3 ms·
When I hear “Foundation” and “stable financial position” I think endowment. They seem to be making the same mistake as the Mozilla foundation. You’re living on
by hinkley 6y ago
When I hear “Foundation” and “stable financial position” I think endowment.
They seem to be making the same mistake as the Mozilla foundation. You’re living on your nest egg instead of the interest. Spending 4 times as much as you should.
- tux3 6y agoThe foundation set up a Wikipedia Endowment some five years ago, which has now reached 90MM of a 100MM goal. https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia_Endowment https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia_Endowment
- Zababa 6y agoThanks, I wasn't aware of this project. I have edited my comment to include it.
- hinkley 6y agoIs that enough to pay salaries and hosting costs? Sounds like the dividends will only cover 20% of their current expenses if they stop making grants. At it is it’s less than 10% of their burn rate. That’s a very excellent start but I suspect someone will want to grow that later on. In fact they’re at 90% of their goal and less than 60% of their target date, so they could be looking for $150M as the stretch goal.
- throwaway2245 6y agoWhy should Wikimedia need a significant nest egg? What do you do with the money, when people have stopped valuing Wikimedia enough that they are no longer paying for it to exist?
- hinkley 6y agoDonations are not a zero sum game but they aren’t terribly elastic either. Try as you might, every dollar you get as a donation is taking some of that money from someone else. There will be times when Wikipedia is not sexy, but taken for granted. That’s when you need the endowment.
- throwaway2245 6y agoIf Wikipedia becomes unfashionable to the extent it is highly dependent on its savings, it will no be longer valued for being Wikipedia (by definition). It might be valued as an institution with modest economic power, which doesn't seem to me to add anything to the world that isn't already there. 2 years of all current spending as a cushion seems like plenty to me (for Wikipedia, which has not faced any unexpected financial shocks, even in 2020). If you can't navigate shocks and downward trends with that cushion, then you probably ought not to exist.
- hinkley 6y agoOnly if you believe that market economies are always efficient. Plenty of things have a huge impact on your life and yet nobody wants to pay for them. They're important, but they're not important. If you have an endowment, you don't have to keep wrestling with keeping the two in sync.
- throwaway2245 6y agoI think our perspectives are different because I'm thinking about what the board of Wikimedia might look like later: when it controls a bunch of money but is essentially dying as a service. I imagine a political mess, of people trying to extract personal benefit from the remaining endowment.