4 ms·
This is a reasonable comment, and seems a fairly popular idea. But is this the most important comment thread, to be voted to the top, on this particular post?
by neilv 6y ago
This is a reasonable comment, and seems a fairly popular idea. But is this the most important comment thread, to be voted to the top, on this particular post?
The topic of the post is alleged blatant theft of tips. The question of whether there should be tips in the first place could be a diversion from the more immediate topic.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baby 6y agoNo tips = no theft and people actually get paid a wage that allows them to live well.
- helmholtz 6y agoBut what about the people who have actively just been shortchanged out of 61.7M USD in tips? Surely that' the topic here?
- katbyte 6y agoWell as a Canadian I’m going who the hell tips the Amazon delivery person
- eigenvector 6y agoI agree that of all developed countries, tipping is most prevalent in the USA, but as a fellow Canadian I wouldn't assume our Amazon delivery people are being paid anymore. They are independent contractors and not subject to minimum wage laws. If anything, their effective wage might be lower because vehicle operating expenses are higher in Canada.
- gambiting 6y agoI understand that part, I don't understand the part where people find it acceptable to tip the delivery person. It's just not ok, unless they brought your fridge up the stairs or something then sure, I'll slip in a little something for the effort. But an amazon delivery driver? Where they drop the parcel at my door, ring the doorbell and leave? Why would I ever tip them? The same with food delivery drivers - I open the door, say "hi" grab the food and they are gone. There is nothing there to tip for.
- __s 6y agoAlso a Canadian, Ontario. I didn't think to tip delivery, but my girlfriend at the time would include a tip when putting cash on the table for when it arrived. My mother's friend tips at Tim Horton's drive thru. So it likely varies a lot between various demographics The hassle is that even if a place charges more for food, you don't know if they pay their service better. So if you're going to support the "no tips" agenda you'll have to put in the additional effort of looking up wages to decide Starbucks is better than Tim Horton's
- gambiting 6y ago" So if you're going to support the "no tips" agenda you'll have to put in the additional effort of looking up wages to decide Starbucks is better than Tim Horton's" I just....don't see why. I honestly don't get an argument why. When you get a plumber do you check how much they earn per hour and decide accordingly? Like seriously, it's the biggest scam the restaurant industry has managed to pull off - they are making customers a) worry about this stuff at all, even though you wouldn't for pretty much any other industry b) make them feel bad for not tipping if the company pays poorly. That's incredible. And it's so incredibly condescending towards the workers too "oh you poor slave, you are paid so little, I'll give you some extra cash so you can actually live like a normal human being". There's probably some kind of syndrome that fits this situation.
- __s 6y agoSure, but reality is that minimum wage laws exclude waiter positions on the basis of tipping. So if you're anti tipping you should at least make sure you're avoiding places paying less than minimum wage. & you can't know just by looking at the menu I worked ice cream vending (https://serprex.github.io/w/Ice%20Cream%20Biker https://serprex.github.io/w/Ice%20Cream%20Biker if someone wants to read a very dry recount of my first day) where half my income was from tips. The prices of the items were generally like 2.75 to encourage getting me the extra quarter. It's a weird way that the business can leverage advertising a lower price while allowing tips to average out to cover a shitty wage Here's a cbc article on the topic where a no tips experiment failed: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/caf%C3%A9-linnea-allows-tipping-1.4272268 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/caf%C3%A9-linnea-all...
- baby 6y agowhat tips though? Who tips an Amazon delivery person?
- t-writescode 6y agoAmazon Prime Now has a 'tip' section with a recommended amount of money to give the driver. It works out to about 10% of the price, I think, generally?
- beckman466 6y agoThanks for explaining. And jesus, if this is not late capitalism then I’m not sure what is. Through the phenomenon of tipping everyone becomes a Caeser-like philanthropist, making life or death choices based on the perceived suffering and performance of their precarious underlings. Meaning waiters, and other service industry workers, compete for crumbs by trying to make other people feel like "the golden child of their day", in a system that systemically undervalues and underpays them (that's putting it very lightly). David Graeber has a great name for service workers, he calls them 'the caring classes'. [1] In another article he writes about the British working class: "In other words, the historical defeat and humiliation of the British working classes is now the island’s primary export product. By organizing the entire economy around the resultant housing bubble, the Tories have ensured that the bulk of the British population is aware" [2] In a talk he gave he says despite technology increasing the productivity and therefore some wages, "in the caring sector the exact opposite has happened. Digitization is being used as an excuse to make lower productivity so as to justify the existence of this army of administrators" [3], in Britain this has created a "cheerful, creative, and subservient working-class population who, drawing on centuries of tradition, know exactly how to be butlers" [2] [1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/26/caring-curse-working-class-austerity-solidarity-scourge https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/26/caring... [2] https://thebaffler.com/salvos/despair-fatigue-david-graeber https://thebaffler.com/salvos/despair-fatigue-david-graeber [3] http://opentranscripts.org/transcript/managerial-feudalism-revolt-caring-classes/ http://opentranscripts.org/transcript/managerial-feudalism-r...
- gambiting 6y ago
- ddingus 6y agoAre they to be compensated? Appears so. A related topic might be all the people suffering the same theft while working for much smaller players. From there, it moves pretty rapidly to, "get rid of tips and pay a wage that funds people existing reasonably and showing up for work" rather than start a fairly expensive and difficult enforcement effort. Maybe the idea of just avoiding all this mess to prevent what did happen, and what is happening to a ton of people is popular because it is relevant?
- user-the-name 6y agoIf I stole 61 million, I would not be politely asked to pay it back. I would be going to jail for the rest of my life. Who is going to jail for this theft?
- juanani 6y agoYou want to steal 61million as well? Join a corporation. Conform or get stomped.
- kitsune_ 6y agoWhy not both? Many people would still want to be able to tip for good service even if the employees are paid adequately by their employer, and most of those customers expect the employer to not touch that money at all.
- baby 6y agoTragedy of the common, it just doesn't work because then workers expect it.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI find the people US society deems it necessary to tip to for service to be arbitrary and jarring. It’s kind of, sort of people you feel sorry for since they don’t earn much, but only if you interact with them, but even then sometimes not? Janitors and custodians making sure everything is clean? No tip. Person that brings you food? Tip. Nurse/plumber/electrician/Government employee? No tip. Delivery driver? Tip. Grocery/hardware store/department store employee who helps you find what you need? No tip. Person who brings out your online order to your car? Tip. EMT that saves your life, but makes $12 per hour? No tip. The whole thing is insane.
- astura 6y agoDo you tip your doctor? Plumber? Daycare provider? Cashier? Mechanic? Resturant employees when there is counter service? Hotel housekeeper? Physical therapist? Batista? Cook? Walmart greeter? Ferry crew? Person who sold your tickets? Person who checked your ticket? Usher? Travel agent? Real estate agent? Brewery employee? Winery employee? Tour guide? Hardware store employee who makes you a key? Can driver? Medicab driver? City bus driver? Tour bus driver? Shuttle bus driver? Pharmacist? Pharmacy assistant? It's extremely arbitrary which service employees "get" tips and which do not. Not everyone agrees who society "expects" to be tipped. The whole thing is absurd and profoundly unfair.
- monksy 6y agoThere's no obligation to tip. It's not theft. It's only considered to be a loss of money due to the taxman responding to a lack of reporting over tips.