4 ms·
I think the major fault with these studies is there participants know the benefits will end. I think this biases them towards continued working because they vie
by bumby 6y ago
I think the major fault with these studies is there participants know the benefits will end. I think this biases them towards continued working because they view it as a short term windfall that won’t sustain them rather than a long term solution. It would be incredibly hard to design an experiment to control for this.
Conversely, I think the hard part about implementing UBI is that it would be incredibly hard to roll back once people become accustomed to it
- arcticbull 6y agoIndeed, I think the challenge is around committing to a 50 year study that they won't cancel later in a discretionary way. > Conversely, I think the hard part about implementing UBI is that it would be incredibly hard to roll back once people become accustomed to it So we are left with something people like and don't want to give up, and that's bad because... :)
- bumby 6y ago>So we are left with something people like and don't want to give up, and that's bad because... :) Sorry, I should have taken the time to elaborate. There’s certainly a conceivable scenario when the situation is either unsustainable or not providing a net benefit. For the first case, consider a petrostate whose population is heavily subsidized by its oil sales. If oil price drops, whether by lack of demand or over supply, they may not have the funds to continue these benefits without debt, regardless if the populace “likes” them. In the second scenario, it’s possible that it creates unintended consequences (like spikes in drug use, drop in life expectancy, reduced productivity) that become a larger social ill than what it was trying to prevent. Despite society being worse off, it becomes hard to scale it back because of the psychological endowment effect. I’m not saying its likely, just as a counter point that just because people like a benefit it means it should continue. I think it’s important to do a “pre-mortem“ on these kinds of policies to make sure we have the guardrails in place before implementing them.
- malandrew 6y ago> So we are left with something people like and don't want to give up, and that's bad because... :) ... other people are burdened with providing it against their will. A Southern plantation owner in the pre Civil War southeast US had something they liked and didn't want to give up and it was most certainly very very bad.
- arcticbull 6y agoUBI is universal, everyone gets it. I’d wager if you asked slaves if they were enjoying it they’d say no. One of the many problems is they weren’t being asked.
- bumby 6y agoI think the counterpoint is that, while everybody receives the same amount, people contribute differing levels so the net benefit is very different for individuals. I think this is an affront to some people's ideas of fairness even though it aligns with progressive tax schemes.
- lostcolony 6y agoThe question I always wonder, when people bring this up, is if they've applied it to themselves. If they had a basic UBI of, say, $20k, would they quit their job, and not look for work, not work on personal projects, not look to go back to school, nothing, just do what they are assuming others will do, sit around, watch TV, that sort of thing? Rather than keep striving, keep working, and have both an extra $20k being paid to them currently, and that safety net in place in case they lose their job? Because I can't imagine doing that. I -like- having a higher quality of life. I desire to do things, to affect things. In fact, the most frustrating jobs I've had were the ones that felt like they handcuffed me from leaving due to the salary (not to mention things like equity cliffs and paying back signon bonus), but deprived me of any real empowerment or responsibility to affect change. If this logic applied to me, I should be thrilled; I barely have to do anything, am barely expected to do anything, and am paid through the nose. But I end up hating it and wanting out. Even something like working McDonald's; would the additional pay of working there on top of UBI be worth it? If not, what would have to change? Better working conditions? More pay? I'd be interested to find out; why -don't- people find service industry jobs desirable? Why would someone choose to be unemployed, if their disposable income is higher working there? Are they just lazy, as America likes to paint it, or are there institutional problems that could be addressed, but remain unaddressed due to the inability for people to just quit and walk away? We actually have some anecdotal data to this; people who inherit money sufficient they could live the rest of their lives doing nothing. If it's multiple millions, yeah, people do decide not to work, "trust fund babies" and the like. But plenty of people get a few hundred thousand and a house. That's enough that, if invested, they could pay property taxes and live a basic life without working. They could sell the house and move out of the country, and live even cheaper. How many do it in lieu of working? Very few. Why? Because they desire something more.
- bumby 6y agoAnecdotally I’ve seen both sides. I’ve seen people get social security or disability benefits and coast for the rest of their lives without working even though they have the ability to do so without affecting their benefits. I assume they value sleeping in and not having to answer to anyone. Their idea of a good time is spending hours hiking or watching tv or various other things that have negligible cost. I’ve also known those who get said benefits and either use it as a leg-up to get ahead or just donate it while they keep working. Honestly, I’ve seen more in the former category than the latter. I suspect it cuts down along the industriousness subset of the Big Five personality traits. Those who get intrinsic satisfaction doing/building are probably likely to be in the latter group. I bet HN skews towards this which is why so many find it difficult to comprehend why somebody would want to just loaf around with their life. To your very thoughtful questions about why someone wouldn’t want to continue working, my guess is the roles they qualify for aren’t intrinsically satisfying to them because it’s a poor mating of their personality and the jobs society has deemed necessary or they don’t pay enough to make the juice worth the squeeze