3 ms·
The only reason they're able to regulate broadcast at all is because it's a scarce resource. Since only a few people could use it, they were able to get away wi
by jfengel 6y ago
The only reason they're able to regulate broadcast at all is because it's a scarce resource. Since only a few people could use it, they were able to get away with regulating them. Even they don't really use it: AM radio is full of outright hate speech, which is also legal as long as it can have any kind of fig leaf as "opinion".
Other than that, there's really no limits at all. The First Amendment is pretty clear about that. They were more afraid of having the government clamp down on legitimate dissent than they were on illegitimate dissent. They had, after all, just fought a revolution, and one of the complaints was about newspaper and pamphlet publishers being suppressed. So you get to say anything you want, and if anything
"news" gets even more leeway.
It does feel like false advertising to say "Here is the news: grass is purple, llamas are a kind of tulip". I don't know if anybody has ever tried to apply false advertising to news media. It's kind of remarkable that false advertising is regulated at all, given the sacred place they give the First Amendment[1] -- and here[2] is a right wing think tank saying it's wrong.
Yeah, that's pretty horrifying. As far as the Cato Institute is concerned, it should be perfectly legal to sell you horse meat labeled as beef. They'd probably tell you that it's up to you to do genetic testing on your meat, or maybe sign a contract with the grocer so that you can sue them for breach of contract. If you don't have a contract with Fox News to tell the truth, it's your problem.
And if you live in a country where half the people believe a conspiracy theory promoted by freely-available news, that's also your problem.
[1] https://www.lawpublish.com/amend1.html https://www.lawpublish.com/amend1.html
[2] https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/contrived-distinctions-doctrine-commercial-speech-first-amendment-jurisprudence https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/contrived-distinctions-...
- samizdis 6y agoThanks again. If the pubs were open (we're locked down and drinking alone in our homes/park benches etc atm), I'd happily buy you a few ales - but probably bore you with my conversation. Cheers :-)