4 ms·
A lot of people talk about that, actually. I've heard it several times and it comes up in most of these discussions. However, doctor's pay is not enough on its
by whatshisface 6y ago
A lot of people talk about that, actually. I've heard it several times and it comes up in most of these discussions. However, doctor's pay is not enough on its own to explain even a small fraction of the cost problem. In reality it's an issue permeating every single component of the system, each one making a small contribution to the overall pile. I've heard of this situation being called "cost disease."
- stocknoob 6y agoPerhaps in small, private forums, but in public physicians are a protected class. Not many op-eds criticizing the AMA vs the big, evil pharma companies. That said, it's not a panacea, but not great when a 15-min visit to get a $.10 pill costs $200.
- whatshisface 6y agoOh, of course, it just hadn't occurred to me to consider op-eds a meaningful participant or representative of the public discourse.
- stocknoob 6y agoThey set the Overton window of allowed policies.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoNot great, but also: people above this asked why the system doesn't get reformed, and the answer is that doctors are popular with the voting population, and tackling their salaries will only have a modest impact in reducing costs. This is not to say that doctor's pay shouldn't be addressed, but the system doesn't get reformed because every discussion on fixing it gets derailed into a discussion of doctor's pay, which is literally the highest-effort lowest-payoff part of the problem. And the situation stays bad because of this dynamic.
- teorema 6y agoA $.10 pill that the person has been taking for years and is maybe even safer than many things sitting on the shelves of the hardware or grocery store.
- lostapathy 6y ago> doctor's pay is not enough on its own to explain even a small fraction of the cost problem Not on it's own, but doctor shortage can still contribute to medical costs. Do doctors make more mistakes due to high patient loads? Are preventable items missed because doctors can't spend enough time with patients? Would people be less likely to abuse the ER and/or wait to address conditions if they could get a primary care appointment more easily? If doctors had a little more slack in their schedules, might they innovate in other ways? If we had more doctors, would it be harder for mega-hospital chains to gobble up the supply of doctors in your area, leaving more independent practices to innovate in other ways?
- teorema 6y agoAlso: What if your pharmacist could do most of the practical things that matter to you about your medication, rather than requiring prescriber permission? What if you could do X by going to a psychologist or optometrist, or some other profession that doesn't currently exist, instead of going to an MD or PA or LPN? What if you could just buy certain things directly without a middleman? US healthcare is over regulated in general (in many areas, even as it's arguably underregulated in others).
- teorema 6y agoIt's not doctor pay, it's economic repurcussions of monopolies. It's also not just limiting the numbers of physicians, it's locking out alternate providers of care and other models. Right now US healthcare is very hierarchical, with physicians at the top, nurses close by. Other professions and services are subsidiary to them. You don't get to choose a provider based on skillset per se, you are forced to abide by this hierarchy. That's the real economic cost, the restrictions in provider and service choice.