5 ms·
When you get issued stock options at a company, you immediately become liable for taxes on them, since they are treated as income. This is true even if there is
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
When you get issued stock options at a company, you immediately become liable for taxes on them, since they are treated as income. This is true even if there is no public market for the shares at that time (something that caused headaches for many early dotcom stock option grantees).
It's is an obvious precedent for taxing somebody who has "received" wealth via the route that Bezos has done.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoHow about land? IP? Or a private company? Surely, only people that get issued options aren’t subject to a $1B max.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agono need to set a max. Just set the marginal rate so high that earning (or, if a wealth tax, owning) more than some amount becomes pointless.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoAnd disincentivize people from working? That's not a sustainable economic system. For a properly sustainable system, consider how Islam solved this problem over 1400 years ago. Zakat is the only form of "tax" if you will that is mandated. Interest and other predatory practices are prohibited (e.g. shorting). Once the fundamentals are correct, everything else naturally falls into place. It has been reported that during the rule of Umar II, there were no poor people left in Iraq to accept Zakat (charity) since everyone paid their share. It would be nice to see that happen again, but the modern financial system won't let it happen.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoOne might argue that having $1B of assets (certainly liquid assets) is a fairly major disincentive to working. High marginal tax rates on super-high levels of income and/or wealth doesn't discourage working. It just makes doing something to add another chunk to your income/wealth require something other than financial renumeration. There's plenty of evidence that humans do their best work when they have intrinsic and not extrinsic motivation. Bezos is a case in point. I believe him to have an almost absurdly high level of intrinsic motivation (I worked with him for 15 months). He might like the wealth he has, but the things he will continue to do with his life, just like Amazon itself, get done for reasons beyond money.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoFirst, I really appreciate your response :) > High marginal tax rates on super-high levels of income and/or wealth doesn't discourage working. Do we have precedence for this? From what I'm aware, even when the US had high marginal tax rates which some dems seem to be calling to bring back, no one ever paid those rates because there are always ways for the very rich to reduce their income on paper, while still increasing their wealth. I do agree with you that it takes a very special kind of person to have the wealth of Elon or Bezos and still continue to want to work, it's obviously more than money at that point. But those people are outliers. I know I wouldn't be motivated to spend more effort if it meant a proportional decrease in the total amount of money I would end up pocketing due to increased taxes.
- fossuser 6y agoWorse than disincentivizing people from working, it disincentivizes people from risking money on growth (building companies, doing startups, angel investing). Interest isn’t predatory, it encourages growth and investment in building businesses. Look at the enormous wealth created by capitalism. Economic growth helps the most people the fastest, this model works. That doesn’t mean there shouldn’t be protections on the lower bound and human rights, there should be. It also doesn’t mean there shouldn’t be environmental protections or regulations to effectively coordinate and prevent tragedy of the commons style failures. We should also prevent wealth being able to leverage political power (which isn’t easy).
- gher-shyu3i 6y ago> Interest isn’t predatory It is by the very fact that the lender is owed money in the contract by doing basically nothing. Proper investment balances the risk between parties, so that one party does not have an inherent advantage over the other. This is part of running a moral and just society. > Look at the enormous wealth created by capitalism Red herring. The system is fundamentally unstable, by the very fact that people are on the lookout for the next economic crash because it's built into the system. When that happens, people with money are able to acquire even more assets, increasing the divide. I'm all for people making money, as long as they do it the moral way. Interest is immoral and predatory.
- fossuser 6y agoThe lender is paid for the service of lending money out (which incurs risk). You want to incentivize this behavior. Without interest, it would be harder for people to get loans. Lots of financial services wouldn’t exist (or would demand some other form of payment). This would keep people who aren’t already rich unable to access capital. People react to incentives, good incentives lead to beneficial behavior. Interest is extremely net positive, both for lenders and for borrowers (and society). Everyone wins. Crashes aren’t really built into the system or a fault of capitalism, they happen because problems are hard to predict and the environment changes. The wealth created isn’t only for the rich: https://press.stripe.com/#stubborn-attachments https://press.stripe.com/#stubborn-attachments everyone benefits from economic growth. I think Islamic law (or really any religious framework) has very little of value to say on the topic of morality or running a productive society.
