3 ms·
"Math is precise." Your brain is not. I've seen a lot more evidence of people bootstrapping from intuition up to mathematical precision than simply starting wi
by jerf 15y ago
"Math is precise."
Your brain is not. I've seen a lot more evidence of people bootstrapping from intuition up to mathematical precision than simply starting with mathematical precision. Taken to its logical conclusion (and I do mean that I believe this is the logical conclusion), this leads to trying to teach number and set theory to kindergarteners, berating them for failing to get it, throwing your hands up and declaring they just aren't suited for math. You have to start with quantitative intuition, the alternative is not to teach math at all. There isn't a "start them out on correct pedagogy immediately" choice. You can and should argue about what tradeoffs are best, but you will have to have tradeoffs.
- run4yourlives 15y agoI don't seen how quantitative intuition and precision are somehow opposed to each other. 4*5 is 20. Not 21. Not 18. 20. That is logical, and it's vitally important in the understanding of all future concepts. You don't need to understand advanced calculus to grasp the concept that 2 3/4 oranges + 2 1/3 oranges is not 5 oranges altogther, but actually more, and that left over bit is in fact meaningful and relevant. It's when you start to play with abstractions that mathematics becomes confusing, not when you are being precise.
- lurker14 15y agoWhen is the last time you had a use for exactly 1/12 oranges? "some bit more than 5" is plenty of precision for nearly any conceivable situation in which your example could appear. https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Significant_figures https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Significant_f...
- run4yourlives 15y agoI think you misunderstood my example. My point was that knowing that there is 5 1/12 oranges (as opposed to 5) is the important precision, and it works logically to a child's mind. It's quite a bit more complex to expect the child to discard the 1/12 and suggest there are 5 oranges. It's not that the 1/12 is useful for anything, it's the fact that it exists, and is accounted for.