4 ms·
AWS provided multiple times over evidence of violent content that was against their policies and asked Parler to step up moderation, which didn't happen. AWS a
by judge2020 6y ago
AWS provided multiple times over evidence of violent content that was against their policies and asked Parler to step up moderation, which didn't happen.
AWS arguments:
https://twitter.com/KYWeise/status/1349200096345296897?s=20 https://twitter.com/KYWeise/status/1349200096345296897?s=20
> Parler itself has admitted it has a backlog of 26,000 reports of content that violates its (minimal) community standards that it had not yet reviewed
https://twitter.com/KYWeise/status/1349203942614335488?s=20 https://twitter.com/KYWeise/status/1349203942614335488?s=20
> When I said Amazon cited many vile and violent examples of posts that it flagged for Parler, I meant it. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ErlVjN7U0AEr1gt?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ErlVjN7U0AEr1gt?format=jpg&name=... https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ErlVjPBVEAEs9sg?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ErlVjPBVEAEs9sg?format=jpg&name=...
https://twitter.com/KYWeise/status/1349202898459115520?s=20 https://twitter.com/KYWeise/status/1349202898459115520?s=20
> Such a requirement also poses a risk to Amazon itself, with posts calling for others to "burn down Amazon delivery trucks" until they "reverse course."
- echelon 6y agoI wonder whose side the FSF would take. Amazon shouldn't be making these decisions, and certainly not without giving the other party ample time to make other arrangements. This should have been litigated in court prior to taking deplatforming actions. Imagine if Amazon was a Chinese company and Parler hosted information about the plight of the Uyghur people. Community websites have the right to enforce rules. I'm not so sure common carriers do, and AWS is a common carrier. A good rule of thumb for American hosting companies is if the FBI won't seize the website for the content hosted therein, the website shouldn't be removed. For context, I'm a liberal and dislike the content on Parler. Defending free speech is more important than zapping the republicans. Imagine if the tables were flipped and talking about abortion was what conservatives wanted to ban.
- judge2020 6y ago> Amazon shouldn't be making these decisions, and certainly not without giving the other party ample time to make other arrangements Amazon is still working with Parler to export their data off of AWS. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/johnpaczkowski/amazon-parler-aws#126285512:~:text=We%20will%20ensure%20that%20all%20of,we%20can%20to%20help%20your%20migration https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/johnpaczkowski/amazon-p... > We will ensure that all of your data is preserved for you to migrate to your own servers, and will work with you as best as we can to help your migration
- dmix 6y agoTaking the services entirely offline then giving them a few weeks to access archived data does not entirely cover the definition of (at least in my opinion): > not without giving the other party ample time to make other arrangements Going entirely offline like that can easily destroy a web business. Or at a minimum seriously harm them. Not to say I care much for Parler's technical nor administrative approach to providing free speech.
- rodone 6y agoWhy aren't you hosting them?
- echelon 6y agoBecause they're not Amazon.
- bonesss 6y agoParler ignored repeated notices of TOS violations from Amazon, were given a chance to address their frequent TOS violations and incomplete enforcement of TOS violation notices, and came back with a very weak plan while still ignoring specific TOS violations AWS had notified them of. Parler had ample time. They ignored warnings, they did not address their TOS violations. Then their contract was terminated, and AWS is helping them migrate after the fact. Parler displayed an ignorance of the law and how web hosting works. Web companies that repeatedly violate the TOS of their hosts deserve to be at the mercy of their failover plans. That responsibility is borne by the web company, not the host.
- bbreier 6y agoAWS is not a common carrier
- echelon 6y agoAt their size, they sure seem like it. What happens when AWS and Azure design their own silicon, outstrip other hosting providers, and then become the only hosts on the internet? Are they common carriers then?
- tomrod 6y agoNah, anyone can set up a host.
- tolbish 6y agoWhat does "outstrip" even mean? Physically ripping the silicon out from the servers in your garage?
- meheleventyone 6y agoIt means overtake or outcompete. In this case they’re saying that the big cloud hosting providers could end up in a monopoly like position that smaller companies couldn’t compete with if they developed their own superior server tech.
- tolbish 6y agoDon't AWS, GCP, and Azure have the majority of the market already? What would them having their own silicon change?
- meheleventyone 6y agoOh sorry, I’m not defending the point just explaining what outstrip meant in context of it.
- paxys 6y ago
- kickopotomus 6y agoAWS is not a common carrier. They are a hosting company. There are hundreds (thousands?) of hosting companies to choose from and you are not even required to use one to host a website on the Internet. You are free to host your website yourself on your own hardware.
- 8note 6y agoI'd imagine that the FSF would say parler should be using free software for their hosting, so that they can switch to local hosting if they want Their position is usually to not rely on non free software
- ashtonkem 6y agoParler was, by the by. The issue is that their hardware requirements were bonkers, so finding a new host capable of giving them a few hundred servers and dedicated 10G internal network capacity wasn’t trivial.