- ibn_khaldun 6y agoAs salaamu alaykum, I enjoy reading your discourses in support of Islaamic economics. Do you have a blog, email or social media account? Wa salaam.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoWa alaikom assalam, Thank you brother. Please feel free to reach out to me at zmadaniia@gmail.com
- selimthegrim 6y agoUmar II is the one Umayyad caliph whose tomb wasn't sacked by the Abbasids when they took power. Would you care to enlighten us as to how this system went so wrong (Hint: it was Arab Muslims accumulating property and wealth over non-Arab Muslims, let alone non-Muslims)
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThe question is how to determine the value of non liquid assets in order to implement a maximum wealth tax. Suppose I own land or a private company or a collection of copyrights that become very valuable. Who and how determines when it crosses the $1B threshold, and how am I brought under said threshold. What if the asset is not easily divisible?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThese are legitimate questions. In some ways they have analogs that have already been "solved" (perhaps not satisfactorily). Who and how determines the property tax you owe on a building or land? But I agree that these are not trivial to answer in satisfactory ways. Societies frequently have to come up with imperfect answers.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI know we can’t expect perfect solutions, but arbitrary blanket statement such as capping wealth at $1B make no sense to me. Wealth (or money) is a proxy for power, and if the goal is to limit one’s power, I don’t see the purpose of an arbitrary dollar amount maximum that is extremely hard and probably litigious enforce to enforce. It would be better to suggest capping the number of companies’ boards one can sit on, or limit the number of non broad market index fund investments one can have, or some other solution that directly attacks the problem of concentration of power.
- creddit 6y ago> When you get issued stock options at a company, you immediately become liable for taxes on them, since they are treated as income. This is false, right? It's only taxable on exercise. That or I know 1,000s of people at major companies that owe back taxes.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoIn the 1990s, I knew dozens of people who faced major financial problems because they immediately owed taxes on options they had just exercised, on shares that were not tradable. These were just regular developers (or in some cases, shipping crew), and they didn't have $50-500k sitting around to cover taxes like that. Maybe the rules have been changed since then? I do know that by the early 2000's there were financial services companies offering wierd loans to help cover the taxes (obviously using the stocks as collateral).
- azinman2 6y agoThis is the difference between RSUs, NSOs, and ISOs. ISOs don't make you pay taxes until you exercise it (a qualifying event), which means you actually took this piece of paper and converted it into tangible value. I'm not sure how they could have exercised it and not had it turn into cash (perhaps their company got acquired and they got options of another non-IPO'd company?).
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoLet's put it like this. The year after I exercised my one and only set of amzn stock options, I owed US$43k in taxes based on their nominal value. The stock was not publically traded at the time, and I had to find savings to cover the tax bill. I retained the piece of paper and started selling later that year after the IPO. At least one other early hire at amzn owed a lot more than this.
- fossuser 6y agoYeah - options are taxed on exercise, not on grant (that’s the dispute with your original comment). Also, you’re taxed on the spread at exercise between the strike price and the fair market value at the time of exercise. If you’re able to exercise when the shares are granted (which early employees can often do by early exercising unvested shares) then there is no spread and there is no tax (at time of exercise, you still pay tax when you eventually sell the shares). Doing this and filing an 83b election with the IRS is important for people joining a startup where they hold lots of equity that’s valued near zero. It’s even a little more complicated than that if you get ISOs since you can exercise some of them tax free until you hit AMT (but AMT has not increased over time so this is less useful than it used to be). NSOs don’t have this ability. RSUs are different and you do get taxed on grant and some are withheld to cover (FB started this and they’re colloquially called FB-style RSUs). This is a relatively recent invention that started because private companies with high valuations had options with strikes too expensive for normal employees to exercise prior to the mandatory ten year expiration. Also old employees who held the option contracts wouldn’t be able to pay the exercise tax on the spread you mention and would hit the 10yr expiration (at which point they need to make a loan shark deal or risk floating a lot of cash). This used to not be an issue because companies didn't stay private this long. With RSUs employees don’t have to worry about any of this, but they lose more on grant to income tax than they could by exercising and holding options optimally. RSUs aren’t strictly better though because if you can exercise options you can hold the stock for 1yr and get long term cap gains which is 15% up to 400k and 20% after. This is a lot more potential upside than just getting hit with income tax. Though in CA you still get hit with a large percentage state income tax on it anyway. (13% after 1M I think). All of the above commentary is unrelated to a wealth tax (or capping net worth) which I think is dumb policy. This grew into a kind of long comment, but if you’re dealing with equity it’s worth learning this stuff for yourself since leveraging equity effectively is probably the best way to actually get wealth in a timeframe shorter than a lifetime of index funds investing.
- PeterStuer 6y agoDepends on the country/jurisdiction. In some places it is upon issue, in some places it is upon exercise or a mix thereof. Sadly over here in Belgium a non trivial tax (18%, but it varies according to some parameters such as runlenght) is due upon issue, turning stock options into a potential substantial risk.