4 ms·

I encounter it occasionally. Either broken or omitted features. Slack calls don't work in Firefox just because. Blurring out your background in Google meet isn'

I encounter it occasionally. Either broken or omitted features. Slack calls don't work in Firefox just because. Blurring out your background in Google meet isn't available on Firefox. Some utilities websites here, in Ireland, don't work in Firefox but do in Chrome.

tristor 6y ago
>Slack calls don't work in Firefox just because. Slack calls don't work in Firefox because Slack explicitly made the choice to not support Firefox and to not follow web standards in how they implemented Slack calls. Furthermore, they go a step further by detecting your browser and blocking the feature for Firefox users and telling you to switch to Chrome. [1] This is not a failure of Firefox, it's a failure of Slack. I think the attitude in your comment is very common, and is exactly why it's so hard to build a web browser for the modern web that isn't part of the Google Chrome monoculture. Users cannot differentiate easily between problems they encounter because of their browser vs problems they encounter because of the web app, and for the user it doesn't matter because it's still a problem. Regardless of the cause, it's important that browser makers solve these issues to ensure that users can get things done on the web, but that's easier said than done. [1]: https://twitter.com/slackhq/status/958645632620748800?lang=en https://twitter.com/slackhq/status/958645632620748800?lang=e...
- richeyryan 6y ago
  I know its a failure of Slack, which is why I responded to the parent
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago
  > Furthermore, they go a step further by detecting your browser and blocking the feature for Firefox users and telling you to switch to Chrome. Well, it is perhaps worth noting that if you fake your user agent to remove the block, calls still don't work (I've tried). I'm not opposed to blocking a feature which the developer knows is not going to work (although it would be nice if their was an override, for browser developers if no one else). But, yes, the fact the calls don't work in the first place is BS. And it is, sadly, one of the reasons I finally gave up and switched to Chrome earlier this week. I need this stuff for work, and I just can't fight it anymore!
- kelnos 6y ago
  That's the thing, though: very few Slack users will care that it's Slack's fault that calls don't work on Firefox. They'll blame Firefox, and switch to Chrome, if that feature is important to them. (Or they'll use Slack's Electron app.)

tristor 6y ago

>Slack calls don't work in Firefox just because. Slack calls don't work in Firefox because Slack explicitly made the choice to not support Firefox and to not follow web standards in how they implemented Slack calls. Furthermore, they go a step further by detecting your browser and blocking the feature for Firefox users and telling you to switch to Chrome. [1] This is not a failure of Firefox, it's a failure of Slack. I think the attitude in your comment is very common, and is exactly why it's so hard to build a web browser for the modern web that isn't part of the Google Chrome monoculture. Users cannot differentiate easily between problems they encounter because of their browser vs problems they encounter because of the web app, and for the user it doesn't matter because it's still a problem. Regardless of the cause, it's important that browser makers solve these issues to ensure that users can get things done on the web, but that's easier said than done. [1]: https://twitter.com/slackhq/status/958645632620748800?lang=en https://twitter.com/slackhq/status/958645632620748800?lang=e...

richeyryan 6y ago
I know its a failure of Slack, which is why I responded to the parent
Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> Furthermore, they go a step further by detecting your browser and blocking the feature for Firefox users and telling you to switch to Chrome. Well, it is perhaps worth noting that if you fake your user agent to remove the block, calls still don't work (I've tried). I'm not opposed to blocking a feature which the developer knows is not going to work (although it would be nice if their was an override, for browser developers if no one else). But, yes, the fact the calls don't work in the first place is BS. And it is, sadly, one of the reasons I finally gave up and switched to Chrome earlier this week. I need this stuff for work, and I just can't fight it anymore!
kelnos 6y ago
That's the thing, though: very few Slack users will care that it's Slack's fault that calls don't work on Firefox. They'll blame Firefox, and switch to Chrome, if that feature is important to them. (Or they'll use Slack's Electron app.)