8 ms·
"You're never as careful when spending other people's money." I briefly worked in healthcare at a tech startup. The thing you quickly learn is that the market
by legitster 6y ago
"You're never as careful when spending other people's money."
I briefly worked in healthcare at a tech startup. The thing you quickly learn is that the market for healthcare is fundamentally broken. You could invent something that saves a patient $10,000 and they will never know. The hospital and doctors won't care about saving money. And the insurance company has no leverage to make them. And it will never make it onto the patient bill in a way that they understand.
And as much as doctors and hospitals love to paint insurance as the bad guy, the only reason things like prior authorization is a pain in the ass is because doctors don't actually put in any effort into prescribing generics or really learn how much anything costs. This is highly unusual in most professions: Imagine if your roofer grabbed whatever shingles they liked best and billed you for it after they were up. Now imagine every roofer worked the same way.
- foepys 6y agoI'm from Germany and here it's exactly the other way around. Public health insurences (there are over 100, but they are all organized in an umbrella organization) give out licences to doctors to be allowed to practice on publicly insured patients. The doctors get some amount of money they can spent on patient-specific prescriptions, but in general the doctors only prescribe the active ingredient. When the patient goes to the pharmacy to get their prescription, the pharmacy looks up the insurence and hands the patient the medicine that the insurence dictates. A doctor can prescribe a specific medicine but has to pay for it themselves (mostly from the money the insurences previously provided, see above). Insurences check about 10% of all hospital bills and just don't pay what they deem unnecessary. Hospitals are therefore careful not to do things the insurences didn't approve of. There is an open catalog of therapies that the public insurences will definitely pay and how much it may cost, so it's not a secret. They will also push for modern treatments if they reduce recovery time and have less risks. There is a lot more to the system but that's the gist.
- gumby 6y agoIronically despite the lower cost, the German medical system also provides a wider range of services than are provided in the US. For example my mother in law had an unusual cancer and after her treatments she had a rest spa paid for; once the treatments could no longer help she had in home care. In the US, good luck.
- nicbou 6y agoI came here to extol the virtues of the German system. There's a lot more to it: - It's priced according to income, not health condition - You will never, ever be refused necessary healthcare, and you'll know it's covered before work begins - You are not punished for using your insurance, and the premiums won't change - There is no deductible, except a 5-10€/month co-pay for prescriptions - Your employer/employment has no impact on your coverage, or the insurer you choose This is for the public system. The private system is a bit more complicated, but generally, the same rules apply. The only difference is the pricing structure, and the possibility of having a deductible (usually ~1000€/year). American expats tend to have trauma that affects their insurance choices. My job is to reassure them that our system is completely unlike the American system. If you want a plain English overview of the system, you can have a look here: https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/german-health-insurance https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/german-health-insurance
- ballenf 6y agoOne important caveat to the German system is that if you make over a certain amount and are healthy, the private system will actually be cheaper since it's not tied to income.
- MuffinFlavored 6y agoI'd say the average programmer makes $120k/yr USD after about 5 years in, which is roughly €100k EUR. What would a German citizen making 80k-100k EUR pay in healthcare monthly? I think my employer subsidizes about $200/mo into a medical program for just myself. Curious how it stacks up to Europe (which seems to do health care better than the US by leaps and bounds?)
- estaseuropano 6y agoThe article linked in the comment chain you responded to gives numbers. For public insurance (which covers all essential care with no deductibles) > The ninimum is 200€, [...] If you make more than 58050€ per year, you pay around 400€ per month. This is the maximum contribution (Höchstbeitrag). If your salary is higher than 58050€, you will not pay more. For private insurance (possible if you earn above 64k or are a freelancer) its not linked to your income so rates vary. > Private is cheap when you are young If you are young and healthy, you could pay as little as 175€ per month (350€ for freelancers) for private insurance. If you make a lot of money, this is much cheaper than public insurance. But there are deductibles and fees can go up if you have frequent health issues. Freelancers cannot be covered by the public system so it only works when you're an employee, otherwise you're on private insurance.
