3 ms·
I was worried about this so I worked out the math. It wasn't as bad as I expected. Let's say it's 20 years from now, the total size of the bitcoin economy is $
by DennisP 15y ago
I was worried about this so I worked out the math. It wasn't as bad as I expected.
Let's say it's 20 years from now, the total size of the bitcoin economy is $1 trillion, and there are 10 million bitcoins in existence. (We could find the number of bitcoins exactly, but 10 million makes the math easy and it's within a factor of 2 of the ultimate limit. There are about 6 million coins right now.)
$1 trillion / 10 million coins = $100K per coin, so we can expect people to spend almost that much money to generate a coin.
The rate of coin production is currently 50 per 10 minutes, dropping in half every four years, giving us 9 coins per hour in 2031.
That's 78K coins per year, at $100K per coin, or $7.8 billion in computer time and energy spent per year.
Let's say half of that is energy, call it $4 billion, including the energy to make the dedicated mining computers. At ten cents per kilowatt-hour, we're talking 40 billion kilowatt-hours per year. Divide by the number of hours in the year and we get 4.5 gigawatts.
In other words, a $1 trillion bitcoin economy can be run on the output of roughly five typical nuclear power plants (assuming it's 20 years from now).
If we get to $1 trillion in only 12 years, energy usage will be four times higher, since coins will be worth about the same but four times as many will be generated per hour.
If people use custom ASICs to generate coins, they'll be costly but more energy-efficient, weighting expenditures more heavily on hardware than energy.
People can grant transaction fees to miners to make their transaction go through faster. If transaction fees become prevalent, resource usage will be higher, since there will be additional reward for completing blocks. But $7.8 billion is already almost one percent of the bitcoin economy. If the average bitcoin changes hands once per year with a one percent fee, or ten times per year with a 0.1 percent fee, we add $10 billion to mining rewards and approximately double our resource usage.
Edit: $1 trillion is about equal to the amount of U.S. currency in circulation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_supply http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_supply
- gammarator 15y agoI don't know much about economics, but this seems to illustrate why bitcoin must ultimately fail. Since producing new bitcoins by design becomes exponentially (!!!) more difficult as time passes, the true cost in resources (electricity, computing time, etc.) to produce a new coin can only increase. That resource use can be justified, but only if the value of the bitcoin is also increasing. Here's how I see it playing out: eventually it will be too costly for most people to produce new bitcoins. Since nothing forces one to use bitcoins, bitcoin holders will cash them out, and the exchange rate will plummet. Deflationary panic? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Money_supply_side_deflation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Money_supply_side_def...
- DennisP 15y agoIt will always cost about the same to produce a bitcoin as the bitcoin is worth. If it costs more, people will stop doing it and the difficulty will drop. If it costs less, people will profit by doing it and the difficulty will rise as more people join in. It's already difficult for individuals to produce bitcoins, but people have solved that by pooling their resources, getting regular rewards of fractional bitcoins.
- gammarator 15y agoThat's helpful, thanks. Still, it's only profitable to mine bitcoins at any computing cost if they can be exchanged for other items of value. If the value of bitcoins drop and people leave the bitcoin economy, making the last N bitcoins easier to compute won't make them more valuable.