3 ms·
It's such a shame nutrition science is in such infancy because when I read these types of things I get excited and then a couple years later there's inevitably
by endisneigh 6y ago
It's such a shame nutrition science is in such infancy because when I read these types of things I get excited and then a couple years later there's inevitably some contradicting study.
The only thing I've read that seems to never be contradicted is the following quote:
> Eat food, not too much, mostly plants
EDIT: Is it just me, or do they never say how the eggs are prepared? I feel like that would have a huge effect as well as since the preparation method changes the composition of the eggs of course. Frying eggs with a bunch of butter might negate any health benefits eating say, an otherwise poached egg, might have.
I loved fried eggs and wonder if I'd receive more benefit by boiling or poaching, hmm.
- the-pigeon 6y agoResearch has said eggs are good for the last 20 years. It was believed they were bad due to their high cholesterol and cholesterol was considered bad across the board. But modern research shows it's more complicated than that.
- endisneigh 6y agoI personally think eggs are good for you and eat at least one a day, but there have been studies that have shown results that might lead you to believe otherwise like the following: https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/87/4/964/4633437 https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/87/4/964/4633437 ". In addition, consumption of ≥7 eggs/wk was associated with a modestly but significantly greater risk of total mortality in this population. In contrast, egg consumption was associated with a greater risk of all-cause mortality in a dose-response fashion among physicians with diabetes (2 times the risk of death in people consuming ≥7 eggs/wk than in those consuming <1 egg/wk). Furthermore, our data provided suggestive evidence for a greater risk of MI and stroke with egg consumption among male physicians with diabetes. In contrast, baseline hypercholesterolemia status did not influence the relation between egg consumption and CVD or mortality." The same study admits that the finding was not conclusive though and that there have been other studies that have contradicted their results.
- airstrike 6y agoThey never controlled for preparation method or associated ingredients (read: butter) so it's basically useless data
- endisneigh 6y agoI completely agree - that's exactly my point. A lot of these studies are not done with the necessary level of rigor needed to draw a definitive conclusion. So we're left with a bunch of half baked "contradictory" studies in many cases.
- pmiller2 6y agoHow exactly would you conduct a nutrition study to the "necessary level of rigor needed to draw a definitive conclusion?" The most interesting studies are the ones that follow people long term, and you can't exactly force people to eat according to a specific diet for a period of years.
- derekp7 6y agoThe one thing that is hard to control for in the studies is if people who crave eggs (and therefore consume more of them) also crave other things that are bad for them. Or if the genetic makeup can cause an increased craving for specific food types (for example genetics influences whether cilantro enhances food or tastes like dish soap).
- atweiden 6y ago> Research has said eggs are good for the last 20 years. McGill published a study in 2012 [1] which shows egg yolk consumption is connected in an exponential relationship with carotid plaque area (see: pg 3): > ... both tobacco smoking and egg yolk consumption accelerate atherosclerosis, in a similar fashion: the increase in plaque area is linear with age, but it is exponential with smoking history and egg consumption. Curve fitting with the cases that had non-zero values for egg yolks and smoking showed that an exponential fit was better than a linear fit. [1]: http://www.medicine.mcgill.ca/epidemiology/hanley/tmp/Applications/EggyolkPlaqueSmoking.pdf http://www.medicine.mcgill.ca/epidemiology/hanley/tmp/Applic...
- MPSimmons 6y agoThe fact that dietary cholesterol has no impact on serum cholesterol should have shot this down immediately, but shrug
- xtracto 6y agoI remember my father (a scientist himself) stop eating eggs about ~25 years ago because of the "science" and at a later time resuming eating eggs because of that other "science".
- snarf21 6y agoThis is what you get when "nutrition" is run by the USDA, whose job it is to grow and sell food. This belongs in HHS so there is no conflict of interests. Most of these "studies" are funded by groups with ulterior motives. And then we have billions in lobbying and subsidies to reconcile. It is such a shame. We know what we should do but remain bullied.
