3 ms·
You should be ashamed of the embarrassingly disingenuous characterization of the court packing proposal. “Court packing” refers to expanding the court to allow
by rayiner 6y ago
You should be ashamed of the embarrassingly disingenuous characterization of the court packing proposal. “Court packing” refers to expanding the court to allow a president from one party to appoint new justices to change the ideological makeup of the court. You know this because the very phrase “court packing” originated in a proposal to do just that: https://www.history.com/news/franklin-roosevelt-tried-packing-supreme-court https://www.history.com/news/franklin-roosevelt-tried-packin...
It absolutely would destroy the rule of law. The Senate Judiciary Committee, controlled by FDR’s own party, had this to say: https://constitutioncenter.orgblog/how-fdr-lost-his-brief-war-on-the-supreme-court-2 https://constitutioncenter.orgblog/how-fdr-lost-his-brief-wa...
> By June 1937, the Judiciary Committee had sent a report with a negative recommendation to the full Senate. “The bill is an invasion of judicial power such as has never before been attempted in this country. . . . It is essential to the continuance of our constitutional democracy that the judiciary be completely independent of both the executive and legislative branches of the government,” the report read.
> Its conclusion was even more direct: “It is a measure which should be so emphatically rejected that its parallel will never again be presented to the free representatives of the free people of America.”
Even the mere threat of court packing effectively gutted separation of powers and federalism. Today, a federal government of “enumerated powers” is a dead letter, all thanks to FDR.
- cozuya 6y agoWow. Speaking of "embarrassingly disingenuous characterization". "Court packing" would be breaking a US government norm. A norm, very similar to, Mitch McConnell not bringing Merrick Garland's nomination to the Senate for 8 months, because "You can't nominate a SCOTUS justice in an election year". Also breaking a norm very similar to Mitch McConnell shoving through a SCOTUS justice 8 days before an election. If "Court Packing" happens, it is a direct result of bad faith norm breaking by the Republicans. But you knew that. Elections have consequences. https://www.wbtv.com/2020/09/30/trump-filling-supreme-court-seat-elections-have-consequences/ https://www.wbtv.com/2020/09/30/trump-filling-supreme-court-... Winners make policy, losers go home. https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/320506-mcconnell-winners-make-policy-and-losers-go-home https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/320506-mcconnell-winners...
- bhupy 6y agoHow is an elected official choosing not fill one of N vacancies while they're in power (mind you, they won the following election) remotely comparable to just changing the value of N because you were unhappy with how elected officials played the game up until that point? Even RBG found this line of thinking to be nonsense and dangerous: https://www.npr.org/2019/07/24/744633713/justice-ginsburg-i-am-very-much-alive https://www.npr.org/2019/07/24/744633713/justice-ginsburg-i-...
- cozuya 6y agoSo Republicans can change the agreed upon rules (norms), lie about it, and then change the rules again, to get what they want while they're in power, but when the Democrats are in power, they have to play by the Republican's rules? In 1988, AN ELECTION YEAR, the Dems controlled the senate and still confirmed Kennedy who was put forward by Reagan of course, 97-0. But when Mitch McConnell spits in the face of Obama and Merrick Garland, Dems are supposed to just sit and take it? Once again, elections have consequences, and we'll see what they are very soon. By the way this is academic as Manchin has said he won't do it.
- bhupy 6y ago> So Republicans can change the agreed upon rules (norms), lie about it, and then change the rules again, to get what they want while they're in power, but when the Democrats are in power, they have to play by the Republican's rules? The only agreed upon "rules" are what the legislature passes. "Norms" don't really mean much; those are just glorified pinky promises. You're basically comparing "norms" to laws, but those two are not the same. The fact that there are 9 justices on the Supreme Court isn't a norm that we all just shake hands and agree on, it's what's currently set by legislation. Mitch McConnell never violated any law, nor did he change the rules via legislation. He (and the GOP) exercised the power to advise and consent (or not) to a nomination. If the people had wanted the kind of nomination he refused to consent to, they would have voted for a different Chief Executive, and a different Senate. But alas, that did not happen; those are the rules of the game. What you (and the so called "academics") are advocating for is changing the rules of the game. Notwithstanding the merits of that, it is in no way comparable to just playing hardball by the existing rules, and to argue otherwise is pretty disingenuous.