- aaomidi 6y agoYes. The system is broken from the ground up. From doctors working with other doctors to make sure to limit new doctors coming into the workforce, to our multi-node insurance systems. Anyone selling you an easy solution is lying. Anyone selling you a "reform" solution is also lying. We need a holistic approach to this that means the government needs to hire a bunch of experts that are given a lot of power to change the system to make it work.
- stocknoob 6y agoEveryone complains about the cost of healthcare and nobody asks why the AMA operates like a cartel. The number of doctors allowed to graduate hasn't changed in 40 years.
- fragmede 6y agoWhich is why Nurse Practitioners are the best thing to happen for patients in decades. Better access to healthcare means better treatment.
- prostoalex 6y agoIt's a tough road for NPs in California at least https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2019-07-03/california-doctors-oppose-expanding-nurse-practitioner-authorities https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2019-07-03/...
- whatshisface 6y agoA lot of people talk about that, actually. I've heard it several times and it comes up in most of these discussions. However, doctor's pay is not enough on its own to explain even a small fraction of the cost problem. In reality it's an issue permeating every single component of the system, each one making a small contribution to the overall pile. I've heard of this situation being called "cost disease."
- stocknoob 6y ago
- civilized 6y ago> doctors don't actually put in any effort into prescribing generics or really learn how much anything costs I'm hesitant to blame doctors, since I myself find it impossible to learn how much anything costs until after being billed for it. Is it any easier for the doctors? (Note: clearly the doctor in this article is scamming his patients, but I'm talking about the situation in general)
- thaumasiotes 6y agoAs much as Kaiser Permanente has been giving me awful, awful care, they tell you how much something will cost you before giving it to you, and you have to explicitly agree to pay that amount. (In my case, I also pay before getting whatever it is, but it's possible to have the charge added to your bill instead.)
- civilized 6y agoI have never, ever had the experience of getting an answer to how much a health care procedure will cost, and believe me I've asked. Also never had Kaiser - mostly BCBS.
- react_burger38 6y agoHow do you do that? I tried to get Kaiser to tell me how much my wife's delivery would be and what they told us was much less than the actual bill, even though there weren't any complications
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI have not made any effort to get them to do that. Most of my experience with them has been really routine stuff -- "visit copay", "get a blood sample taken", or the like -- but this also happened for a stomach biopsy involving cramming a huge device down my throat, and for which they wanted to have me sedated, which seems like a pretty close analogy to a childbirth with no complications. :/
- hengheng 6y agoWhy is there no incentive for the insurance company to be frugal? That's how it works elsewhere, and they have a lot of bargaining power.
- pnutjam 6y agoThere is some incentive, but when you tell someone you can only make a profit of (for example) 10% of what you pay out; it warps their incentives. They don't want to bankrupt themselves, but they can raise rates and keep more money when they pay more.
- maxerickson 6y agoThis assumes they don't have any competition looking to take their market share (which reduces their intake). It can be the case that the market isn't very competitive, but it isn't the case that the companies can just arbitrarily raise rates.
- pnutjam 6y agoOnce a year the company can shop around, but you as an insured have no say. Your HR picks, and they may or may not be competent. They may optimize prices for family, or for single people, or any number of weird things.
- adolph 6y agoHMOs often have a negative public image due to their restrictive appearance. HMOs have been the target of lawsuits claiming that the restrictions of the HMO prevented necessary care. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_maintenance_organization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_maintenance_organizatio...
- anon946 6y agoShort term, yes. But when costs go up, they know that they can then later use it justify a proportional increase in premiums.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y ago
- munificent 6y ago> "You're never as careful when spending other people's money." That's a nice description of: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_proble... > This is highly unusual in most professions: Imagine if your roofer grabbed whatever shingles they liked best and billed you for it after they were up. Now imagine every roofer worked the same way. I mean, this basically is my experience with contractors, auto mechanics and most other professions where there's a lot of information asymmetry between consumers and providers. In a capitalist exchange, buyer and seller are opponents and both will use the others' lack of knowledge to their advantage (or be outcompeted by others that do). It's a fundamental dilemma of our world. The more expertise a task requires, the more important it is to hire someone to do it instead of doing it yourself. But the more necessary that person is, the less qualified you are to evaluate their performance.
