3 ms·
It's interesting to imagine an alternate world of CP/M-86/S-100 vs. MS-DOS/ISA for x86 PCs. The brilliant bit to me is how modular S-100 seems to be with every
by musicale 6y ago
It's interesting to imagine an alternate world of CP/M-86/S-100 vs. MS-DOS/ISA for x86 PCs.
The brilliant bit to me is how modular S-100 seems to be with everything on a swappable card. This seems to enable a more granular upgrade and system build approach compared to what we have with modern PCs where most core components are stuck on a single motherboard.
I think I might be interested in a modular, semi-disaggregated PC based on a PCI backplane.
- skissane 6y ago> This seems to enable a more granular upgrade and system build approach compared to what we have with modern PCs where most core components are stuck on a single motherboard. You end up paying for that increased flexibility in a number of ways: greater physical size, increased part count, increased manufacturing costs. I think even if the industry went with CP/M-86/S-100 instead of MS-DOS/ISA, sooner or later people would have put the CPU card and the backplane on the same PCB, and we would have ended up in more or less the same place – the cost advantages of doing so would have made that development inevitable. > I think I might be interested in a modular, semi-disaggregated PC based on a PCI backplane. You can buy those, they exist – there are passive PCI backplanes [0] into which you can plug a CPU card. They are used for industrial control applications. You are going to pay a premium for that though. As well as increased number of parts/etc, the lower volumes they are manufactured in adds to the cost. [0] https://www.advantech.com/products/passive-backplanes/sub_1-2jkogc https://www.advantech.com/products/passive-backplanes/sub_1-...
- tssva 6y agoSome early PC compatibles were based upon the same backplane/card approach as the S-100 computers. I have a Zenith/Heathkit Z-160 transportable in my collection. It has an 8 slot 8-bit ISA backplane and everything including the cpu is on ISA cards. This backplane is shared with the Zenith/Heathkit Z-150 desktop. They also released AT class desktops, by this time the portable PC form factor had become too small to support this approach, which used a 16-bit ISA backplane before eventually abandoning the approach for their later computers. Most likely for all the reasons you point put.
- analog31 6y agoI was actually doing computer repair when the IBM PC came out. It had a backplane, but most of the system was on the motherboard. Repair people were horrified that many if not most of the logic chips were soldered in, not in sockets like the Apple II. At the time, I had repaired Apple II's, and dumb terminals that had soldered IC's. Half of my time was spent painstakingly de-soldering chips from boards so a replacement chip could (hopefully) solve the problem. On the other hand, most Apple II repairs consisted of what we jokingly called "the laying on of hands," which meant reaching in and pushing all of the chips back into the sockets with the palms of your hands. That was always accompanied by rubbing the gold fingers on the disk controller card with a pencil eraser because the gold plating was inferior. Many Apple II repairs were 5 minutes. Third on the list was power supplies, which we never figured out how to repair at a component level, and were justifiably afraid of. At the time, IBM published some data based on their own years of computer service. They serviced a lot of their own boards, and made their own memory chips. Their data showed that chips were actually more reliable than sockets, so they limited sockets to those which had potential for fallout in production (the 8088), and the memory chips which were an optional add-on. And the ROMs, which could potentially be upgraded.