3 ms·
> Whereas these crashes can and do occur today, the non-realtime aspect of settlement and clearing mitigates to a large extent. See the 2010 flash crash example
by lmm 6y ago
> Whereas these crashes can and do occur today, the non-realtime aspect of settlement and clearing mitigates to a large extent. See the 2010 flash crash example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_flash_crash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_flash_crash
How so? I'd argue that the SEC policy of breaking "clearly erroneous" trades before settlement exacerbates that kind of flash crash: market-makers can't step in to prop up prices and then hedge their exposure, because their trades will be broken and their hedges won't. If settlement was real-time, preventing flash crashes would be profitable and people would do it.
> Also this feels like a diversion tactic from the implosion of Robinhood of the company from last week's debacle. For those unaware, RH also put limits on AMD stock to be traded - what the heck?!
It's not a diversion, it's a genuine explanation - the collateral requirements were why RH had to impose a bunch of limits.
- paulpan 6y ago> I'd argue that the SEC policy of breaking "clearly erroneous" trades before settlement exacerbates that kind of flash crash: market-makers can't step in to prop up prices and then hedge their exposure, because their trades will be broken and their hedges won't. I'm a bit lost on your response. Are you advocating against SEC or stock exchange intervention? Remember that trading can be halted by stock exchanges also in order to decelerate massive movements. If the settlement happens on even a by-minute increment, then there is no effective recourse for these interventions. Flash crashes are black swan events and as such there's little incentive (as of now) for companies to build safeguards against it. > It's not a diversion, it's a genuine explanation - the collateral requirements were why RH had to impose a bunch of limits. It's an explanation but doesn't explain why other stock brokers didn't impose the same limitations, nor why RH is tapping its credit lines. I say it's a diversion because it's an attempt to deflect blame for its own poor business practices and policies - e.g. if my server can't handle the load, I can't just say "well, if I had a faster load balancer...." to my users.
- lmm 6y ago> Are you advocating against SEC or stock exchange intervention? Remember that trading can be halted by stock exchanges also in order to decelerate massive movements. If the settlement happens on even a by-minute increment, then there is no effective recourse for these interventions. Yes, I'm advocating against them. My position is that SEC and exchange intervention makes flash crashes more rather than less severe. (Also they're harmless; artificially suppressing the volatility of the stock market makes everything more fragile, we'd be better off embracing them and making sure all market participants are equipped to handle volatility. It's like how decades of suppressing forest fires has made forest fires much worse) > It's an explanation but doesn't explain why other stock brokers didn't impose the same limitations, nor why RH is tapping its credit lines. I say it's a diversion because it's an attempt to deflect blame for its own poor business practices and policies - e.g. if my server can't handle the load, I can't just say "well, if I had a faster load balancer...." to my users. If your hosting service suddenly cuts your server capacity down by 2/3, I think it'd be fair to complain about that to your users.
- Reason077 6y ago> "It's an explanation but doesn't explain why other stock brokers didn't impose the same limitations" Other brokers did impose trading restrictions on GME (and other stocks) around the same time as Robinhood. Webull, M1 Finance, Public, and E-Trade all halted buys of GME. Others, including Interactive Brokers, TD Ameritrade, Schwab, and Trading 212 implemented restrictions such as halting options trading and greatly increasing margin requirements.
- ashtonkem 6y agoWebull, M1, and Public all use Apex for clearing, and Apex declared a halt of buying GME; it wasn’t the brokerage’s call. The decisions by IB, TD Ameritrade, and Schwab all seem pretty prudent to me. Reducing client leverage in that situation is the right move.
- ec109685 6y agoAccording to Robinhood, they didn’t want to put limits on anything, it was the cleaning house that made them, so there had to be something that triggered AMD restrictions?
- homero 6y agoDidn't robinhood switch from apex clearing to robinhood clearing over a year ago? They clear themselves.