- AlanYx 6y ago>I mean, this basically is my experience with contractors, auto mechanics and most other professions where there's a lot of information asymmetry between consumers and providers. The unique feature of the medical care system that's different from most other professions is that there's multi-way asymmetry. An auto mechanic generally does have some rough idea of how much a given repair costs (inclusive of labor and materials) or at least can easily inform him/herself. It's a basic two-party information asymmetry where the professional making the decision has more information than most consumers. In medicine, physicians often have no idea themselves what the total cost of treatment will be, and there are various structural and economic factors that discourage or make it very difficult for physicians to find this information. This is a very different type of information asymmetry, where both the providers and the consumers lack information.
- anon946 6y agoThe US HC system basically runs as a "skim" operation. Since skim is fundamentally percentage based, the more money that flows through the system, the greater the absolute amount that is skimmed. Thus, no one has incentive, in the long run, to reduce costs. Short term, insurance companies might benefit from cutting costs, but they know that ultimately, when costs go up, they can justify proportional premium increases, which increase their skim in absolute value.
- ballenf 6y agoNot only that, no one has a financial incentive to improve outcomes. Surgeons are judged on outcomes, but no one judges them on whether they did the right surgery or just very skillfully gave everyone who came through the doors stents and spinal implants.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chromatin 6y ago> And as much as doctors and hospitals love to paint insurance as the bad guy, the only reason things like prior authorization is a pain in the ass is because doctors don't actually put in any effort into prescribing generics or really learn how much anything costs. The only reason? Don’t put in any effort? How is this comment not flagged dead? This is patently false and essentially slanderous. (I guess libelous since we’re on a written medium) If you and the rest of the public had any idea how much your insurance company literally does not give a shit about you, when you are for example battling cancer, there would be pitchforks in the street.
- llamataboot 6y agoI have also worked in and around healthcare in various capacities (both tech and non-tech) and this is totally wrong. There are /many/ reasons the US healthcare system is broken, and I agree the issues are more systemic at this point, than any one bad actor, but if there /is/ a bad actor, it is definitely the health insurance companies. There are a lot of good people in the health insurance industry that want to improve health outcomes and make a profit and are swimming upstream as well against those systemic forces (just maybe the market isn't the best way to distribute healthcare...) but as a whole it's not the health insurance companies reining in the costs of frivious doctors and hypochondriac patients, it's the incredible layer of bureaucracy and arbitrary decisions there that soak up a ton of monetary resources, constrain doctors into not even being able to do the preventative care work they want, and lead to all sorts of perverse incentives like showing up in ER 5x a year, instead of getting to show up at your GP and nutritionist every week, etc
- Vaderv 6y agoWrong!!! There is a difference between generic and brand name medication. Please stop embarrass yourself.
- collyw 6y agoNot sure if your comment is specific to the US, but my gf is a doctor working in public healthcare here. She has worked with private healthcare and doesn't enjoy it as she says half of the time is battling with insurance companies trying to get them to pay for the best drugs for the patient, while insurance companies always want to pay for the cheapest drug for the patients.
- brianwawok 6y agoIn a not life threatening situation, wouldn’t it make sense to try out the cheaper drug first? When you are paying the bills, that is what you do. Roof springs a leak? Try a $20 patch first. Don’t immediately spend $8,000 tearing off and installing a new roof. But when you are spending other people’s money, it’s real easy to try and skip steps. If insurance didn’t push back, costs would be even more bonkers!!
- collyw 6y agoShe specialised in a long term degenerative illness, so giving an inferior drug may lead to a big loss of life quality down the road, an increase long term costs of treatment and care.
- Balgair 6y ago> because doctors don't actually put in any effort into prescribing generics or really learn how much anything costs. Medicine is a pretty difficult art as is. I'm not entirely convinced that I want my MD to be price conscious over being outcome conscious. If it comes down to choosing one over the other, I'd rather my MD focus on their practice and not their billing.
- craftinator 6y agoI'd prefer not being destitute to many medical alternatives. Have you been homeless? It's actually really, really bad for your health.
- Balgair 6y agoI'd think being unhoused with a medical condition may be worse. Though in the suffer-olympics, no one wins.