3 ms·
There has been a profound change in mathematics education in the years indicated, and the author of the submitted article is on to something. One of my favorite
by tokenadult 15y ago
There has been a profound change in mathematics education in the years indicated, and the author of the submitted article is on to something. One of my favorite authors on mathematics, Professor John Stillwell, writes, in the preface to his book Numbers and Geometry (New York: Springer-Verlag, 1998):
"What should every aspiring mathematician know? The answer for most of the 20th century has been: calculus. . . . Mathematics today is . . . much more than calculus; and the calculus now taught is, sadly, much less than it used to be. Little by little, calculus has been deprived of the algebra, geometry, and logic it needs to sustain it, until many institutions have had to put it on high-tech life-support systems. A subject struggling to survive is hardly a good introduction to the vigor of real mathematics.
". . . . In the current situation, we need to revive not only calculus, but also algebra, geometry, and the whole idea that mathematics is a rigorous, cumulative discipline in which each mathematician stands on the shoulders of giants.
"The best way to teach real mathematics, I believe, is to start deeper down, with the elementary ideas of number and space. Everyone concedes that these are fundamental, but they have been scandalously neglected, perhaps in the naive belief that anyone learning calculus has outgrown them. In fact, arithmetic, algebra, and geometry can never be outgrown, and the most rewarding path to higher mathematics sustains their development alongside the 'advanced' branches such as calculus. Also, by maintaining ties between these disciplines, it is possible to present a more unified view of mathematics, yet at the same time to include more spice and variety."
Stillwell demonstrates what he means about the interconnectedness and depth of "elementary" topics in the rest of his book, which is a delight to read and full of thought-provoking problems.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0387982892/ http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0387982892/
I have a collection of analytic geometry and calculus books, accumulated as used books from various readers, that includes the books used by my late father in his higher education as a chemistry major during the Truman administration, followed by books from other previous owners reflecting "new math," "back to basics," and "reform" approaches to mathematics education. Plainly today's secondary and tertiary students of mathematics need to take advantage of current technology so that they can devote more time to THINKING about the mathematics they learn and less time to what even any mathematician would call "tedious calculation." But too few students have ever been guided to through the kind of insight-producing problems in which the tedious steps themselves and the false starts while struggling with the problem produce deep understanding. Stillwell gives examples of such problems in his books, and the minority of students who participate in math contexts or who voluntarily work the "challenge" problems not assigned in their textbooks may gain such insight, but most school textbook problems of all eras are mere exercises, and too few students do enough of those thoughtfully to have hope of learning mathematical concepts.
See "Basic skills versus conceptual understanding: A bogus dichotomy in mathematics education," American Educator, Fall 1999, Vol. 23, No. 3, pp. 14-19, 50-52 for additional commentary on mathematics education,
http://www.aft.org/newspubs/periodicals/ae/fall1999/index.cfm http://www.aft.org/newspubs/periodicals/ae/fall1999/index.cf...
and see an earlier HN comment
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2515796 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2515796
for a FAQ on the distinction between problems and exercises in mathematics education.
- kenjackson 15y agoI side much more Conrad Wolfram on this than Stillwell [1]. Computation simply is a lot less important now as we have tools that do them with far greater speed and accuracy. And I'm from the generation that did tons of computation, but I honestly never had a great grasp of it. I just knew there were steps to be taken (leave an extra space to right as you do long multiplication) -- and I was one of the top math students in the district. In fact I'd argue that I never really understood much of any math until grad school. I was computational sophisticated, but lacked understanding. And oddly, I seem to find quite the opposite problem from what the blog author describes. I find students who know 3x5. But struggle to understand when the Fourier Transform is appropriate. Sure, if they're looking at problem sets at the back of the chapter about Fourier Transforms then they'll start with it, but in the real world they lack the conceptual understanding of it. I've met students who can compute the SVD, they can tell you the text book definition, but don't actually intuitively know what it means. They don't know when it should be applied, or when it is applied, what it means. [1] http://blog.wolfram.com/2010/11/23/conrad-wolframs-ted-talk-stop-teaching-calculating-start-teaching-math/ http://blog.wolfram.com/2010/11/23/conrad-wolframs-ted-talk-...
- ntkachov 15y agoAs a student in a fairly good university(Umass), Math tends to be taught exactly how you describe it. "Heres the FT. This is where you use it. This is how you do it". Most students will be able to do the FT, and most students can actually find the correct answer. However, because teachers and books tend to formulate very artificial situations where the a specific tool students often are used to looking for very specific patterns inside problems to decide what tool they will use for the job. When a problem falls outside the usual patterns, students will have a hard time identifying the tool they should use. I see this all the time when I help someone with a programming assignment. They may understand the problem, they may understand each individual solution if you explain it to them. However, they usually do not know where they should start. They may understand what a hash table is, and they may even know how to implement one. However if a problem does not fall into one of the patterns they are used to for a "hash table problem" they may not realize right away that they could use such a solution. Kids need to be taught how to break down a problem into its elements, and then realize which elements can be solved most effectively by what tool. This can also be learned through experience. Program enough and you will eventually start to break down problems yourself. But some kids don't seem to take initiative and work on themselves outside school. Which also is the reason why some kids from Umass CS are working at Facebook, Google, Microsoft, and others serve me coffee.