3 ms·
> I kinda wonder if they shouldn't charge, say $100 to list an app on the App Store and $50-$100 per update too. Many of these apps that game the App Store gen
by heavyset_go 6y ago
> I kinda wonder if they shouldn't charge, say $100 to list an app on the App Store and $50-$100 per update too.
Many of these apps that game the App Store generate enough revenue that a $100 fee won't be a barrier to entry, but will certainly be a barrier to entry for students, hobbyists, and developers whose apps are pre-revenue.
Most apps don't make more than a few hundred to a few thousand dollars over their entire lifetimes, and such a fee will disincentivize ever pushing feature, stability or security updates to them.
> It's going to cut down on scam apps and pay for enforcement.
The App Store generates billions of dollars of revenue and pays for its own enforcement many times over, it's just that Apple can increase their App Store profits even more through poor enforcement and turning a blind eye to manipulation and scam apps.
What would really benefit users is real competition in the mobile app distribution market. It is obvious that Apple and Google are poor stewards of this space and that competition can improve experiences for consumers and developers.
- snowwrestler 6y agoApple and Google have more resources than just about anyone, and struggle to get this right, even though it is obviously in their interest to do so. I just do not get the idea that adding a bunch of other random app stores is going to somehow make for better user experience or security. An obvious move for scammers would be to flood the alternate app store with fake versions of popular apps in the hope that a bunch of people would accidentally install them. Many users are not sophisticated and a scam only needs a few victims to make money. The alternate app store would struggle to moderate against that, and since Apple has no way to reach in and fix it, they would have to cut off an alternate app store at some point when it gets too bad. And then everyone would lose their minds over that.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Apple and Google have more resources than just about anyone, and struggle to get this right, even though it is obviously in their interest to do so. This sounds a lot like you believe that if Apple or Google fail or refuse to do something, then it can't be done. It's in their interests to pay as little as they possibly need to in order to keep the App Store and Play Store money hoses operating. If there was competition in the mobile app distribution market, then I'd agree that it's in their interests to curate their app stores, because competition would wipe them out otherwise. Unfortunately, Apple and Google have leveraged their duopoly in the mobile operating system market to prevent competitors from competing with them in, and improving, the mobile app distribution market. > An obvious move for scammers would be to flood the alternate app store with fake versions of popular apps in the hope that a bunch of people would accidentally install them. There are dozens of app stores for other computing devices and operating systems where this isn't a problem. Competition means that no user is forced to use a poorly curated mobile app store like they are currently forced to use Apple's poorly curated App Store.
- dzhiurgis 6y ago> What would really benefit users is real competition in the mobile app distribution market. Wouldn’t that be race to the bottom tho?
- heavyset_go 6y agoIt would be a good thing for users and developers, because it would mean that the app stores are using their customers' money as efficiently as possible. I don't particularly care if better efficiency means that Apple and Google are forced to adapt and compete, and as a result, might be less profitable than they were when they held a duopoly in the mobile app distribution market.
- jmull 6y agoThe scammers need to iterate to discover the loopholes, learn how to best exploit them, and to adjust when the platform they are exploiting closes a loophole. A cost per app release drives a stake into the general approach. It doesn’t stop scammers but makes it much harder to do on a larger scale. Meanwhile, legit developers spend hundreds or thousands or more hours on a good app. $100 in the first world just isn’t that much. At the very least the opportunity cost (e.g., the money that could’ve have been made if the time had been spent in a more convention job) easily dwarfs the amount. In lower-income places, then a commensurate amount makes sense.
- ryandrake 6y agoThis would cut off pretty much all free hobbyist-built apps that have no intent to monetize, but actively develop and update. The $100/year Developer Center subscription is bad enough! If I’m releasing once a month, and making zero dollars, $1,300 a year is excessive—I just wouldn’t develop the app in the first place.
- flashgordon 6y agoThis. I literally build apps that are 'utilities' for me and my family+friends. Paying 100 a year for the SDK is a cost of that but bearable. Now having to charge my family+friends just to release updates seems way too excessive!
- heavyset_go 6y agoI maintain several open-source apps for macOS. I don't use macOS anymore, and am not interested in investing in that platform, however users still get value from my apps. Right now, macOS treats those apps as if they're radioactive because I didn't spend the $100/year it costs to notarize the apps. The result is that some users suddenly think the apps they've been using are either broken or malicious. That $100 is already a barrier, if I had to pay more money to release apps at all for Apple devices, I just wouldn't. Which brings me back to my main point: > Many of these apps that game the App Store generate enough revenue that a $100 fee won't be a barrier to entry, but will certainly be a barrier to entry for students, hobbyists, and developers whose apps are pre-revenue. The cost barrier might stop a handful of script kiddies, but it will do nothing to stop the malicious apps bringing in $300k a month in revenue which are both more prolific and widespread. > Meanwhile, legit developers spend hundreds or thousands or more hours on a good app. $100 in the first world just isn’t that much. I don't know what country you're in, but I'm in the US and it's a country where not having $100 can mean not eating, making rent or buying medicine that you need. There are a lot of students, hobbyists and those that are trying to break into the industry who are in this boat. Your proposal would make it hard for them to release an app. There are also people in this country who are either wealthy enough, or their income is high enough, that they wouldn't notice a $100 change in their budget. Your proposal wouldn't affect their ability to release an app, but they would benefit from a lack of competition. In the end, users would suffer from the lack of competition, and people without means would be priced out of participating in the market.