6 ms·
I think a common reason behind this (and I've find myself doing this) is that when the most extreme elements of your preferred party do something crazy and outl
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I think a common reason behind this (and I've find myself doing this) is that when the most extreme elements of your preferred party do something crazy and outlandish, you have a tendency to push it aside and think "that's only the fringe of my party", but when you see it on the other side, you think "Anyone who could even think of being on the same side as those nutjobs is evil."
That is, most folks have a tendency to personify themselves with the middle of their party, but personify those in the other party as the extreme of that party.
- neartheplain 6y ago“Too often, we judge other groups by their worst examples, while judging ourselves by our best intentions.” https://time.com/4403510/george-w-bush-speech-dallas-shooting-memorial-service/ https://time.com/4403510/george-w-bush-speech-dallas-shootin...
- dane-pgp 6y ago"Ultimate attribution error is the tendency to internally attribute negative outgroup and positive ingroup behaviour and to externally attribute positive outgroup and negative ingroup behaviour. So in other words, ultimate attribution error arises as a way to explain an outgroup's negative behaviour as flaws in their personality, and to explain an outgroup's positive behaviour as a result of chance or circumstance." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_attribution_error https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_attribution_error
- minikites 6y agoI don't disagree with this in abstract but I think the idea that both sides have extreme elements that are in any way comparable died on January 6th. There's a difference between Bernie Sanders and Marjorie Taylor Greene, but a lot of people don't see it that way because they're uncomfortable being in the same group as Marjorie Taylor Greene. I think the Republicans have a responsibility to address this and I don't think the Democrats are in a similarly dire situation.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoWhy did you select Bernie Sanders as the most extreme person in Congress on the left? Why not Maxine Waters or Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez? Once you can answer that question, you might discover something you weren't expecting in why this divisiveness continues to accelerate.
- minikites 6y agoI think those are fine examples too and I think my comment would be very similar if I substituted one of them for Bernie. I think Bernie has a higher profile than either of those two examples (he ran for president and neither of them did), so it made more sense to me. In retrospect, AOC would have been a better choice since they're both in the House.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoWhose AOC called to execute? https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/04/us/marjorie-taylor-greene-georgia-district.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/04/us/marjorie-taylor-greene...
- jfengel 6y agoUntil four years ago this case might have been arguable. In 2016 it lost any cogency: a fringe candidate took the top job, and they voted for him again in even larger numbers four years later. There is absolutely no fringe candidate on the other side with anywhere near that kind of power. The closest you get is a Presidential candidate who was rejected. The highest office holders an objective observer would identify as "fringe" are Representatives, or perhaps that one Senator. None of them is very powerful. They receive outsized attention in the media, and are pushed by their opponents as having far more power than they do, but no rational person would compare that to electing and then re-electing a conspiracy theorist to the top job -- supported by large numbers of legislators at all levels. We still have to deal with our own internal biases, as you say. But they're entirely insufficient to justify any kind of equivalence. The fringe really does run that party.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoBernie Sanders might well have won the Democratic nomination in 2016, if the party structure hadn't intervened for Hillary. And Bernie wasn't even a Democrat. That's almost exactly symmetric to the Republican situation, except that the Democratic Party had both mechanisms and the will to avoid such an insurgency, and the Republican Party didn't.
- minikites 6y ago>That's almost exactly symmetric to the Republican situation Is it? Do you really think that if Bernie won in 2016 and then lost in 2020 he would call upon his supporters to storm the Capitol?
- mikeyouse 6y agoIt’s just completely ahistorical too. Democratic voters picked HRC over Bernie and then they picked Biden over Bernie 4 years later. There was no conspiracy or “party machinery” involved as much as that pains the Bernie wing of the party. Republican voters overwhelmingly picked Trump - and then turned out millions more in 2020 after they saw what he had done with the Oval Office. Just no remote equivocation between the two parties.
- k4c9x 6y agoUntil you look how each side tends to react when the most extreme elements of their party do something crazy and outlandish. One tends to immediately hold individuals accountable for their crazy actions, the other tends to give them a promotion, unless they think it will hurt their agenda more than help it. Edit: To be clear, by "crazy and outlandish" I mean violent, oppressive, hostile. Not has a "crazy" idea about where tax dollars should be spent.
- telchar 6y agoIf you consider comments and posts from anyone on Twitter or Reddit who claims to support one side or the other, it would seem you have a point. But if you look only at what the elected officials from the two sides say, it's clear that there is a world of difference. That's where the difference lies: one side doesn't tolerate anything like the level of extremism or violent rhetoric from the people they elect compared to the other.
- tstrimple 6y agoYou do realize that Republicans elected a QAnon conspiracy theorist right? Saying it's the fringes on both sides is incredibly disingenuous.
- pelliphant 6y agoBut does that argument really work when one of the extremes got elected president?