2 ms·
> This seems to enable a more granular upgrade and system build approach compared to what we have with modern PCs where most core components are stuck on a sing
by skissane 6y ago
> This seems to enable a more granular upgrade and system build approach compared to what we have with modern PCs where most core components are stuck on a single motherboard.
You end up paying for that increased flexibility in a number of ways: greater physical size, increased part count, increased manufacturing costs. I think even if the industry went with CP/M-86/S-100 instead of MS-DOS/ISA, sooner or later people would have put the CPU card and the backplane on the same PCB, and we would have ended up in more or less the same place – the cost advantages of doing so would have made that development inevitable.
> I think I might be interested in a modular, semi-disaggregated PC based on a PCI backplane.
You can buy those, they exist – there are passive PCI backplanes [0] into which you can plug a CPU card. They are used for industrial control applications. You are going to pay a premium for that though. As well as increased number of parts/etc, the lower volumes they are manufactured in adds to the cost.
[0] https://www.advantech.com/products/passive-backplanes/sub_1-2jkogc https://www.advantech.com/products/passive-backplanes/sub_1-...
- tssva 6y agoSome early PC compatibles were based upon the same backplane/card approach as the S-100 computers. I have a Zenith/Heathkit Z-160 transportable in my collection. It has an 8 slot 8-bit ISA backplane and everything including the cpu is on ISA cards. This backplane is shared with the Zenith/Heathkit Z-150 desktop. They also released AT class desktops, by this time the portable PC form factor had become too small to support this approach, which used a 16-bit ISA backplane before eventually abandoning the approach for their later computers. Most likely for all the reasons you point put.