4 ms·
It's interesting to see articles such as this one about the state of work in the tech industry in China, and not immediately see its direct parallels to Silicon
by Apocryphon 6y ago
It's interesting to see articles such as this one about the state of work in the tech industry in China, and not immediately see its direct parallels to Silicon Valley.
https://news.yahoo.com/why-chinese-youngsters-embracing-philosophy-040037640.html https://news.yahoo.com/why-chinese-youngsters-embracing-phil...
Sounds like the Chinese Dream which has just appeared in the past 25 years or so has already become increasingly difficult:
> The intense anxiety felt by younger people, and exacerbated by the pandemic, prompted a wider discussion on a once niche academic concept: neijuan. Translated as “involution,” the anthropological term was first applied to agriculture, and has come to describe conditions in which a society ceases to progress, and instead starts to stagnate internally. Increased output and competition intensify but yield no clear results or innovative, technological breakthroughs.
> Neijuan has become a hot topic on the Chinese internet and in media reports this year as a word that “captures urban China’s unhappiness.” Complaints of their work becoming too “involuted”—more competitive with little corresponding rewards—are as likely to be discussed on Weibo by white-collar workers as food delivery drivers.
> One example cited to illustrate the phenomenon is a notice in a Wuhan marketplace that forbade employment of female workers (link in Chinese) over the age of 45, and male workers over 50, citing the need to “upgrade” its services. In an “involuted” society, demand for work is so high that age and experience become liabilities. In another example, a student at China’s prestigious Tsinghua University was pictured typing on his laptop while riding on a bike. The pressure to stand out at this elite school has become so intense that even commuting has become an opportunity to maximize output.
> Shanghai-based Clarisse Zhang is one of the youngsters who feels they have missed out on a golden period, when simply working hard could mean a ticket to a better life.
It's not hard to spot the similarities to the decline of the American Dream.
And yes, it's not specific to more capitalistic societies like America or China either. You make good points about the rather stagnant nature of Europe's tech industry. Also, the high youth unemployment in some countries of Europe is quite alarming, despite the presence of much stronger social safety nets than in the U.S. Japan despite all its wealth and technological innovation, has experienced economic and social stagnation for decades, and I believe there's similar hopelessness among the youth in Taiwan [0]. Even parts of South Korea is seeing this as deindustrialization begins to set in. [1]
Wonder why so much of the developed world is experiencing involution, even nations that have just 'made it' recently like (coastal) China, or the Asian Tigers. Rich countries are still getting richer, but their citizens are getting unhappier.
[0] https://www.ozy.com/around-the-world/lost-ambition-taiwans-millennials-drown-in-despair/87884/ https://www.ozy.com/around-the-world/lost-ambition-taiwans-m...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17747086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17747086
- 1996 6y ago> Japan despite all its wealth and technological innovation, has experienced economic and social stagnation for decades, and I believe there's similar hopelessness among the youth in Taiwa [0]. Even parts of South Korea is seeing this as deindustrialization begins to set in. [1] The article properly describe how Japan has the same "disease", yet with different symptoms. The cause is not capitalism, but uniform objectives prescribed by society and adopted by its people. If you accept them as an unmovable truth, you can not work on alternatives. The McDonald example was another great piece: the student did the right thing (to keep trying the same thing while it fails and hoping for different results is a definition of insanity in the Simpsons joke), but even that was criticized. There is little hope people can find good solutions, if any attempts to do things differently is attacked. > It's not hard to spot the similarities to the decline of the American Dream. Indeed. The American Dream died in the 1960s, when "counter culture" was not recognized at its true value: an antidote to this involution. The article you linked are interesting, but they give the wrong solution: giving up by touching fish (slacking at work) is not very fulfilling unless there is something else with meaning in your life. It is accepting the same narrative, and just inverting your response to this narrative, instead of creating your own. Hopefully, China will manage its democratic transition better than America managed in counter culture. I have lots of hope, when I see accurate descriptions of the problem like this.
- Apocryphon 6y agoThe cause isn't just economic, or just attributed to simply "capitalism", but there's certainly a lot of economic aspects- inequality, regulatory capture, financialization, decline of unions (in a word- neoliberalism), etc. But true, it's possible a society's values also informs its expectations. It's not just the wealthy seeking to maximize their wealth by all means possible. And so the problem isn't just economic, or even just political. It's also be cultural. Certainly there's additional perverse incentives with the current system, and not all of it is just simple profit-seeking. The McD example is definitely mirrored in the U.S. as rising unemployment for college graduates, the swelling numbers of college students, and increasing university tuitions all happen at the same time. And here too, many service employers would consider graduates as overqualified for their jobs. Hiring expectations- including in tech- often do reflect cultural perspectives and not necessarily economic realities. I wouldn't go as far as to say the American Dream died until after the '70s or '80s, but certainly the '60s could be seen as lost potential to correct the course. However, I'm also drawn by Adam Curtis' thesis that the counterculture of the hippies, in contrast to the civil rights movement, focused too much on individualistic self-transformation and thus was unable to turn into a mass movement that could actually affect political, material change. Touching fish isn't really meant to be a way to bring about systemic change, it's just how those who are suffering from 996 seek to cope with what they're put under. It does show there is somewhat of widespread dissatisfaction with what's going on under involution.