7 ms·
Your comment reminds me of this book: https://time.com/3910020/the-over-parenting-trap-how-to-avoid-checklisted-childhoods-and-raise-adults/ https://time.com/3
by hedora 6y ago
Your comment reminds me of this book:
https://time.com/3910020/the-over-parenting-trap-how-to-avoid-checklisted-childhoods-and-raise-adults/ https://time.com/3910020/the-over-parenting-trap-how-to-avoi...
> So imagine how surprised I was to discover among my more affluent, well-connected students a growing number who seemed to be lacking the ability to make their way independently in the world, as, frankly, 18-22 year olds always had been able to do and just as crucially, used to desire to do. I’m deliberately being vague about what exactly was missing in so many students because frankly I couldn’t quite tell at first. Something was just off. Odd. It took most of my ten years as dean before I figured out what exactly the problem was.
For starters, each year my students were more and more and more and more accomplished. The grades, but not just the grades: the scores. And not just the grades and the scores but the awards, and the accolades, and the activities, and community service, and leadership, and, and, and, and, and, every other prospect for perfection. Yet each year I noticed that more and more could tell you what they’d done but not so much why they’d done it.
I’m old enough that helicopter parenting wasn’t a thing when I was a kid. I find the whole phenomenon incomprehensible.
But, yeah, I imagine people used to accomplish more before everyone got so damned risk adverse.
- ryandrake 6y agoI don't know if this dean's observation is about helicopter parenting or risk aversion as much as it's about how bifurcated and ultra-high stakes the university/credential-pedigree system has become, and how essential it is to optimize for a certain outcome at all costs. When I was high school age, the A students went to good universities and generally ended up with a good professional career, the B students went to state schools and had an average life in an office job. The C students went to community college and limped along. The D students went to trade school and at least had a shot at turning things around. We're moving towards a world where the A++5.0GPA+awards+accolades students will go to the top universities and end up living in relative luxury, the A students maybe will finish college hamstrung with mountains of debt, and the rest? Walmart/Meth if they're lucky, prison if they're not. Competition among students is a complete slug-fest and every parent is doing whatever they can to juice the metrics that universities demand, at the expense of every other part of the student's development/upbringing. You don't want your kid left behind in the dirt.
- sharadov 6y agoI agree, I've some nephews/nieces in college and was talking to their parents about why they were getting them to start applying for tech internships in freshman year, sounded absurd to me. And I was telling them how they should be more adventurous with where they want to work and live after they graduate. But all they wanted to do was work in Silicon Valley ( they grew up around here, so I thought they would want to move and explore other parts of the country). But, no they did not want to. I think it was both risk-averseness and also sheer practicality that all the good tech jobs are here.
- KMag 6y agoI see what you did there. Very subtle and gentle correction of the GP's misunderstanding of the phrase.
- gbear605 6y agoWalmart/Meth is a pretty strong exaggeration. Things aren’t great without a degree, but they’re not (yet) impossible.
- phs318u 6y agoWe're straying way off-topic here but I'd suggest that things are pretty terrible for significant numbers of people. As evidence (I'm not US-ian), I present this article [0], which actually tries to make the point that living standards have never been better. In my view, he fails, specifically with the following statement in para 5, "There would surely be a revolution in America if 90% of our citizens have suffered income stagnation or worse". I'd suggest that recent events and the fact that many tens of millions of people supported (and still support) Donald Trump, are proof of a slow-motion revolution in progress - a kind of cold-civil-war. So, maybe parent was being colourful with the "Walmart/meth" exaggeration, but in terms of "effective equivalence" I'd say they are close to the mark. [0] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/americans-living-standards-are-at-an-all-time-high-heres-proof-2019-05-02 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/americans-living-standards...
- ROARosen 6y ago> But, yeah, I imagine people used to accomplish more before everyone got so damned risk adverse. I'm looking at you GameStop... (tongue-in-cheek)
- simonh 6y agoThere's a British children's adventure film called "Swallows and Amazons". A family of children want to go on a sailing trip without adult supervision to camp on an island. Their mother sends a telegram to her husband, who's an officer on a navy ship asking his advice (or permission, it was another time). He sends a telegram back "If not duffers won't drown, if duffers better drowned".
- dmurray 6y agoIt was originally a book, or actually a series of books, written and set in the 1930s. Great reading as a child, but to have such permissive parents - they barely make an appearance while their kids as young as 7 spend days at a time boating and camping - seemed as fanciful to me as Harry Potter. I wonder if it was really like that in the 30s.
- pjc50 6y agoApart from the magic, Harry Potter is just the well-worn genre of "school stories" and the social structure of the school is basically that of a select British private school, complete with boarders and "houses" and so on. It really was like that in the 30s (see Roald Dahl's Boy, for another example, or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stalky_%26_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stalky_%26_Co.). I think Swallows and Amazons is a little stretched from what would have been normal levels of parental contact, but not beyond what a reader of the time would have considered normal or reasonable.
- ghaff 6y agoOr pretty much any of Enid Blyton's books. As you say, probably an exaggerated view of childhood independence in upper middle class(?) England (and certainly there are American examples as well although boarding school is a less prominent feature), but not something wildly fantastical to many readers.
- simonh 6y agoThere are always older children around though, I think there was a much higher expectation that older children would take responsibility for the younger ones back then. S&A is adventure fiction so maybe a little exaggerated, but not outrageously so.
- canadianfella 6y agoThe students were accomplishing more.
- jjk166 6y agoPersonally I think the risk aversion has less to do with parenting and more just life experience. For the vast majority of human existence, high child mortality was much higher than today. Even for the wealthiest, watching some of your siblings die was simply a fact of life. It was only in the early 20th century that childhood death became uncommon, and even then these kids were being born to and raised by people who had grown up in such a world. My grandfather, for example, was the youngest of 12 and grew up in a household where no one expected all 12 to make it. The combination of an excessively large number of people and the desensitization to death (with maybe a little bit of lead paint thrown in for good measure) naturally leads to the view of life being cheap. These are the sorts of conditions that make wars that cost tens of millions of lives conceivable, but also the conditions where people are okay with being strapped to a rocket with only a bit of testing. The baby boomers were really the first generation raised entirely with the expectation that they would live, and late genX/early millennial children were likely the first in history to be raised by parents who had been raised with that mindset. The longer you expect to live, the more sensible risk aversion is.