4 ms·
The Democratic Party has been taking many extreme positions over the past 60 years. Name a single developed country pushing towards legalizing abortion right up
by rayiner 6y ago
The Democratic Party has been taking many extreme positions over the past 60 years. Name a single developed country pushing towards legalizing abortion right up to birth?
- jdub 6y agoAnd the rest of the developed world applauds their attempts to catch up.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoIs there a Democratic Party controlled state that allows this?
- rayiner 6y agoNew York and Massachusetts are getting close: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/abortion-extremism-in-new-york-and-virginia-paved-the-way-for-alabama-and-georgias-laws/2019/05/17/ffad643a-78f0-11e9-bd25-c989555e7766_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/abortion-extremism-i.... Plenty of Democrats believe it should be entirely a medical decision. (You can find a doctor willing to do anything, of course, the 20th century had taught us.) The current status quo of elective abortions to 24 weeks is already extreme. Few countries have generally legalized abortion past the first trimester (absent health, etc.), and less than 30% of Americans support it. (Why the developed world tends to draw the line there is obvious to anyone whose been to an 18 week ultrasound.)
- verall 6y agoAccording to your profile you are an attorney and so I feel you already fully understand this, but red state abortion laws do not make exceptions for the mother's health. They state clearly that after a point in time, the life of the unborn child is to be considered equally valid as the life of the mother. The health of the mother is not considered the first priority. Abortion should be a medical decision. If a doctor is lying about the medical necessity of an abortion, that is illegal and they should lose their medical license and potentially get prison time. Same if they are giving out pills without necessity. Same if an attorney is caught illegally concealing evidence. I don't understand how it is relevant that you can find dirty doctors, lawyers, accountants, etc. Or how the 1900s are related.
- rayiner 6y agoYes, they do make exceptions for the mother's health. For example, here is the recent Alabama law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Life_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Life_Protection_Act > he law provides for exceptions in cases where a fetus has a lethal anomaly (in other words, a medical condition that would cause the fetus to be stillborn or to die shortly following birth) or in cases where a pregnancy would "prevent serious health risk" to the woman.[9] The law also allows abortions to be performed "upon confirmation from a psychiatrist" that a pregnant woman diagnosed with a "serious mental illness" might otherwise take an action that would lead to her own death or to the death of the fetus.[7] The law does not ban procedures to end ectopic pregnancies[10] or procedures in which a dead fetus is removed from the uterus.[7] It does not include an exception in cases of rape or incest.[9] > Abortion should be a medical decision. You're arguing with me on substance, but the point of this thread is talking about what positions are "left" or "right." The idea that abortion should be a purely medical decision--that society should completely delegate to doctors the issue of when it's okay to terminate fetal life--is significantly to the left of where most countries are. Most developed countries recognize a significant state interest in fetal life after the first trimester. They make exceptions for unviable fetuses and maternal health, but don't delegate the decision to doctors completely.
- verall 6y agoIt is fun to cherry-pick the most favorable facts for your argument from a source. This[0] Time article is the [9] from your wikipedia copypasta. It discusses details of 6 pieces of conservative abortion legislation. The Alabama law you link is the only one with a provision to "prevent serious health risk to the mother". The rest all use the much higher bar of "serious risk of the substantial and irreversible impairment of a major bodily function". All ban abortions starting within the first trimester, most at 6 weeks. All but Ohio have no exceptions in the case of rape and incest. Of course I am arguing with you on substance, I am replying to you and your intellectually dishonest arguments regarding abortion. I'm not discussing the upper thread. You are an attorney; this isn't ignorance, it's dishonesty. US abortion laws are not more radical than other developed nations. The WaPo opinion piece you linked is a terrible source[1]. I hate this kind of dishonesty with a passion. If you live in a conservative state in America, getting an abortion is significantly harder than in most other developed countries. Legislation is constantly proposed to try to make it even more difficult. Most developed countries recognize a significant state interest in the human rights of women. Parts of the United States make exceptions. [0]: https://time.com/5591166/state-abortion-laws-explained/ https://time.com/5591166/state-abortion-laws-explained/ [1]: It includes nice goodies, like: > the Guttmacher Institute’s data suggests that “most women seeking later terminations are not doing so for reasons of fetal anomaly or life endangerment.” Just to be clear. When you chase down the study[https://doi.org/10.1363/4521013 https://doi.org/10.1363/4521013], the #1 reason for late abortions is needing to raise funds for the abortion. #2 is not knowing about the pregnancy. > "...a woman’s perhaps fleeting state would be sufficient to end a baby’s potentially viable life" Well, you know, women, they're controlled by their emotions.../s
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Plenty of Democrats believe it should be entirely a medical decision. Abortion being legal up to birth as a medical decision is the norm in the developed world; where there are time limits in the developed world, they are for abortion without medical need (and while most countries do have such limits, Canada, notably, does not.)
- tptacek 6y agoNo, plenty of large European countries have cutoffs after the first trimester. I've been to an 18 week ultrasound and two births, both traumatic (I put a hole in the wall of a bathroom at UCSF after the first), and while we wound up with healthy, happy kids who are the best decisions of our lives, I can't imagine forcing anyone through that experience, and there is pretty much no limitation on abortion I'd actively vote for. Also the notion that people are obtaining abortions like, the day before their due date is just silly. Rayiner, what would an abortion the day before a due date even mean? The other term for that would be "scheduled caesarian".
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Name a single developed country pushing towards legalizing abortion right up to birth? Most of the developed world has abortion legal right up to birth; many countries that do so also have a time limit on when it is available on demand rather than with medical need criteria. But Canada, notably, has no legal restrictions.
- pelliphant 6y ago???????????? As someone from europe, the american democrats are in no way extreme on abortion, I would say they are somewhat centrist, maybe even slightly conservative.
- tptacek 6y agoWe are to the left of Germany, France, Spain, Sweden, and Switzerland. I stopped looking after that, so I don't know if there's a country we're to the right of. (Rayiner is wrong about the "right up to birth thing"; as many have pointed out, even in Europe, where there are often bright-line cutoffs on abortion by pregnancy week, there's still medical abortion after that. So the answer to his "name another" question is "most European countries".)
- rayiner 6y agoBased on what? In the U.S., Roe protects elective abortions (i.e. abortion on demand) up to viability, 20-24 weeks. Almost all European countries ban on-demand abortions after the first trimester (10-14 weeks): https://www.loc.gov/law/help/abortion-legislation/europe.php https://www.loc.gov/law/help/abortion-legislation/europe.php Lots of other issues are tied up in this one. E.g. federal funding of abortions would result in public funding on-demand second trimester abortions that would be illegal in most European countries.
- pelliphant 6y agoAbortion laws in europe isn't decided by our most liberal parties. The first trimester rules you mentioned are usually what everyone can agree on. Example one: In my country (Sweden), a high-ranking party-poard member of our conservative christian party just got into a lot of trouble because it was found out that they had been a member of an anti-abortion organization 10 years ago, and now had to publicly state that they now support the first-trimester abortion rules (Personally, I think it's a lie, but this is what you have to do over here to not ruin your political career, even in the conservative christian party).