- subungual 6y agoThis study is a meta-analysis, so it works off of published research and does no original experiments of its own. By its nature, it incorporates systemic bias of earlier published studies. Often times, this kind of analysis leads to opposing biases being diluted or canceling out, but given widespread industry funding of this topic in particular, I'm not super optimistic about impartiality here.
- post_below 6y agoNot sure why your post is getting downvoted, the evidence for it's accuracy isn't in question that I know of. Real question: Does anyone think that food industry money doesn't influence policy and recommendations? If so can you provide some sort of supporting evidence for this view?
- derekp7 6y agoNot an answer, but another question. Back when eggs were demonized and grains were promoted, was there more lobbying flowing from grain farmers vs. egg farmers? Also including that chickens are fed grains, and therefore every egg sold represents profit to the grain seller?
- post_below 6y agoWhen it comes to the precise details, I imagine there aren't many people who know for sure how the convoluted machinations of money and policy played out on a particular issue. It's the nature of the game to keep it as opaque as possible. If we find out, it's usually many years down the road and it's rarely as direct as "grain outbid eggs". There are behemoth consumer food manufacturers involved, pharmaceutical companies too (statin drugs are a cash cow). Lots of industries profit or lose based on public health decisions and perceptions. Every once in a while it's pretty direct though, maybe the most well publicized example in recent years: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...
- mantenpanther 6y agoMaybe the study mentioned here points to a contradiction to the last part of that quote? ;-)
- Bukhmanizer 6y agoI don’t think the problem is that nutrition science is in its infancy, it’s more that modern science incentivizes pumping out flashy results cheaply, and as fast as possible.
- subungual 6y agoNutrition research is incredibly difficult to conduct, too. It often relies on participant reporting and is immensely complicated in terms of identifying and weeding out potential confounders. With how little we know about things that could play significant roles (e.g. gut microbiome), doing good science on this is super difficult.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- drzaiusapelord 6y agoWhich is kinda a half measure too. My body has been responding amazingly to a vegetarian diet (w/vegan flex days) and anywhere between 16-20 hours of fasting a day. I combat the horrors of factory farming and what's done to these poor animals and gain all the incredible benefits of fasting, all the while still enjoying a normal lifestyle of 2 tasty meals a day. Meat seems like this weird socially acceptable yet dangerous extravagance, a bit like smoking, to me. I'm working my way to cutting out eggs and am glad to be doing so considering all the negative outcomes other studies have revealed about egg consumption. If you look at all the studies uncritically and average out their findings, then the safe amount of eggs, imho, per week is between zero and two. The study of the health outcomes of egg consumption, in general, is a bit out there. A 2009 study claimed the opposite, that 7+ eggs a week increased the odds of cardiovascular disease. There's a strong anti-vegetarian pop-culture under-current right now fueled by the alt-right, keto types, and 'masculinity' experts so small single studies like these will get a lot of attention, but I'd wait for someone to try to replicate it, or at least see it as one data point in hundreds of reputable egg studies that mostly seem to contradict themselves. The egg industry is a $10bn industry and politically very well connected. Some of these studies may be influenced by that. Evolution didn't seem to design us to regularly eat the eggs of other animals and we seem poorly adapted to do so. Fun/depressing fact: There's one caged egg laying hen for every American.
- airstrike 6y agoAs I mentioned elsewhere, that study doesn't control for preparation methods and associated ingredients (like butter) so it's virtually useless
- thatguy0900 6y ago"There's a strong anti-vegetarian pop-culture under-current right now fueled by the alt-right," the alt right gets a lot of weird generic boogeyman associations but this is the weirdest I've ever seen lol
- symlinkk 6y agoIt’s sad how far behind health science is. Why don’t we have devices constantly monitoring us for health problems? Why can’t I easily browse through the data that doctors have on me, and transfer it between doctors? Why do I have to prep and cook and measure to get the optimum amount of nutrients for my body, why isn’t there a product that offers that for me? These things should be a higher priority as a society than social media apps or video games.
- itronitron 6y agoeggs have about ten times the cholesterol as butter or cheese so cooking the eggs in some butter is probably fine.