovt 6y agoThey pay all the taxes they are legally required to pay.