10 ms·
What I've always wondered is - why don't we put a supercapacitor between a an EV battery and the motor? This means that EVs of all kinds, could not only get cr
by m463 6y ago
What I've always wondered is - why don't we put a supercapacitor between a an EV battery and the motor?
This means that EVs of all kinds, could not only get crazy acceleration, but could also recover all the energy of regen. Even battery packs with a very good layout can absorb a fraction of the acceleration energy, and less or none when the battery is cold or at the upper range of capacity.
I remember reading an article about a porsche in a car magazine (many) years ago that discussed not the horsepower for acceleration but also the horsepower absorbed by the brakes to decelerate.
It might have been 500 horsepower to accelerate the car, but since the brakes were very good, it could absorb 900+ horsepower when bringing it to a halt.
- linsomniac 6y agoI've been told that the Tesla Model S is the first car that had a 0-60 time that matched the 60-0. I had one of the Ludicrous models as a loaner a few years ago, and I'd believe it. I could feel the tires hunting for grip during acceleration.
- m463 6y agoBut if you look at the power-meter thing, the acceleration power is many times the regen power http://st.motortrend.ca/uploads/sites/42/2017/02/2017-Tesla-Model-S-P100D-instrument-cluster-02.jpg http://st.motortrend.ca/uploads/sites/42/2017/02/2017-Tesla-...
- linsomniac 6y agoYes, that is absolutely true, regen is only capable of a fraction of the 1,000bhp the electric motors are capable of. This is why the performance Teslas have fancy-schmancy huge ass red brake calipers.
- mikewarot 6y agoI have to believe that tire grip is the limiting factor... the maximum seems to be about 2.3 g The fastest braking from 60-0 is 16 meters (53 feet), according to https://fastestlaps.com/lists/top-quickest-stoppers-60mph https://fastestlaps.com/lists/top-quickest-stoppers-60mph Using the physics calculator at https://www.calculatorsoup.com/calculators/physics/uniformly-accelerated-motion-calculator.php https://www.calculatorsoup.com/calculators/physics/uniformly... This gives a deceleration of 22.5 m/sec^2, or about 2.3 g. I'm amazed it can go above 1 g, actually.
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoIts not that amazing, an alternative perspective is that in nature you have animals which can climb vertical walls, which is equivalent to having a grip that can whitstand 1g?
- colejohnson66 6y agoTangent: why does a car going above 2 Gs feel, for lack of a better word, not scary, but a roller coaster pulling the same feel scary (in an exciting way)?
- jandrese 6y agoI've never tried it, but there are plenty of reaction videos of people doing a ludicrous start in a Tesla and the passengers showing expressions of fear and surprise. If you are the driver then being in control probably helps quite a lot. In a roller coaster you are always a passenger.
- bluGill 6y agoRoller coasters are engineered to feel like they are about to fall apart. There is a reason they creek and shake: they were built to creek and shake. They put in lots of unneeded supports that are made to shake excessively, meanwhile the actually supports are hidden so you don't notice they are doing the real work.
- linsomniac 6y agoThat 53 feet 60-0 is a Ferrari race car, which has aerodynamics that sucks it down to the ground, more than 1g of additional downforce. Often referred to as "they could drive upside down to the roof of a tunnel. Years ago in Denver when they had F1 racing, I remember a news story about preparations the city had to do for the race, which included welding down the manhole covers. Because the amount of suction these cars make would pull the manhole covers off as cars drove over them. Also, traction is more than just friction. There's a mechanical component to it, the scraping off of the rubber from the surface of the tire. Also, as far as the 53 feet goes, remember that this car was extremely light, 1400lbs. The Tesla Model S weighs almost 5Klbs for comparison.
- danans 6y agoI've wondered the same for a while, but the best I can figure is that up to this point the use of super capacitors hasn't been worth the added complexity. Also, the power output of Li-ion batteries has gotten so high that the supercapacitors only offer power benefits for marginal use cases.
- xoa 6y agoI've wondered about hybrid supercap/battery designs as well, but up until recently it's apparently often been easier/better to just go with a bigger battery. String more small cells up together, get more performance and also more absolute energy available (range). That said, while it's a completely and utterly different area, I've actually now experienced my first hybrid using equipment just a few weeks ago and it was pretty interesting: the latest Black Diamond avalanche airbag (JetForce Tour 26L). Avalanche airbags are now quite common safety tools for heavy snow back country or mountaineering, and in an avalanche can help keep a person from being completely buried (or at least keep them much much shallower). Fundamentally, they need to extremely rapidly inflate a significant volume with gas or air on demand, with long term reliability in standby, and while being part of a human portable backpack carrying other stuff and thus as light as feasible. It doesn't take much absolute energy, but inflating in a couple of seconds does take a huge amount of power. The original ones used compressed air or small explosives, which obviously are consumable and present problems traveling by commercial air. They're also harder to test/practice with. Electric fan models came about like 5-6 years ago, but extremely high instantaneous power demands in this application meant big fat lithium ion batteries which are fairly heavy. Fine in a car, not so man portable. The JetForce uses Alpride's E1 supercap design fan. The supercap can be charged off of USB or just a single pair of AA batteries in the field, and can hold charge for a good 2-3 months. It shaves a solid couple of pounds off the previous lithium ion design. Anyway, niche application but it was pretty neat to me anyway to see some real practical gains come about from newer supercap work. I'll be curious if hybrid designs continue to make inroads in other places characterized by sharp power spikes with less overall energy demand.
- numpad0 6y agoEnergy density is 2-3 digits lower for typical EDLC vs Li-ion
- cestith 6y agoWith something that has one quarter the energy density but four or more times the power density, the right place to put it commercially might be between the charging station and the batteries rather than the batteries and the motor. Replace 25% of the batteries with this, charge it in a fraction of the time of the full battery pack, then have it charge the batteries while you're driving down the road. I don't need 5500 horsepower. 390 miles on a really short recharge cycle makes a lot of sense. If one could do both, that might be nice. But cutting charging time while maintaining most of the range makes more sense than having acceleration bursts to the wheels that never make it to the road.
- m463 6y agothat's a cool idea -- put the supercap between the motor and battery, but also attach the charging port to the supercap. It would be a buffered input to the battery no matter where the energy comes from.
- blueblisters 6y agoSorry I don't quite get this - why would you charge the battery with the capacitor while you're driving down the road? Can't you just drain the capacitor and use the energy for driving?
- jsight 6y agoAFAICT, the practical difference isn't that big, the supercapacity energy density is much lower, and it is always more worthwhile to just add more batteries. EVs already use their friction brakes pretty rarely, so the potential gains aren't even that big.
- upofadown 6y agoPerhaps for electric aviation? That is an application where high peak power can make for a takeoff on a shorter runway.
- nerpderp82 6y agoTesla bought the premiere energy storage capacitor company. https://www.maxwell.com/ https://www.maxwell.com/
- gens 6y agoAs others have said, the energy that a supercapacitor can store is practically nothing compared to lipo. And that is by weight, when supercapacitors are less dense then lipo. If you want more power you can just put more batteries in parallel. Or use batteries with lower resistance (the flat ones). As for gathering bursts of energy; Again the problem is energy capacity. The (potential) energy released by braking really hard is really high (per time). You could use a flywheel battery for that. They can take it. They are even used in roller coasters just for that purpose (granted they use big flywheels). Considering people usually break "softly", it is just not worth it.
- Hypx 6y agoFuel cell cars are starting use supercapacitors like this.