3 ms·
The actual figures are a tested energy density up to 73 Wh/kg – thus about 28 percent of what today's state of the art EV batteries offer So, no, this isn't us
by Animats 6y ago
The actual figures are a tested energy density up to 73 Wh/kg – thus about 28 percent of what today's state of the art EV batteries offer
So, no, this isn't useful for battery electric vehicles. Hybrids, maybe, for vehicles with an underpowered main engine and electric boost for acceleration.
... retaining 90 percent of their initial storage capacity after 10,000 full charge/discharge cycles.
So, not a good power supply filter either. 10,000 cycles of the power line rectified to DC is under a minute and a half.
There are applications for big pulsed power sources, but not that many of them. Flashguns for cameras. Aircraft carrier catapults. Nuclear weapons detonators. Railguns. Big spark generators. Most of the applications that need a huge power spike are military.
- csours 6y agoWhat about holding the charge from regenerative braking?
- m4rtink 6y agoWhat about using this for grid scale energy storage ?
- ksec 6y agoThat was my immediate reaction as well. Even on a cycle per day that is ~27 years for Grid usage while still retaining 90% of capacity. Consider weight and volume isn't a concern for Grid Scale Energy Storage I assume this is a good fit? Not to mention for something like AirPod....... no more throwing them away due to absurd Battery degradation, at the expense or lower connection time.
- nerpderp82 6y ago> So, no, this isn't useful for battery electric vehicles. This is absolutely useful for anything with a high momentary power draw. Even with the quarter of the energy density. These aren't going to supply all the energy, just the peak power. The main pack can be sized for slightly above the average power draw, and it can charge the boost pack that needs to get you up to speed or handle the surge current sink from braking. Who would use a multifarad capacitor for filtering a rectified AC line? Why is this an argument? This isn't a capacitor, it is a battery with capacitor qualities. I feel like the internet was built for arm chair generals to attempt to rain on parades.
- Animats 6y agoThere are already ultracapacitors used for high short term power draws. There's a nice motorcycle prototype which uses ultracapacitors to boost acceleration.[1] The Lamborghini Sian uses the same trick. The article says the energy storage is "mostly capacitive", so it's reasonable to compare this with ultracapacitors. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/billroberson/2019/12/22/nawas-radical-electric-motorcycle-highlights-the-potential-of-supercapacitors-in-evs/?sh=6b936ef72767 https://www.forbes.com/sites/billroberson/2019/12/22/nawas-r...
- nerpderp82 6y agoThese are batteries with capacitor level charge and discharge rates. Even above what Maxwell can supply, these batteries will absolutely buffer high current loads unlike anything we have seen. If these were integrated into exiting lion packs, it would extend life while supplying much higher instantaneous peak currents.
- sterlind 6y agoFor nuclear weapons, do you really need that much power to detonate the TATP? Or are you talking about the kinds of detonators you'd need for pure fusion devices?
- Animats 6y agoNot really. The usual setup is charging up a capacitor and discharging it through a "detonator" which is just a resistor. The resistor explodes and starts the main explosive. This is done to get synchronized detonation of all detonators, which is needed for symmetrical implosion. But that problem was solved in the 1940s and the power supply has been tiny since the 1960s. So it's not a problem that needs solving. This is all on Wikipedia.
- tzs 6y ago> So, not a good power supply filter either. 10,000 cycles of the power line rectified to DC is under a minute and a half. Are batteries involved in this used in such a way that they undergo a full charge/discharge cycles for every cycle of the incoming AC power?