4 ms·
The GameStop Story You Think You Know Is Wrong
- Pinegulf 6y ago>Robinhood just ran out of money. Really? Then why they restricted buying on _some_ stocks, not all. Must be coincidence.
- valuearb 6y agoBecause the collateral requirements for some stocks are vastly higher than others?
- r3drock 6y agoI think it does not really add up, at least they should have allowed accounts to buy without margin.
- valuearb 6y agoRobinhoods collateral requirements have nothing to do with your accounts margin level.
- ulucs 6y agoEvery possible mainstream news organization coming on r/wsb with hitpieces is totally setting off my alarms. "Don't root for the retail investors, they are rich and only want you for your money! Root for the hedge funds instead!"
- tmotwu 6y agoI'm not really alarmed by the negative perceptions, rather surprised how completely off the mark these takes are, even this one. I think Mark Cuban pointed out how this is a result of the media being lazy rather than nefarious. But this will make me question the News media going forward, not because they might be malicious, but rather how incredibly incompetent they are running stories on such a transparent event. How can we ensure they are diligently reporting on events not as accessible as this?
- ulucs 6y agoSomeone being consistently incompetent in favor of something is a nice reason to throw out the Hanlon's razor.
- lasagnaphil 6y agoI think there is a mixture of both nefariousness and incompetence; one news outlet puts out some misleading information through some shady talk, and then other media websites parrot it without doing any further investigation.
- dfraser992 6y agoI have some amount of sympathy for 'conservatives' now after reading through the lazy and careless reporting about GME. Lots of articles simplifying what is going on, trying to shove it into a 'common sense' or 'conventional wisdom' type of narrative, and just getting the simplest of facts wrong. And the outright propaganda masquerading as 'reporting' - i have seen some things that really ought to have been labeled as opinion pieces in very big block letters. Most "Conservatives" may not be actual conservatives these days, but I get the frustration they have with the MSM that they have been complaining about when even the simplest or basic overview of their position is corrupted thanks to lazy biased journalists... They may be wrong and entirely led by their emotions most of the time (and a lot are now becoming very delusional), but it is gaslighting to deliberately misinterpret someone's emotions or to not and try to understand where they are coming from.
- valuearb 6y agoWhat I’m curious about is whether the SEC is going to sue DeepFuckingValue and require him to disgorge all of his gains. He’s not just a Joe Schmoe on Reddit, he’s a licensed broker with like four active Securities licenses which prohibit publicly pumping a stock exactly like he did. He’s had to sign numerous agreements and passed numerous exams detailing these responsibilities, I don’t understand how he didn’t try to cover his tracks better. Source: https://wallstreetonparade.com/2021/01/gamestop-promoter-keith-gill-was-no-amateur-trader-he-held-sophisticated-trading-licenses-and-worked-in-the-finance-industry/ https://wallstreetonparade.com/2021/01/gamestop-promoter-kei...
- 42_ 6y agoHow did he pump the stock? He only posted his gains and losses over a period of several months.
- valuearb 6y agoThe captions on his YouTube videos stated GME could increase by 10x, while he was an active broker/supervisor at a licensed brokerage and money manager. And “ FINRA has strict rules for licensed brokers regarding use of social media. For example, their rulebook states: “Investors and financial services professionals alike are increasingly using social media for a variety of business purposes. Social Media may be a new medium, but FINRA’s rules on communicating with the public are still applicable. The rules protect investors from false, misleading claims, exaggerated statements, and material omissions…”
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoPlausible deniability? Emphasis on could, which is not an exaggerated statement, nor misleading; it happened.
- valuearb 6y agoDoesn’t matter what happened, it’s exactly the definition of market manipulation the SEC looks for. Again, he’s not you or me, he’s a licensed broker with specific restrictions and responsibilities. “ “Firms must have the ability to supervise the business-related content associated persons are communicating on these sites, including possible suitability determinations if recommendations are made. A registered principal must review prior to use any social media site that an associated person intends to use for business. The principal may only approve a social media site if the principal has determined the associated person can and will comply with applicable rules…” We find it highly unlikely that MassMutual would have approved Gill to post on Reddit’s WallStreetBets, whose users appeared to pride themselves on how frequently they could pack the words f** and b**s into a sentence, frequently with representative artwork. The largest brokerage firms on Wall Street would never allow a Registered Rep to use multiple anonymous user names and promote a $5 stock to a mass public audience because there would be no way to know if it was a suitable investment for the level of risk the individual person could afford to take. The bulk of lawsuits that are brought, and won, against brokerage firms are for “failure to supervise.” Gill’s YouTube videos did offer a scrolling statement at the end to the effect that this was not meant to be personal investment advice. But if it wasn’t, why was he putting it out on a mass medium like YouTube. Gill has another potential problem. According to media reports, Gill was posting copies of his brokerage statements at E-Trade showing his GameStop position making millions of dollars in a short span of time while he was employed at MassMutual. Under FINRA Rule 3210, a licensed broker must first get permission from the broker-dealer where they are employed to open a trading account at another firm. (This is common knowledge among 99 percent of brokers on Wall Street.) If the employing firm grants that permission, the other brokerage firm must send duplicate copies of the broker’s statement to the compliance officer of his current employer. This is to prevent the firm’s name from getting dragged through the mud (as is happening currently to MassMutual) because their broker may have engaged in some form of stock manipulation. It is also to fulfill the broker-dealer’s obligation to supervise their brokers and protect the public.”
- thinkingemote 6y agoIt's amazing that there are so many articles telling us what happened and even Netflix is making a movie, when for everyone on WallStreetBets it's that we are still right in the middle of the chaos. Usually we wait until an event is over to explain it. I know I don't know the story of GameStop. No one does right now.
- raindropm 6y agoIt's their job to write something for a living :p That's why I usually ignore "breaking" or "trending" news, or consume it in very minimal dose. Too many speculation, weird theory, a lot of he/she/they said, and not enough truth or fact. (Also fortunately my job doesn't involve having to follow all those breaking news or else I'd gone mad by now)
- jinkyu 6y agoRH may have ran out of cash but they were still trading all non-meme stocks. how does this author explain that?
- valuearb 6y agoIt’s called DTCC collateral requirements. These are things you should know about if you are going to try to profit from a short squeeze.
- kchr 6y agoThe collateral requirements are way higher for stocks that are heavily shorted, if I understand it all correctly. Meaning RH had to front more money for these stocks to continue allow trading during the 2 day waiting period for executions to fall through.
- finnthehuman 6y agoThis article feels pretty disingenuous in a number of different ways. To avoid posting a wall of text, I'll summarize that The Atlantic is creating a narrative about what the narrative was, that way they can act like serious adults while just feeding us their own narrative. The media was caught on their ass with this story, but never fear The Atlantic is here. With a big dose of Captain Hindsight who knows things that weren't public at the time to trash talk people speaking at the time. To insinuate everyone investing was a dolt that didn't know stocks go down too. And to reassure everybody that the retail investor should never be trusted with anything sharper than a index fund, that there is no takeaway about the market to be found here at all, and we should only worry about pushing politicians for more income redistribution.