3 ms·
There is some basic math that can make a pedestrian downtown difficult. A walking person needs the resource of space, time in the pathway. So take the number
by sandworm101 6y ago
There is some basic math that can make a pedestrian downtown difficult. A walking person needs the resource of space, time in the pathway. So take the number of employees per square foot of office space (~200 sf per employee) to get an estimate of the total number of people in a downtown area. If we assume they each need to commute in/out each day we need a system of movement that can accommodate that number. Even if they are all elite joggers willing to run a couple miles each day, there is only so much street before people have to be relegated to tunnels/bridges. Depending on the office density, there are likely a great many cities where pedestrian commutes are physically impossible for the majority (London, NYC). Either they live downtown or we must move them in/out by faster mechanical means.
This is actually a very studied problem in pedestrian-dominated areas such as stadiums, airports and theme parks. There is a breaking point when the numbers get so big that you simply have to haul people to/from the perimeter entrances. I'm sure that Disney works from some very exact specifications.
- ant6n 6y agoUh, firstly, have you heard of this invention called public transit. Or this other invention called a bike? Also, this comparison to crowds around stadiums is bizarre. Cars use up more space than pedestrians, so it is possible to commue by car, then it is possible to commute on foot - at least as far as crowding is concerned.
- sandworm101 6y agoDid I say car? I said "by faster mechanical means". That would be bikes/busses/trains/helicopters/escalators and everything else mechanical as in mechanisms as in everything not-pedestrian, a big field.
- ant6n 6y agoNeither pedestrian crowding nor travel distance is an issue in walkable cities, because public transit and cycling is compatible with a walkable city. There is nothing difficult about it, there exist thousands of walkable cities. Another concept you may learn about is „mixed used neighborhoods“. It turns out you dont have to separate out working and residential areas, this will reduce travel distances. A related concept is the „polycentric city“.
- bobthepanda 6y agoHaving pedestrian only downtowns is not really relevant when it comes to having a pedestrian friendly environment, so I’m not sure why this is a relevant counterpoint. Most people in downtown Toronto or Manhattan are not solely walking to work, but the walking environment is still pleasant.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoPedestrian traffic is by far the most space efficient method of transportation, so that's not a problem with pedestrian traffic, it's a problem with density in general.