3 ms·
>> There is little meaningful overlap between such a program and an unmanned missile system; the relevance of Dyna-soar is close to zero. Except that part of D
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> There is little meaningful overlap between such a program and an unmanned missile system; the relevance of Dyna-soar is close to zero.
Except that part of Dyna-soar was dipping back into atmosphere for plane change maneuvers. That dipping in and out of atmosphere to make course changes would seem very relevant to missiles.
But this quote is more telling of the author:
"Thus, while hypersonic weapons fly a more direct path to their targets, they lose much of their speed throughout flight, ultimately taking longer to reach their targets than comparable ballistic missiles."
No. A ballistic missile follows a ballistic trajectory. That means it is on a very fixed schedule, a tight min/max flight time to the target based on predictable spheres-in-a-vacuum physics. A hypersonic missile on a lower trajectory can indeed get to some targets sooner. It will require more fuel/energy to do so, as opposed to following the higher ballistic path, but fuel efficiency isn't a big deal when you are delivering nukes.
- topspin 6y agoSorry but citing technical similarities doesn't salvage the Dyna-soar argument for me. Dyna-soar program was a manned bomber/reconnaissance platform. The recent efforts of advanced nations centers on missile development. The lack of a mission for the former has nothing to do with the latter. The difference is so great that I feel the use of Dyna-soar in this context to be misleading, and that probably deliberate.
- cameldrv 6y agoThere are a range of ballistic trajectories that can work. If you want to get there faster, you can use a shallower trajectory (they usually call this a depressed trajectory). This takes more energy, so you get a shorter range for a given missile. The other problem is that the warhead spends more time in the atmosphere. Most ballistic missiles use unguided reentry vehicles, so the best accuracy comes from a high trajectory that comes almost straight down onto the target, so it spends the least time interacting with the unpredictable atmosphere. However, if the reentry vehicle is guided, depressed trajectories become more practical. The U.S. did this in the past with the Pershing II, which had terminal radar guidance, and we have a half-way version of this with path length fusing on the Trident II, where the warhead is not guided, but the detonation point is controlled based on trajectory error. Russia has tested these in the past few years and could have deployed them. IMO it's an underappreciated threat because it could allow attacks against hard targets with less than 10 minutes of warning.