5 ms·
>The bill would make it clear that Section 230, [...] does not apply to ads or other paid content seems reasonable >does not impair the enforcement of civil r
by gruez 6y ago
>The bill would make it clear that Section 230, [...] does not apply to ads or other paid content
seems reasonable
>does not impair the enforcement of civil rights laws
what types of civil rights abuses were protected by section 230? I'm under the impression that saying/posting racial slurs isn't illegal.
> and does not bar wrongful-death actions.
what's the current bar for suing an establishment for wrongful death? if a bunch of radicals met at a bar and plotted to murder someone, would the bar be responsible if they didn't intervene?
- krapp 6y ago>what types of civil rights abuses were protected by section 230? I'm under the impression that saying/posting racial slurs isn't illegal. Many people seem to believe that moderating platforms and banning accounts or otherwise enforcing terms of service for any content or behavior which isn't strictly illegal is a violation of their civil rights, and that this abuse is enabled by Section 230. They believe that any alteration of user submitted content makes the "platform" no longer a "platform" but a "publisher" and that they should be legally liable for that content.
- 0xB31B1B 6y agothe "meet at a bar to plot a murder" metaphor isn't at all how the the tech companies faciliate these things. Its more like if the group meets at a bar, and exclusively communicated through with each other through the bartender. In that case, would the bartender have an obligation to tell law enforcement that a group at the bar was planning a murder? I think so.
- cmdli 6y agoI think "communicating through the barkeeper" makes the barkeeper's involvement sound much more intentional than it actually would be. It's more like if a group regularly gathered at the bar, using the barkeeper's space and supplies, and planned a murder. The barkeeper might have a responsibility to listen in to the conversation and report if they are planning a crime, and the group is using the barkeeper's space to organize, but it's not like the barkeeper ever agreed for that specific group to use their space.
- devonbleak 6y agoBut the platforms have perfect knowledge of the text content of these conversations. It's not unreasonable to say they have near-perfect knowledge of the graphic and A/V content also - that stuff is easily automatically parsed at this point and they're likely already doing that parsing. Hell it's part of their business model for increasing the value of their ads.
- Jtsummers 6y ago> But the platforms have perfect knowledge of the text content of these conversations. "[P]erfect knowledge"? They have knowledge of the text. You can even say they have perfectly accurate knowledge of the text. Do they have perfect comprehension and understanding of the text? They have some comprehension and understanding in order to direct ads. But it is not perfect comprehension and understanding. And unless you're content with your apparently violent talk that's actually about a guild raid in WoW getting blasted by an AI, they need humans to ultimately decide what to do about content.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Jtsummers 6y agoThat example also fails. Without a very high degree of oversight of content, Twitter, Facebook, et al. are often unaware of what's actually posted. Not in the sense that it's unknowable, but that the technical systems facilitating the communication are just that, technical systems. They are not people. A go-between who is both aware of the messages and capable of comprehending them (sent in the clear) can easily be argued to be part of the conspiracy. But a go-between who is incapable of comprehending the messages has a valid defense (especially if the vast majority of the things they sit between are legal communications and not criminal conspiracies). Twitter et al. are capable of knowing, but due to the scope of their systems the communication often has to be obvious or brought to their attention for them to become aware of it in order to to react appropriately.
- mullen 6y ago> what's the current bar for suing an establishment for wrongful death? if a bunch of radicals met at a bar and plotted to murder someone, would the bar be responsible if they didn't intervene? If the bar had a of method of grouping people together based on their interests, then did nothing about violent speech in the bar while promoting other violent interests and showing ads promoting body armour, then yes, the bar should be held responsible for acts of violence that come out of meetings in the bar. By the way, Facebook is nothing like a bar.
- Arete314159 6y agoI think a more apt metaphor would be, If a bunch of radicals meet at a bar, repeatedly and and loudly state their intention to murder someone, loud enough for all the employees to know, and they also get into bar fights with the people they talk about murdering...would the bar owner & employees be responsible for not intervening? For not reporting them to the police and banning them from the establishment? The answer is yes. Yes, they would be liable.
- novok 6y agoBut if they rented private karaoke rooms and you can't hear or see what they're talking about, just that they rent a room regularly, then you wouldn't be eh?
- colejohnson66 6y agoGP’s argument is hinged on the premise that websites can “hear” everything posted. Just because a human doesn’t see it doesn’t mean the system didn’t. They already scan all posts for their targeted ad system. Whether that’s a valid argument or not is up to you.
- gruez 6y ago>The answer is yes. Yes, they would be liable. under what legal theory? A quick search says no. https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/3671/at-what-point-does-refusal-to-report-a-crime-make-one-an-accomplice-to-a-crime https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/3671/at-what-point-d...
- bilbo0s 6y agowould the bar be responsible if they didn't intervene? What state do you live in? It's even worse for tech companies, because of the way people use these services. As a completely hypothetical example that I'm in no way condoning, let's say someone in a forum posted a comment like, "I hate n-words. We should off them all." The comments in the forum degenerate from there, and include posts of the form, "YY black church starts service at 10:30 on Sunday." and, " Oh yeah, you mean the N-word church at XXXX South Whatever Blvd in Charleston SC?" I think you see where I'm going with this. Taken separately, each of those comments is either non-specific, or not threats at all. But taken together, it's a different story. Now, imagine this hypothetical tech firm ran ads on their forums. It wouldn't even matter whether or not they ran ads on the forum in question, because the very fact that they decide where to run ads would make them a publisher and ineligible for section 230 protections.