5 ms·
The argument against nuclear is no longer environmental, it's cost. For the price of a kWh of nuclear (20cents), you can get 3 kWh of solar (3x1.5), 2 kWh of
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
The argument against nuclear is no longer environmental, it's cost. For the price of a kWh of nuclear (20cents), you can get 3 kWh of solar (3x1.5), 2 kWh of wind (2x3) and 1 kWh of geothermal (7.5cents), with a few cents left over to upgrade your power lines. And you can get it in a year, rather than in a couple of decades.
- mam2 6y agoIt's cost, BECAUSE environmentalists have slowed down innovation through fear-mongering.. If it was any other industries it would be cheaper.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoYou're probably right, but so what? You can rail against past injustice but nothing you can do will make nuclear power a rational choice in 2021 or beyond. Solar power is cheaper than just the steam turbine in a nuclear plant.
- mam2 6y agoInvesting in it now would make it cheaper on the long term
- pvaldes 6y agoNot to mention that nuclear was used for doing a few very obscene and terrible things that will rank easily among the worst crimes against humanity. If investors suddenly don't want to be linked with your product in any way... well, maybe your product sucks. Burning thousands of people alive isn't good for your brand image and PR. Keep blaming other people for your own bad decisions instead to face the consequences of your acts is what children do. Lets behave as adults.
- projct 6y agothis is like saying gasoline is bad because napalm.
- pvaldes 6y ago> this is like saying gasoline is bad because napalm. A closer metaphor could be trying to build a new market selling napalm as toy cleaner, and blaming housewives for blocking the development of the product. A product that was proven difficult to store, prone to catch fire, staining the wood for three generations and more expensive than the other brands.
- manfredo 6y agoMeasuring intermittent sources by raw price per watt hour is misleading. How much does solar cost at night? Or wind energy on windless days? A lot more because it needs to be stored and retrieved. Shaving 10-20% off fossil fuels with intermittent sources is easy. Actually decarbonizing the energy sector with intermittent sources is much more difficult, since demand and supply do not match up. Contrast Germany and France. The champions of intermittent sources and nuclear energy respectively, and take a look at the CO2 per KWh: https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/daviz/co2-emission-intensity-5 https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/daviz/co2-emission-i...
- canadianfella 6y agoIs geothermal intermittent?
- undefined1 6y agoso let's figure out how to reduce the cost. no doubt it's far more expensive than necessary. solar and wind are great, but they don't run 24/7, need a battery storage solution, and take up a huge amount of land compared to nuclear.
- belorn 6y agoThe video goes through this in great details. When we close down nuclear energy plants we know from history what those replacement power plants are. They are fossil fueled energy plants, mostly coal and oil. If a country can shutdown nuclear plants without adding more coal, oil and natural gas power plants to the grid then more credit to that country. If they can use that cheap solar and wind without a fossil fuel plants then that is what the market should do, but until that is the practical result of dismantling nuclear power plants then we should not continue the practice of replacing nuclear power plants with coal and oil. If that cost more money then it will have to cost more. The single simplest solutions to all this debate over renewable costs is to simply impose a law which say nothing about nuclear or renewables. A simple law that forbids the construction of new fossil fuel power plants or the expansion of new capacity by existing fossil fuel power plants. What about the cost of nuclear? What about the cheaper price of renewable? We don't need the law to mention either. That should be up to the market to decide, because if we forbid the construction of fossil fuel power plants then the ever increasing demand for more energy will trigger market forces to build something, either nuclear or renewable. I am not a nuclear advocate. I simply do not want more coal, oil and natural gas being burned when in the past my country (Sweden) has been pretty good at avoiding burning fossil fuels. When they recently turned of a reaction, a backup oil power plants suddenly found itself commercial viable to run all year round rather than just during the cold winters. I do not want oil in my air, I do not care if oil is cheaper, and I do not want Sweden to go down the path that Germany has with its replacement of nuclear in favor of more fossil fuel plants. There need to be a law, preferable internationally, which say that you can not replace non-nuclear energy capacity with fossil fueled energy capacity.
- throw0101a 6y agoPossible counter argument: nuclear runs 24/7. In the US, data over several years has shown wind available only one-third of the time, and solar available one-quarter: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#Capacity_factors_by_energy_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#Capacity_facto... Nuclear is 90% of the time.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoFrom your article "geothermal resources are generally available all the time" My costs were quoted in kWh, not kW. So that already adjusts for capacity factor. So my comment has 7x the number of kWh of a nuclear solution, but it has 19x (!) the nominal generating capacity. Also remember that part of the reason for the low capacity factor of renewables is over-production, not just under-production. During high wind events, some turbines are feathered because there isn't enough load on the grid to use the energy. Battery storage is cheap. Casey Handmer calculated that it's cheaper to use batteries to store energy locally than it is to build high voltage lines: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2020/12/27/the-future-of-electricity-is-local/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2020/12/27/the-future-of-...