I agree this is a tangent. The point that I am failing to make is that even if you and I agree that the Islamic Golden Age was the perfect society, we cannot "p

I agree this is a tangent. The point that I am failing to make is that even if you and I agree that the Islamic Golden Age was the perfect society, we cannot "prove" that, and many people believe it was a terrible society by definition, because they have very different value systems than us.